Kaplan's office had the particular Monday-morning energy of someone who had spent the weekend thinking about something and had arrived at nine AM with conclusions fully formed and ready to deploy. She was at her desk before he knocked, coffee already going, paper marked up in pencil — the Pale Rider chapt er with annotations in three colors.
He set the second cup on her desk.
"The Tricorner precedent in chapt er seven," she said without preamble. "Where did you find it?"
"City zoning records. I was cross-referencing the heritage framework." This was true, though the cross-reference had originally been for the LES hearing rather than the thesis.
She tapped the margin note beside it. "It's a primary source application that three tenure-track historians working this subject have missed. Elijah." She said his name in the specific way of a mentor who had moved from being impressed to being concerned about the gap between the work and the student's apparent estimation of the work. "This chapt er is journal material."
"I know." He sat in the chair across from her desk. "That's what I want to talk about."
The argument for GHQ over the Journal of American Folklore took twelve minutes, and most of that was Kaplan interrogating the reasoning rather than resisting it. She was sharp enough to identify that he was steering rather than recommending, and honest enough to say so.
"You're pushing me toward the faster timeline," she said. "Why?"
"Local credibility first," he said. "The Pale Rider's mythology is Gotham-specific. An international folklore journal publishes something on Gotham's colonial supernatural tradition and it becomes a footnote in someone's bibliography. GHQ publishes it and it's in the Gotham Public Library's local history section within four months. Different reach."
She considered this. He watched her weigh it — the publication credit for her versus the actual thesis goal for him, her version of the thesis goal.
"The GHQ editorial board is thorough," she said. "They'll want supporting evidence beyond the archival documents."
"I have more," he said.
She looked at him.
"I found a physical site," he said. "A colonial-era underground chapel. I found it six weeks ago and didn't mention it because I wasn't sure of its significance until I connected it to the land deed. It has stonework that can be dated to the 1690s, ward-marks consistent with the Pale Rider records, and Ezra Colt's initials carved into the altar stone."
The silence lasted three seconds.
"Where," she said.
"Old Town sub-level. Access through a condemned church on Orchard Street."
She was already reaching for her calendar.
They spent the rest of Monday working through the submission requirements. He built the supporting documents section while she drafted the initial cover letter, both working at adjacent desks in a companionable division of labor that felt, for the first time in eleven weeks, like the graduate school experience he'd technically transmigrated into.
[+40 XP — Knowledge application: Academic publishing strategy. BRE: Thesis-as-infrastructure progressing.]
Tuesday was archive work. Wednesday was revision. Thursday he ran two targeted Pale Rider performances — Bowery west edge again, and a new location in the Narrows where a small cluster of conviction-tier believers had independently gathered based on the Drover Street incident's documentation in the forum.
The website kept running. The decay continued at a reduced rate. He was now losing roughly 2 BP per day instead of 5, which was better and still insufficient.
Level 7 arrived at 11:43 PM on Thursday while he was at his desk drafting the catacomb section of the paper.
Not with fanfare. The system's level notifications had been consistent in their refusal of drama since the beginning — clean, functional, information-only. The overlay pulsed once.
[System Level 6 → 7. +5 Stat Points. Universal Skill Unlocked: Costume Shift.]
He put his pen down.
Five stat points. He'd been thinking about the distribution since the Kaplan conversation and the catacomb plan. VIT. Five into VIT, pushing it from 20 to 25 — the HP and SP gains mattered more than marginal improvements to any other stat given that he was about to go underground twice, once with a civilian who couldn't protect herself.
He spent the points without ceremony and felt the change physically: a marginal settling, the specific quality of a foundation that had gotten slightly more solid.
[VIT: 20.0 → 25.0. HP: 220 → 270. SP: 145 → 170.]
Costume Shift was the unlock that had been coming since the Hernandez couple got a look at his face in October. He pulled it up, read the mechanics, and stood from the desk.
The activation was mental — the same register as toggling Belief Sense or engaging the HUD overlay, but with an immediate physical consequence that the toggles didn't have. The Pale Rider version settled over him the way the persona itself settled: not a costume appearing from nowhere, but the existing clothing — his dark jacket, his jeans — becoming something else in the space between one moment and the next. The wide-brimmed hat that had been under his mattress for three weeks was there, on his head, worn and dust-colored and authentic in a way his thrift-store purchase had never quite managed. The coat length adjusted. The Brand on his right palm brightened.
He caught himself in the darkened window glass. The reflection looked like the paranormal forum photographs. More than that — it looked like what the Pale Rider actually was, rather than what a grad student with a coat and a hat was performing at.
He stood with it for a moment.
The Gray Ghost version was different — softer at the edges, the cloak's attention-slide property more pronounced, the coat the specific gray of old photographs rather than modern fabric. And crucially: the face had a quality he'd been trying to engineer manually since October and had never quite achieved. Not hidden — Costume Shift didn't make him invisible — but nonspecific in the way that legends were nonspecific, the face your brain filled in rather than observed.
The Hernandez problem was solved. He deactivated both and sat back down.
The catacomb section wasn't going to write itself.
He worked until two AM, drafting the discovery narrative as a hiking excursion — "following the directional logic of the colonial settlement records" — and describing the chapel in the precise archaeological terms that Kaplan had been using since the archive find. Each sentence was a brick in a wall the Syndicate's website couldn't knock down because the wall was going to have a peer review committee's name on it.
[+25 XP — Creative counter-strategy: Academic infrastructure building.]
He saved the document at 2:07 AM and set the alarm for six.
The condemned church on Orchard Street had a combination lock. The combination was the construction year — he'd worked it out in October from the stonework's date, a historian's reflex applied to a padlock — and it had opened cleanly then. He'd need to confirm it still held before Saturday.
Saturday morning. Kaplan in the catacombs.
He turned off the desk lamp and thought about all the ways that could go wrong, and counted the things he could control versus the things he couldn't, and fell asleep before he finished the count.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!