The Pillars of the Kings rose from the river like stone giants frozen in eternal guard.
Legolas stared upward as the boats passed between them, his neck craning to take in the impossible scale of the statues. Isildur and Anárion, carved when the world was younger, their features worn by centuries of wind and water but still commanding, still fierce, still proclaiming dominion over a river that had flowed since the world's shaping.
The Fellowship fell silent as they passed through. Even Gimli, usually quick with opinions about Mannish craftsmanship, said nothing. The Argonath demanded silence, demanded awe, demanded acknowledgment of something greater than any individual journey or quest.
Aragorn stood in the bow of his boat, his face turned toward his ancestors with an expression that carried grief and pride and fear in equal measure. This was his heritage—kings who had built an empire, kings who had failed, kings whose blood ran in his veins and whose mistakes haunted every decision he made.
Legacy, Legolas thought, watching the statues slide past. They built monuments that would last forever, and still they fell. Still their choices led to ruin.
The thought led him somewhere unexpected—to Thranduil, to the father whose body he now wore, to the legacy of Legolas Greenleaf that he'd inherited without asking. For sixty years, he'd been building his own monument within that inherited frame. Healing Mirkwood. Learning forgotten magic. Preparing for a war that would determine whether any legacy survived the coming darkness.
And like Isildur, like Anárion, like every king and prince who'd ever tried to shape history—he might fail anyway.
The river widened beyond the Argonath, spreading into a lake that caught the afternoon sun and scattered it in patterns of gold and silver. Ahead, Legolas could see the hills of Amon Hen rising green and dangerous against the sky.
Hours, he thought. We have hours before everything breaks.
The intervention with Boromir had continued through the morning—another conversation at the water's edge, another attempt to strengthen defenses that were already crumbling. Boromir had listened, had seemed to respond, but his eyes kept sliding toward Frodo's pocket with hunger that no amount of talking could overcome.
Some falls cannot be prevented. Some tragedies are written into the fabric of the story itself.
But the knowledge didn't ease the weight of watching someone drown while holding a rope they couldn't see.
Gimli shifted in the bow of their boat, his usually gruff voice softened by the Argonath's passage. "Those were impressive, for Mannish work. Not Dwarvish quality, mind you, but impressive nonetheless."
"High praise from a Dwarf."
"Don't get used to it." But Gimli's tone carried warmth that would have been impossible weeks ago. "What lies ahead? You've been watching the river like you're expecting trouble."
"Amon Hen. The Seat of Seeing." Legolas kept his voice neutral. "A place of power from the ancient days. We'll need to decide our path there—whether to continue toward Mordor or turn toward Minas Tirith."
"And you think trouble waits?"
"I think trouble has been following us since Rivendell. The question is whether it catches us here or somewhere further along."
Gimli grunted acknowledgment, his hand moving to the axe that never left his side. "Then we'll face it together. As we've faced everything else."
Together. The word carried weight that went beyond simple alliance. They'd become something more than companions over the weeks of travel—something that approached friendship in ways neither of them had expected.
"In my father's halls," Legolas said slowly, "there are records of ancient enmity between Elves and Dwarves. Grievances that go back to the First Age, to wars and betrayals and wounds that never healed."
"Aye, my father taught me similar lessons. Never trust an Elf, he said. They'll steal your gold and your secrets and leave you with nothing but pretty words."
"And now?"
Gimli was quiet for a moment, his eyes on the approaching shore. "Now I think fathers don't always know as much as they believe they do. Now I think lessons need to be questioned, not just accepted."
The admission was more than Legolas had expected. More than the canon friendship had ever made explicit—a genuine reconsideration of inherited prejudice, a willingness to see beyond the weight of history.
"My father believed the same things about Dwarves," Legolas offered. "Greed and stubbornness and an inability to see beauty in anything but gold. But I've watched you in Lothlórien, in Moria's depths. I've seen you appreciate craft that wasn't yours, mourn losses that weren't your own."
"What are you saying?"
"I'm saying that when this is over—if we survive—I'd like to show you the forests of my home. And I'd like to see the caves of yours." Legolas let the words settle. "I think we've both learned things our fathers didn't teach us."
Gimli's hand touched his shoulder briefly—the same gesture he'd used after their conversation in Lothlórien, the same silent acknowledgment of connection that words couldn't quite capture.
"I'd like that," the Dwarf said gruffly. "Assuming the world doesn't end first."
"Assuming that."
The boats pulled toward shore as afternoon faded toward evening. Amon Hen's hills rose green before them, innocent-looking despite the violence that was approaching. The Fellowship disembarked, stretching legs cramped from days of paddling, checking weapons that might be needed soon.
Legolas touched the phial from Galadriel, feeling its light pulse against his fingers. Light against shadow. The choice she'd offered, the reminder she'd given. When darkness came—and it was coming, he could feel it pressing against the edges of the moment—he would have to choose.
But first, one final attempt.
Boromir stood apart from the others, staring at the ruins that crowned Amon Hen's summit. His hand rested on his sword hilt, but his eyes—his eyes were fixed on Frodo, who was helping Sam unload supplies from the boats.
Legolas approached him with the weight of failure already pressing on his shoulders.
"We should talk," he said quietly. "One more time, before whatever comes next."
Boromir's attention shifted to him slowly, reluctantly. The hunger in his gaze was stronger than it had been—the Ring's whispers having grown louder over the long river journey, eroding defenses that had never been strong enough.
"What is there to talk about?" The words came out harsh, almost angry. "You've said everything you can say. About Gondor, about my father, about the Ring's lies. I've heard it all."
"And has it helped?"
Silence. Boromir's jaw worked, emotions warring across his features—shame and desperation and something that might have been gratitude, buried beneath everything else.
"I don't know." The admission came like a wound. "I try to remember what you've said. Try to focus on who I am rather than what the Ring offers. But the whispers don't stop. They never stop."
"They won't stop until the Ring is destroyed." Legolas stepped closer, lowering his voice. "But you can choose not to listen. You can choose, every moment, to reject what it offers. That choice is yours. It's the only thing that truly is."
Boromir's eyes met his, and for one moment—one brief, terrible moment—Legolas saw the man he could have been. The hero who might have resisted, who might have fought through the corruption and emerged stronger.
Then the moment passed, and the hunger returned.
"I need to walk," Boromir said abruptly. "Clear my head. Think about... everything."
He walked toward the forest, his steps carrying him the same direction Frodo had wandered.
Legolas watched him go, the weight of knowledge pressing down like a physical force. He knew what was coming. Knew that Boromir would find Frodo alone. Knew that the Ring would speak its final argument, and Boromir would finally break.
And he let him go anyway.
Because the breaking had to happen. Because Frodo needed to flee the Fellowship. Because the story required this tragedy, this failure, this good man consumed by corruption he'd never asked for.
Some falls cannot be prevented. Some sacrifices serve purposes beyond our understanding.
The mantras felt hollow now, standing on the edge of a disaster he'd tried and failed to avert.
Within hours, the Fellowship would break. Boromir would fall. Frodo would flee toward Mordor with only Sam beside him. And Legolas would stand among the wreckage, carrying the knowledge that he'd seen it coming and done everything he could—
Everything except the one thing that might have mattered.
He touched the phial again, feeling its light pulse against the coming darkness.
Choose, Galadriel had said. Light exists in itself; shadow is only its absence.
The choice was coming. For all of them.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.