"Do you want me to punish you?" Mike asked and this question made my body shudder with a certain excitement.
No, I know I'm not into stuff like that but the way he asked, his hushed and deep voice with his hot body pressed on mine.
I was compelled to agree to take his punishment, but I didn't want to take on something I couldn't handle, so I shook my head.
"I... I'm sorry." I said. "Please forgive me."
He stared at me, his gaze slowly devouring my vulnerability.
"Don't worry, there's nothing to be worried about. You're mine tonight," he leaned in. "So, for your punishment, you just... Need to enjoy it." His voice sounded gentle, but his eyes...
The spark in his eyes had changed. It was something more fiery. More dangerous.
Was I imagining it?
Maybe I was still a bit tipsy.
"Every sound you make, every place you shiver, I want it all. So, hurry up and open up for me, Bunny." His voice was low, deep, and sensual as he gripped my ass and ground his cock against it. "I want to go in. Won't you let me in?"
Ah, just as I suspected, even the tone of his voice had changed. It was as if he had become a completely different person entirely.
My body shuddered. This feeling... This exhilarating and arousing feeling... He was making me feel so aroused just from the dirty words he was saying and the gaze he had on me.
I didn't know I was a fan of such dirty talk. I hope I don't fall for it too much.
Then, I felt the head of his cock pressed against my entrance, causing me to purse my lips hard, preparing for the impact.
This was it, it was finally going to happen. I was finally going to lose my virginity, I thought to myself with excitement ringing in my head.
And then, as he pressed in, my mouth flew open in a muffled cry,
"M-Mike—ahh!"
He was just putting the tip on but it felt so tight and hurt a bit.
"Ahh—"
My voice was muffled almost immediately as he claimed my lips again, while grinding his hips so the head rubbed back and forth inside me without going deeper. The sensation made me squirm, torn between wanting more and wanting to escape.
It hurt at first but then with this simple movement, it felt at ease.
He probably knew it hurt and that was why he decided to do this. He was so considerate, I thought.
"Ngh," he groaned between our kisses and then said, "Don't stiffen up if not I can't go in more than this." He tried grinding his cock a bit more and I decided to do just that. Though, it wasn't easy. "There, feel how good I fit?"
The slow grind dragged the tip against my inner walls, teasing me, making me clench tighter. I couldn't do it. I couldn't stay relaxed when he was going deeper and rubbing my slippery walls.
He groaned, feeling me clench tighter.
"God, you're hugging me like you don't want me to leave." He said and then tried to reach deeper.
My mouth flew open with a muffled and shocked moan. He... He went deeper.
My legs trembled.
It felt so deep. Was he all the way in?
I couldn't even look down to see as my body was reacting more violently than I expected.
"Oh man, you feel so good, Bunny." He said and I could hear his exhilarating sighs. "So good that I want to go deeper but it suddenly feels like I've hit a wall."
What? My eyes widened. He wasn't all the way in yet?
I barely looked down and discovered he was only halfway in.
My body trembled in disbelief. Ah, I felt so full already, but he was only halfway in? My goodness. What was this?
"Did the guy before me ever reach this far?" He suddenly asked and my heart skipped a beat.
That's right... I had lied that I did it once before but then he found it strange that it felt untouched inside me.
Humiliation flooded me, but I managed to let out a shaky whisper.
"N-no. He... He was small."
Mike chuckled darkly, kissing the corner of my mouth.
"I see. You feel untouched inside, Bunny. Like I'm the first one who really belongs here." He said, and it almost felt like he was sounding me out.
He pushed deeper, inch by inch, trying to break past that wall but my body only tensed up more, trembling as I felt he was trying to pry into an unaccessible area.
I moaned into his shoulder, biting at his skin to keep myself from screaming because it started to hurt at one point again.
Mike hissed, his grip tightening on my waist.
"Fuck… biting me already? You're filthy, Bunny. But..." His lips curled. "I love it. You can bite me as much as you want. Tonight, I'm yours."
He was just saying whatever he wanted to. Was this how he was with his other one-night stands?
He was nice. Too nice.
Mike stayed still, letting me adjust after successfully prying deeper but he wasn't all the way in yet. That, he planned to work on as we continued.
I could feel his cock pulsing inside me. It was huge and it felt like he was going to rip my ass to shreds.
Then his hand slid up my chest, pinching my nipple hard enough to make me jolt.
"Ahhh—!" I cried, my head falling back from the sensation.
"That's it," he said as he smirked, lowering his mouth to suck the other nipple. "This is the right reaction."
I don't like it. I don't like that I've gained yet another sensitive spot. My nipples... Whenever they would run against my shirt from now on, I know I'll be reminded of this night.
I'll be reminded of the sensation he fed me. A cruel and mind-breaking sensation.