[Lightscreen]
[Ten months after moving to Shangyang Palace, the retired emperor Wu Zetian passed away there.
At the very end, the old woman seemed to have finally let go. She issued the last edict of her life, and its contents were surprisingly simple. She retained the title of Empress Zetian Dasheng while relinquishing the other imperial titles she had accumulated over the years.
The descendants of the Wang and Xiao clans, along with the families of Chu Suiliang and Han Yuan, had all been implicated in the deposition of Empress Wang and Wu Zetian's rise to power. They were granted amnesty. Their past offenses were erased, and they were ordered to resume managing their family affairs.
That incident had been one of the defining political struggles of Emperor Gaozong's reign. It pitted imperial power against ministerial authority, the royal family against the old aristocracy, and centralization against the privileges of the nobility. It shaped the course of imperial politics in China for centuries. More importantly, it was where Wu Zetian's rise began.
In her final act, the retired emperor had done something genuinely commendable. Li Xian might not have remembered these people. Even if he had, he might not have been willing to pardon them.
In the fifth month of the following year, Wu Zetian was buried at Qianling beside Gaozong, taking her place as his empress. Thus ended the life of a woman whose legacy was anything but easy to judge.
A'Wu was gone.
We have spent much of our time discussing the old woman's extravagance. Set aside the glitter for a moment. What was Wu Zhou really like under the rule of a female emperor?
In a nutshell, its civil administration was far stronger than its overall statecraft, while its statecraft was far stronger than its military affairs.
One aspect of A'Wu's reign that deserves praise was her inclusive attitude toward culture. Confucianism, Buddhism, and Taoism all flourished to an unprecedented degree. The recruitment of literary talent advanced beyond what had been achieved during Gaozong's reign. Ironically, it was this emphasis on literary talent that helped produce the great poets of the Kaiyuan era.
However, beneath that flourishing cultural landscape lay several ugly problems that could not be ignored.
Constrained by the legal disadvantages women faced in a feudal society, A'Wu turned to Buddhism to strengthen the legitimacy of her rule. After ascending the throne, she intensified her support for the religion, eventually allowing it to grow into a bloated institution.
The most obvious manifestation was the explosive growth in the number of temples. Under A'Wu's decree, every prefecture and county was required to establish a Dayun Temple to house and preach the Dayun Sutra, which proclaimed her to be the reincarnation of Maitreya.
Establishing Dayun Temples in frontier regions, such as the Four Garrisons of Anxi, genuinely helped spread culture and stabilize the borders. Requiring all three hundred prefectures across the empire to build such temples, however, placed an enormous financial burden on Wu Zhou.
These state-sponsored temples multiplied at an unprecedented rate. Di Renjie, who had returned to the capital and resumed his position as chancellor, laid out the damage in a memorial.
"Extravagant and magnificent, painted and embroidered to the utmost. If this does not burden the people, where else could the money possibly come from? Vast and fertile estates have doubled and tripled in number. There are countless water-powered mills and manors. As for monks of unknown origin, there are tens of thousands of them. In the capital alone, we have already uncovered thousands."
Those lavish temples were not built by ghosts or gods. Ordinary people had to shoulder the costs. Meanwhile, the temples accumulated land, estates, and vast numbers of monks. A single investigation in Luoyang uncovered thousands of monks who were evading taxes. The total number across the empire was beyond imagining.
Alongside the temple economy, another form of prosperity emerged during the Wu Zhou period. The flourishing circulation of bad money in the Jianghuai region.
Throughout the century of prosperity under the Tang dynasty, the contradiction between rapid economic growth and insufficient coin production had never been resolved. Jianghuai was far from the political center, yet its economy was thriving. Bad money had already become a problem during Gaozong's reign. When Gaozong and A'Wu returned from the Fengshan ceremony at Mount Tai and discovered that the treasury was running short of funds, they even debased the currency to profit from its circulation. This only accelerated the spread of bad money.
Once A'Wu gained full control of the government, she made a foolish decision. In an attempt to curb the circulation of bad money, she ordered official coins to be displayed in marketplaces and prohibited the use of any coins that failed to meet the required standards.
The result? Transactions ground to a halt. Trade nearly froze.
A'Wu then issued another decree in an attempt to correct the situation. Under the new rules, bad money that was not excessively poor in quality could still be used. Only the crudest and most severely debased coins were prohibited.
This effectively gave official approval to bad money. Overnight, it went from being a shadow-market commodity to an officially tolerated form of currency. Wealthy households in Jianghuai began minting coins as a side business, flooding the markets with debased currency on an unprecedented scale.
Throughout the Wu Zhou period, bad money circulated everywhere. The resulting market prosperity had little to do with the state's own achievements.
During the Kaiyuan era, Emperor Xuanzong devoted considerable effort to resolving the problem. Even Chancellor Song Jing became entangled in the struggle. Yet the results were minimal. Regardless of how responsibility was divided, A'Wu deserved at least a third of the blame.]
"I understand now," Ma Chao muttered, chewing on a piece of fruit.
He spat the pit onto the floor with the casual aim of a man who had spent his life outdoors.
"Whether that bronze pillar actually made anyone submit, who knows. Probably not. But wasting a million jin of copper on a monument? Now that's something I understand."
He held up his hand, counting on his fingers.
"A million jin. You could arm every soldier from here to Liangzhou with that. Spearheads. Armor. Horse fittings. Bridles. Maybe even a few decent high-pommel saddles for the cavalry." He shook his head. "And they melted it all into a pillar nobody can eat or stab with."
Zhang Fei barked out a laugh.
"Ha! At least the old lady had good taste in statues!"
"Good taste?" Ma Chao turned to him, grinning. "Yide, if that's good taste, then my horse has better taste. At least she knows what to do with a field of grass."
"The problem," Ma Chao continued, "isn't just the waste. It's what happens when a kingdom forgets what actually keeps it alive." He gestured vaguely toward the Lightscreen. "You can build all the pretty monuments you want, but if your soldiers aren't paid, if your horses aren't fed, if your borders aren't guarded, then one day someone with sharper steel and hungrier horses comes knocking."
Zhang Fei nodded vigorously.
"Finally, someone speaking sense! I've been sitting here listening to all this talk about coins and markets and..." He waved his hand dismissively. "What does any of that matter if you can't win a battle?"
Ma Chao laughed.
"Exactly! Give me a thousand good horsemen and I'll take any city you like. Let the merchants argue about copper. I'll argue with a spear."
Across from them, Lu Su had been studying the Lightscreen in silence. He turned from it and noticed Zhuge Liang watching him with a faint smile.
"The five-zhu coins of Jiangdong are gone, aren't they?"
The question was delivered lightly, as though it were idle conversation. Lu Su's heart jumped.
He understood at once. "Good money" meant the opposite of bad money. Coins of regular size with sufficient copper content.
He thought for a moment, then asked in return.
"Do the merchants of Jianghuai take orders from Jiangling?"
Zhuge Liang laughed.
"Zijing, that is hardly a reasonable question. Jiangling can barely control its own merchants, let alone those in Jianghuai."
Lu Su did not argue the point. He pressed on.
"Then how would you stop the spread of bad money?"
For a man steeped in statecraft, the present predicament was the best examination paper in the world. Only by laying out strategy could one prove one's talent. As for the temple problem, Lu Su did not even bother. That was a matter of the ruler's preferences. Once A'Wu was gone, as long as the emperor did not bow to the Buddha, the crisis would solve itself.
Kongming laughed at the question, then rattled off his answer like a man reciting a list.
"To end bad money, you need to reform the bureaucracy, control the copper industry, and expand minting. Only then can bad money be cured. To cure bad money, you must first regulate the border markets, then rectify the capital markets. You also need strict laws. Private copper mining and private minting must carry heavy penalties. Regulate through official markets, let the people's markets self-adjust. When good money is sufficient, bad money will not flourish."
Pang Tong watched Lu Su's astonished expression and smiled.
"Money matters. Kongming and Liu Zichu discussed this at length in Chengdu."
---
In Ganlu Hall, Zhangsun Wuji was making a similar case. His observations were much like Kongming's.
"Therefore, looking to the Sui Emperor Kaihuang's monetary policy as a precedent. To cure bad money, you need strict punishment for the lawless. And you need to open copper mines and expand minting. Also, I believe..."
He paused, choosing his words carefully.
"Our Tang has established granaries for famine relief. If there were a surplus of copper, we might establish a bureau to regulate coinage. When coins are cheap, buy them into the bureau. When coins are expensive, release them into the market."
His voice trailed off. Li Shimin, listening closely, understood why. The idea looked good at first glance. But the details were a mess. In whose name would you buy? In what form would you release? And the biggest problem of all was those four words: "if there were a surplus of copper." Li Shimin smiled bitterly. That was the hardest part.
But speaking of money, he could not help turning his gaze to the large map. The country across the sea from Tang was looking a little more attractive at the moment.
He still remembered clearly what the later generations had said. That place had a silver mountain containing thirty percent of the world's supply.
If there were such rich silver mines, what about copper? What about gold?
His breathing grew heavier. But he pulled his thoughts back and nodded at Zhangsun Wuji.
"Put what you just said in writing. Draft a memorial."
Zhangsun Wuji was overjoyed. He nodded quickly.
[Lightscreen]
[Another obvious problem during the Wu Zhou period was fleeing households.
No need to explain how they came about. Di Renjie already said it. The lavish spending of the Wu Zhou period. "If this does not burden the people, where else could the money possibly come from?"
At the time, commoners faced temples seizing their land and wealthy families using bad money to strip them of their property. Running away was normal.
But fleeing households was a problem throughout the feudal era. The root was land annexation by the rentier class. Without transcending the era itself, there was no solution. So there is no point being harsh on A'Wu here. She failed this test. But failing is better than handing in a blank paper.
The severity of the fleeing household problem and its effects were laid out clearly by Wei Sili in a memorial.
"Today, more than half the registered population has fled. The tax base shrinks. The state lacks funds."
Wealthy landlords annexed land. The self-farming peasants who paid most of the taxes fled. That directly slashed tax revenue. And above, A'Wu kept building. Of course the money was not enough.
So after A'Wu had enjoyed her fill of being emperor, she tried to solve the problem. Starting in 698, she spent five years conducting a census. Historical records call it the household registration audit.
The audit failed on two counts.
First, it was sloppy. People who had been dead for twenty or thirty years were still on the registers. The population numbers were inflated.
Second, all the fleeing households that were discovered were sent back to their original registered homes, regardless of their actual circumstances. That caused even bigger problems.]
