The Argonath rose against the stars like giants frozen mid-stride.
Legolas took the final watch of the night, finding a position on a rock that overlooked both the camp and the river ahead. The ancient statues were visible even in darkness—massive shapes that blocked the stars, their hands raised in warning or benediction depending on how the shadows fell.
Footsteps behind him. Legolas turned to find Aragorn approaching, the Ranger's face drawn with sleeplessness that went beyond simple fatigue.
"You should rest," Legolas said. "Tomorrow will be difficult."
"Rest won't come." Aragorn settled onto a rock nearby, his grey eyes fixed on the statues ahead. "Not tonight."
Silence stretched between them, comfortable in the way that weeks of shared travel had made familiar. But there was something else beneath the silence—a weight that Aragorn carried like a stone against his chest.
"They're my ancestors," Aragorn said finally. "Isildur and Anárion. The kings who founded Gondor, who built an empire from the ruins of Númenor." His voice carried a bitterness that Legolas had never heard before. "The kings who failed."
"Failed?"
"Isildur took the Ring when he should have destroyed it. His weakness is the reason we're here, carrying the same burden across the same lands, trying to finish what should have been finished three thousand years ago." Aragorn's hands clenched. "His blood runs in my veins. His weakness is my inheritance."
Legolas chose his words carefully. "You are not Isildur."
"Am I not?" Aragorn's eyes met his, and the fear there was raw and genuine. "I have felt the Ring's pull. In Rivendell, when it sat on its pedestal. On this journey, when Frodo sleeps near me. The same whispers that corrupted my ancestor speak to me. The same temptation waits."
"You've resisted."
"So far. But the road grows darker. Gondor waits ahead, with all its expectations, all its demands. If I claim the throne—if I become what my heritage says I must become—can I trust myself with that power? Can anyone?"
The question hung in the air, heavier than the stone statues watching from the darkness. Legolas understood the fear Aragorn expressed—had felt similar doubts about his own path, his own potential for corruption.
"I have seen futures," Legolas said slowly. "Not through any power I can easily explain, but through visions that have shown me what might be."
Aragorn's attention sharpened. "What kind of futures?"
"Different possibilities. Different choices leading to different outcomes." Legolas met the Ranger's eyes directly. "In every future worth living, Aragorn—in every path that leads to light instead of shadow—you rise. You claim what is yours. You become the king that Gondor needs."
"How can you have seen—"
"Some questions have answers that would burden you." Legolas held up a hand, forestalling the inquiry he could see forming. "Trust that I believe in you. Trust that the fear you feel about your potential for darkness is itself proof that you will not succumb to it. Isildur didn't fear the Ring—he wanted it. You fear it. That fear is your strength."
Aragorn studied him for a long moment, his ranger's perception probing at edges that Legolas kept carefully guarded. The curiosity was obvious—the desire to understand how an Elf prince could speak of seeing futures with such certainty.
But he didn't press. Some wisdom ran deeper than curiosity.
"You speak in riddles," Aragorn said finally. "Like Gandalf did."
The comparison hurt more than Legolas expected. "I'm no wizard."
"No. But you carry something similar—knowledge that doesn't quite fit the world around you, perspective that sees further than it should." Aragorn's voice softened. "I've watched you since Rivendell. The way you move through events as if you've already lived them. The way you look at people as if you're seeing their futures written on their faces."
He sees too much, Legolas thought. Eventually, he'll see everything.
"Some burdens are meant to be carried alone," Legolas said carefully. "Not because sharing them is wrong, but because the sharing would create new burdens for those who hear."
"That sounds lonely."
"It is." The admission came before Legolas could stop it. "It is the loneliest thing I've ever experienced."
Aragorn was quiet for a time, his eyes returning to the statues on the horizon. When he spoke again, his voice carried something that might have been understanding.
"I don't know what you carry, Legolas of Mirkwood. I don't know what futures you've seen or how you've seen them. But I know this: you've walked beside us through darkness, fought beside us against enemies that could have killed us all. Whatever secrets you keep, they haven't stopped you from being someone I trust with my life."
The words landed with unexpected force. Trust. After all the suspicion, all the careful watching, Aragorn offered trust.
"Thank you," Legolas said quietly.
"Don't thank me." A ghost of a smile crossed Aragorn's face. "Just keep doing what you've been doing. Keep fighting. Keep trying to save Boromir, even if you can't. Keep believing in futures that are worth living, even when the present seems dark."
They sat in silence as dawn crept over the horizon, painting the Argonath in shades of gold and rose. The ancient kings watched them pass, hands raised in gestures that might have been blessing or warning.
Two men carrying secrets they couldn't share, walking toward a future that only one of them could see.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.