Ficool

Chapter 441 - Chapter 441: Emperors at Their Lowest

[Lightscreen]

[The problem of phantom population entries during the Wu Zhou period is a messy one to argue. So, rather than drown you in theory, let's look at a single household registration record from 701.

According to the Dunhuang County Register of Xiaogu Township, compiled in the first year of Dazu, the entry reads:

Fu Han Tuntun died after the register was compiled in the third year of Shengli. His son, Changming, died after the register was compiled in the third year of Shengli. His father, Shi, died after the register was compiled in the second year of Shengli. His mother, Si, died after the register was compiled in the third year of Shengli.

Simple enough. A man named Fu Han Tuntun from Dunhuang had his entire immediate family drop dead shortly after the census. His son, both parents, and eventually the man himself. What a spectacular run of bad luck. The kind that makes you wonder whether the census was cursed or the paperwork was lying.

The record was unearthed from the Mogao Caves, alongside Otani Document 2835, titled "The Household Registration Inspector's Report of the Third Month of the Third Year of Chang'an, with the Dunhuang County Report." That document offers a much better look at what was going wrong with the audit.

It's too long to reproduce in full, so let's focus on the two problems it exposes.

The first was that local officials in Shazhou were less than enthusiastic about cooperating with the inspector.

And the reason for their resistance brings us to the second problem. The inspector demanded that every fleeing household be dragged back to its original registered home.

That, unsurprisingly, did not go over well.

Faced with local resistance, the inspector blamed the whole mess on what he called "seduction by local masters." According to his report, "the common people of Gan, Liang, Gua, and Su all know the fugitives personally, and falsely claim they have land deeds." Put plainly, the locals knew these people, recognized their claims to the land, and were not particularly interested in helping the inspector uproot them.

Think about what that meant in a feudal society.

If someone had become a fleeing household, there was usually a reason. They had not abandoned their registered home for the thrill of becoming an administrative headache. They had left because staying there had become impossible, or at least unbearable.

And if they had managed to establish themselves somewhere new, chances were they had already married, had children, acquired land, and built some semblance of a life. Telling them to abandon all of that and return to a place where they had nothing was not merely unreasonable. It was an invitation to flee all over again.

Now compare this with Li Longji's household registration campaign in the ninth year of Kaiyuan, which history generally treats rather more kindly than A'Wu's.

Under Yuwen Rong, fleeing households were no longer forcibly hauled back to their original registrations. Instead, they were allowed to register where they actually lived. Better yet, they received a five-year exemption from land taxes. During those five years, their only obligation was an annual head tax of fifteen hundred cash.

Imagine that. Rather than treating displaced people like runaway livestock that needed to be herded back into the correct pen, the government gave them a reason to stay put.

And apparently even that was not enough to make the policy permanent. By the sixteenth year of Kaiyuan, Li Longji was still issuing decrees promising that fleeing households willing to settle along the frontier "shall be given fertile land upon arrival, and shall receive lasting tax relief."

Because sometimes, if you actually want people to register themselves, it helps to make the prospect of being registered less terrifying than the alternative. Who knew?]

"This Xuanzong... turns out he isn't quite as..."

Li Shimin shook his head. He understood the later generations' sigh more deeply now. But then he thought better of cursing his own descendants and could only manage a complicated shake of his head.

Empress Zhangsun had fewer reservations. The household registration issue struck her deeply. She had seen too much of it during the chaos. Families dragging their children across a thousand li, searching for a place to survive.

Picture it. They work for years, clear land, build a house, and finally start to see their lives improve. Then an official arrives and says: return to your original home, and we will perhaps exempt you from taxes for a few years.

The thought alone was unbearable.

Beside her, Du Ruhui's interest had shifted back to the Mogao Caves.

From what he had seen so far, the caves had produced maps and documents related to the Guiyi Army, records from the Hexi region, and copies of Buddhist sutras. All kinds of materials.

"I wonder how the Mogao Caves were sealed off," he said. "To preserve paper and silk for a thousand years without decay?"

Fang Xuanling did not believe a word of it.

"Rather than the cave-sealing technique being clever, I would say the later generations' methods of study are remarkable."

He still remembered the mural of Zhang Yichao. If not for the later generations' restoration, he would never have recognized it as the same painting.

"Let me look into it later," he said. "Even if we leave behind only a mottled wall for future generations, it would be better than having nothing but broken bricks."

Du Ruhui was more optimistic. He planned to find an opportunity to visit the temple monks and ask whether such cave-sealing preservation methods existed.

Fang Xuanling nodded, then moved past the subject and pulled together what he had been copying.

"It seems this phantom population problem is mostly connected to the household registration audit."

Shazhou was certainly short on population. Fleeing households would have been more than welcome there.

If those phantom entries were left in the registers, fleeing households might be allowed to take over the associated land temporarily and pay the taxes. That would explain why the local officials of Shazhou were so opposed to the inspector. The frontier had to deal with bandit raids. Population was always a problem.

Looked at from this angle, Yuwen Rong's census also had the effect of striking at the powerful families.

Fang Xuanling thought it over and grew more certain.

If this census were done well, it would strike at the great families, block land annexation, and benefit the common people. The people could rest and recover. The dynasty could endure.

"What if we had the Ministry of Revenue establish a permanent Household Registration Bureau? Send inspectors to the provinces every few years, overhaul the registers, and survey the fields. Could that become a policy that benefits the people?"

During the Wude era, the retired emperor had ordered a household registration effort. But back then it was just a matter of having the provinces report their populations and having the central government review them. Even weaker than the Sui.

Even the Sui census was weaker than this Wu Zhou effort. During the Kaihuang era, they had only sent men like Linghu Xi and Qifu Hui to inspect Hedong and Shandong. Nothing like this Wu Zhou and Xuanzong effort, with inspectors sweeping the whole empire.

Once Fang Xuanling explained, Du Ruhui understood. He even grew excited.

"This inspector travels the realm on behalf of the central government, overseeing the provinces!"

---

Zhuge Liang had also noticed something significant in the household registration inspector. He already had a blueprint in his mind.

Once the realm was settled, appoint regional inspection commissioners with the authority to promote and demote. Use them to clean up officialdom across the empire. Then appoint household registration inspectors to patrol the nine provinces, detecting hidden households and concealed fields.

With such a system in place, how could the people fail to rest and recover?

Pang Tong had been struck by something else. The later generations had praised Wu Zhou's civil governance, saying that A'Wu placed unprecedented emphasis on literary talent.

But look at how the Poet Immortal Li Bai struggled. Look at the ugly spectacle of that petty man Song Zhiwen. Literary talent did not mean administrative talent.

When the Chang'an examinations came up this year, he should advise his lord. The examinations should select capable administrators, not merely men who excelled at elegant writing.

[Lightscreen]

[Beyond all that, Wu Zetian left behind a substantial political mess. The kind that doesn't disappear just because the person responsible has finally left the throne.

To her credit, she did introduce the practice of sealing examination papers. Unfortunately, throughout the Wu Zhou period, the traditional selection system remained the primary method of recruitment. The imperial examinations never got their moment in the spotlight. Revolutionary reform, this was not.

Then there was the awkward little problem of her being a woman claiming the imperial throne in a political world built by and for men. Lacking the legitimacy the Li Tang dynasty could claim, A'Wu leaned heavily on loyalists, promoting them regardless of cost. She needed people she could trust, and she needed them fast. Their job was to weaken the lingering influence of the Li Tang clan at court, preferably before anyone got the bright idea of restoring it.

The result? The selection system began rotting from within. When loyalty matters more than merit, the rot is practically inevitable.

Her early years of enthusiastically playing emperor also came with a hefty price tag. By the middle of the Wu Zhou period, state finances were in serious trouble. Memorials from more than one chancellor complained of "insufficient state funds."

Then came the Khitan rebellion, which dealt a devastating blow to the Wu Zhou army. The Turkic Khan seized the opportunity to join the party, launching a major attack on Hebei while the court was already struggling to contain the damage.

The historical record puts it bluntly:

"The barbarians raided Zhao, Ding, Heng, and Yi prefectures. They took millions in silk, and carried off sons, daughters, sheep, and horses before withdrawing."

So by the late Wu Zhou period, the government was scrambling. State livestock ranches at Deng and Lai. Government purchases of slaves in Jiangling. New checkpoints to tax traveling merchants. Cattle and sheep bought in Hebei.

That last measure drew particular criticism. The government was accused of deliberately suppressing prices and forcing sales, competing with ordinary households for profit. Apparently even the state had decided that squeezing the public was a viable business model.

The treasury was looking less like a functioning institution and more like an empty purse someone had already turned upside down and shaken for loose change.

Even the granaries meant for famine relief had become decorative infrastructure. One account observed:

"Public and private finances were strained. Gradually the relief granaries were tapped for general use. From the Shenlong era of Zhongzong onward, the resources of the empire's relief granaries were nearly exhausted."

Another was less charitable:

"Empress Dowager Wu, the Xiaohe court, Princess Taiping, Wu Sansi, and the disgraced former imperial figure indulged their desires in extravagance... thus agricultural work was wasted and the treasuries were emptied."

From this angle, Li Longji really did inherit a difficult job. He wasn't simply taking over an empire and polishing a few rough edges. He had to clean up after an entire cast of people who had apparently mistaken the imperial treasury for their personal spending account.

Still, calling A'Wu a foolish or incompetent ruler would be going too far.

After all, as we discussed, even Di Renjie advocated strategic retrenchment, urging her to abandon the Western Regions and Liaodong. The argument was hardly frivolous. Maintaining distant territories and defending lengthy frontiers drained resources the state could scarcely afford to waste.

Yet A'Wu refused to surrender the Four Garrisons of Anxi or abandon the defenses along the Hexi-Longyou frontier. Whatever her shortcomings, she understood that an empire's security could not always be reduced to whatever happened to be cheapest that year.

Throughout her reign, Wu Zetian faced a persistent political disadvantage. The absence of a widely accepted legal foundation for a woman occupying the imperial throne made her position vulnerable, and she had to govern while constantly navigating that vulnerability.

Her domestic administration had plenty of flaws, some of them serious. But she was not stumbling blindly from one decision to the next. She had her own principles, her own methods, and a clear determination to keep power in her hands.

The Zizhi Tongjian offered a succinct assessment:

"She used salaries and ranks to win the hearts of the realm. But those who were unfit she soon dismissed, or had punished and executed. She wielded the power of rewards and punishments to govern the realm, with all political decisions ultimately coming from her."

She knew how to attract talent. She also knew when to discard people who failed to meet her standards. Whether one admired her methods or found them ruthless, incompetence was hardly the defining feature.

Old Wu was already sixty-seven when she ascended the throne. At that age, the decline of an emperor's faculties was a real concern, especially when the responsibilities of ruling an empire never politely took a day off. Given the circumstances, she actually performed reasonably well. Anyone who has spent time reading Chinese history knows the bar was never high.

Emperors like Qin Shi Huang and Han Wudi pushed the upper limits of what an ambitious ruler could accomplish. They expanded territory, reshaped institutions, and left behind legacies large enough to keep historians arguing for centuries.

But they were the exceptions.

For every emperor who reached extraordinary heights, there were plenty of others who seemed determined to demonstrate just how low the imperial bar could be dragged. Some turned incompetence into an enduring family tradition.

Take A'Dou, for example. He is practically the poster child for a ruler remembered as ineffectual. Yet even he offers a useful benchmark. Sometimes an emperor didn't need to conquer new territories, revolutionize the bureaucracy, or leave behind a glorious legacy. Simply keeping the administration running in reasonably orderly fashion was enough to put him ahead of a shocking number of his peers.

The bar was that low. Merely managing not to trip over it counted as a political achievement.]

More Chapters