The BRE's decay curve looked like a blood pressure reading from someone who had just gotten bad news.
The data was clean enough to be its own kind of demoralizing. He could see the thread structure of his belief network laid across the Gotham heat map: the Bowery nodes in cold blue, the Old Town cluster, the Coventry amber — and running through all of it, the thin grey lines where belief had been three days ago and wasn't anymore.
The Scarecrow evacuation witnesses were the first to go. The Mythbusters piece on Robinson Hall had been calculated in a way that made it hard to dismiss: sympathetic, neuroscience-forward, citing actual fear-toxin research from Gotham General's published case studies. It didn't mock the witnesses. It explained them. "Trauma creates coherent narrative." The piece had found three people who'd been in Robinson Hall that night and filmed their recantations, which were quiet and sad and therefore more credible than a hundred forum posts insisting otherwise.
He had deleted the Gotham Mythbusters bookmark from his browser at 2:14 PM on Wednesday. Not because he was done tracking the damage — the BRE provided better data than the site's traffic did. Because he'd checked it seven times before lunch and the checking itself was becoming a drain in the way that staring at a bleeding wound was a drain: observing didn't stop it.
By Thursday evening the Tier 1 and 2 thread count had dropped roughly 40%. He ran the numbers twice, which was unnecessary, and then stopped running them.
What remained was more instructive than what had left.
[BRE — CURRENT BELIEF DISTRIBUTION: TIER 1: ~310 (-90). TIER 2: ~155 (-25). TIER 3: ~58 (stable). TIER 4: ~28 (stable). TIER 5: 4 (stable).]
Twenty-eight people at Conviction tier. Four at Devoted. That was his actual power base — not four hundred curious forum readers, not the collective attention of people who'd upvoted a thread at midnight. Thirty-two people who had seen something with their own eyes in sufficient proximity that no amount of rational explanation had been able to dislodge it.
He'd known this in the abstract since the drama class gave him 0.3 BP from forty witnesses and an Old Town corner gave him 14 BP from two frightened Falcone dealers — the relationship between quantity of witnesses and quality of belief had never been linear. The math had always favored depth. What he hadn't understood until now was how fragile the wide-base approach was — how a single coherent counter-narrative, well-resourced and patient, could walk through the shallow believers like they weren't there.
The first performance of the counter-strategy was Thursday night.
He ran the Pale Rider through the Bowery's western edge — not the high-traffic blocks where new witnesses would generate new shallow belief, but the specific streets where the Tier 4 cluster was densest. Frank's bar was on Alderman and Sixth. The three blocks around it were home to twelve of his twenty-eight conviction-tier believers. He didn't go inside. He didn't need to perform for them — the BRE's mechanism didn't require the believers to be directly present during a performance. What it required was that the performance happen in a space charged with conviction-quality belief, amplifying the authenticity of everything that occurred there.
Two interventions in forty minutes. One mugging stopped with Dread Presence alone — the mugger took one look and made the correct decision without Elijah touching him. One domestic disturbance where the presence of something not-quite-human at the door made the louder of the two people inside go very quiet very quickly.
[+8 BP. Performance Grade: A. Environmental amplification: +30% (Conviction-dense zone). Net: +10.4.]
The decay was still running. The net gain per night was roughly equivalent to the net loss from the website's continued operation. He was treading water at ~245 BP, and the Pale Rider needed 500 to evolve.
The second night was the Lower East Side — the Drover Street lot from three weeks ago, which the paranormal forum had made into a minor contested site. Three separate posts about the animated bicycle frame and shopping cart. The Mythbusters essay had explained it as staging: theatrical props on fishing line. It was a good explanation. It was also entirely wrong and unprovable as wrong because the residue from Slaughter Swamp's proximity was invisible to the naked eye and undetectable by anything below professional-grade magical instrumentation.
He cleared another residue pocket — genuine, necessary work, the swamp kept bleeding energy into available material along the waterfront — and the BRE logged it: four witnesses on an adjacent fire escape getting a clear line-of-sight on the work. A woman walking her dog who stopped on the sidewalk for thirty seconds. The dog sat down and refused to move until the Rider was out of sight, which was operationally annoying and probably good for the performance grade.
[+9 BP. Performance Grade: A-. Witness count: 5. Conviction tier average: 2.8.]
The website was winning the wide-audience battle. His targeted performances were winning the narrow-conviction battle. He was losing the war because the narrow-conviction tier wasn't where new belief came from — it was where existing belief survived.
He sat on the bus home with the BRE data open and thought about it for twenty minutes without arriving at a productive conclusion, which was unusual. He was good at this kind of analysis. He'd been trained to think about how information moved through systems, how narratives spread, how communities of knowledge built and dissolved. The problem was that all of his tools were operational and none of his tools were institutional.
The Syndicate's website had institutional weight. It looked credible. It cited sources. It had a design budget and a video production budget and, based on the three recanting witnesses, some kind of field operation to find and film cooperative former believers.
He needed something that had institutional weight in the other direction. Something the website couldn't debunk without looking absurd. Something with a citation, a peer review process, a journal header.
He was in the middle of that thought when Kaplan's email arrived.
The subject line was direct in the way of someone who considered subject lines to be a professional courtesy and not an opportunity for enthusiasm: Thesis Chapt er — Submission Discussion.
The body: "The Pale Rider chapt er is the strongest work you've done, and I want to discuss fast-tracking it for journal submission. Monday morning, nine o'clock. My office. Bring coffee."
He put the phone away and watched Gotham's skyline pass the window.
The Syndicate could debunk witnesses, but they couldn't debunk a peer-reviewed paper in a Gotham historical journal with primary source citations, photographic evidence from the archive, and a methodology that would survive academic scrutiny. They could write a counter-piece, but counter-pieces about academic publications read as fringe work and fringe work amplified rather than diminished the original's credibility.
The catacomb chapel. Ezra Colt's altar stone with the initials carved into it. The Dutch ward-marks Kaplan would be able to date to the 1690s by stylistic analysis alone. Physical, tangible, un-doctored-able evidence that the Pale Rider was not a marketing stunt.
He needed to tell her about it.
He'd been sitting on the catacomb discovery since October 22 — three and a half weeks — on the premise that bringing an academic authority figure into a space where he had ongoing mythic operational use was a liability. That math had just changed. The thesis paper was no longer just a cover story with accidental credibility. It was his best counter-weapon against an organized information attack on his belief infrastructure, and the catacomb chapel was the strongest evidence it could contain.
Monday. Coffee. Nine o'clock.
He got off the bus and walked the last four blocks home faster than he'd intended to.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!