Ficool

Chapter 291 - Chapter 291: The Western Spear Withdraws

The withdrawal began with the distinction men made when they still wished to call themselves soldiers: this was not flight, but an orderly movement to another position.

At least, that was what Ronald Tolkien told himself as his men gathered their remaining ammunition, lifted the wounded and began descending the hotel's ruined staircases. The word retreat tasted like ash in his mouth.

Outside, the solitary tank held the boulevard.

Its cannon fired through the smoke, breaking French barricades and tearing open firing positions in the buildings opposite. Dust rolled across the street until the morning light turned grey. The hull machine gun answered movement with short bursts, cutting down men who appeared in windows or attempted to cross the open road.

The armoured trucks contributed what fire they could. One stood crookedly near the alley mouth, its gunner covering the boulevard while wounded soldiers were lifted into the rear compartment. The other had moved closer to the hotel entrance, its engine coughing smoke as the crew shouted for the men inside to hurry.

Above them, aircraft swept through the haze.

Günther had contacted the few German pilots still overhead as soon as Tolkien agreed to withdraw. His radio hissed against his ear while he explained that the forward companies were abandoning their positions and needed the French kept under cover.

Hilary Tolkien heard the request, or perhaps recognised what his brother needed without being told. Either way, his F-1 was the first to descend.

The little fighter dropped through the smoke like a hawk that had lost patience. Its guns raked the French-held buildings opposite the hotel, shattering tiles and knocking brick from chimneys. Blue-coated figures disappeared from the windows. Then Hilary released his last small bomb.

It struck the street beyond a barricade and burst in a dirty flash. The explosion was too small to demolish a block, but it scattered timber, dust and panic through the French position.

Other aircraft followed. With the opposing forces so close together and the streets so confused, they could not attack indiscriminately. Instead, they made brief strafing passes and dropped light bombs into French-held courtyards and approaches, forcing defenders away from their firing positions long enough to give the Germans a few precious minutes.

Dust and smoke spread across the boulevard. Beneath that shifting curtain, Ronald's men began to leave.

The wounded went first. Some were carried; others dragged themselves along with help, cursing the men supporting them when the movement became unbearable. The worst cases were placed inside the armoured trucks. Those able to sit were secured on the tank's rear deck or against its sides with belts and straps.

A handful of soldiers found motorcycles that would still start and brought them snarling to life in the alley. They would go ahead and find a route back. Everyone else would walk, carrying weapons and whatever supplies they could manage.

There were no banners or parade-ground ranks, only men forcing themselves through narrow passages with rifles in their hands and fear close behind.

Ronald descended with the last of the infantry from the upper floors. Before leaving, he glanced through a broken window at the end of the corridor. The Eiffel Tower remained visible beyond the smoke, thin and dark against the distant sky.

It would have to remain there, uncaptured and apparently determined to mock him.

Adolf gave him a light shove between the shoulders.

"Move, poet."

Ronald moved.

On the third floor, Goebbels kept Brunhild firing until Günther gave the signal. His bursts hammered the opposite buildings, punishing any Frenchman who attempted to watch the withdrawal too closely. At last, he lifted the weapon from its position and followed the others downstairs, carrying it across his chest like a beloved but thoroughly unreasonable wife.

Otto and Max were the last to leave the roof.

"French infantry moving through the side streets," Otto reported when they reached Günther.

"Not quickly enough," Max added. "We gave them something to think about. They're being cautious."

"Good. Cautious men live longer, which means they pursue more slowly."

The tank reversed clear of its firing position, then pivoted with a shriek of tracks. The trucks began moving behind it, their gunners watching for shapes in the smoke. Infantry advanced ahead of the vehicles and along their flanks, passing from doorways to alleys and from courtyards into side streets.

It was not a rout. Günther made certain of that. The Suicide Squad moved through the withdrawing troops like black-armoured shepherds, preventing groups from bunching together or losing contact with the vehicles.

Behind them, the French finally realised that the hotel was being abandoned.

For a few moments, confusion held them in place. Men leaned from windows or rose behind barricades, trying to see through the dust. Officers called for pursuit.

Then the French artillery opened fire.

The request had been sent minutes earlier, while the hotel and neighbouring buildings were still pouring German fire into the boulevard. Runners and signalmen had carried the coordinates to the light field batteries General Michel-Joseph Maunoury had brought into Paris under cover of darkness. Most were French 75s, concealed in courtyards, garage entrances and open squares from which they could fire above the rooftops.

The infantry could see the Germans leaving. The gunners could not, and the bombardment could not be halted in time.

Shells screamed over the roofs and struck the row of buildings the Germans had occupied moments before. One hit an upper floor of the hotel, blowing a room into the street in a shower of glass, plaster, curtains and splintered furniture. Another tore open the neighbouring façade. A third detonated lower down, inside what had once been a dining room, sending powdered masonry through the windows.

The shells did not flatten the buildings. They murdered the rooms inside them.

Ronald stopped in the alley and looked back.

Another ten minutes, and the French would not have needed their bayonets. The hotel would have been torn apart around its defenders.

Günther noticed him staring.

"Now you understand. They stopped attacking because they were waiting for their guns."

Ronald said nothing. He had mistaken the lull for fear when it had merely been patience.

The bombardment gave the withdrawing Germans an unexpected advantage. Dust swallowed the boulevard, fragments fell across the road, and French officers shouted for their men to hold position. Pursuit now meant entering their own shellfire, with German machine guns still somewhere inside the haze.

Günther seized the opportunity.

"Move! Use the smoke!"

The column quickened its pace. The tank ground away from the hotel, followed by the truck carrying the most seriously wounded. The second vehicle lingered long enough to cover the rear before joining them. Its gunner continued shouting "What?" whenever an order reached him, hours beside the weapon having reduced most of the world to a persistent ringing.

The three forward companies withdrew through alleys and side streets while shells burst among the buildings behind them. Ahead, motorcycle couriers sped towards the captured forts.

At Fort de l'Est and Fort d'Aubervilliers, the two companies holding the works received their orders with disbelief. They had spent the morning firing French guns into Paris, convinced they were standing at the gates of victory. Now they were being told to abandon everything they had won.

From the higher positions, they could see distant flashes to the northwest, the south and beyond the city's outskirts. Whether these marked French success, British pressure, Belgian movements or German counterattacks, no one could say with confidence.

But the instructions had come through the Eternal Guard. That was enough.

The garrisons prepared to leave with bitter reluctance. Captured guns that could not be moved were spiked or broken, ammunition that could not be carried was ruined, and papers were burned. Useful supplies went onto carts, vehicles and the shoulders of the men. The Imperial flags were lowered last.

Beyond the most exposed approaches to Paris, the two garrisons rejoined the three withdrawing companies. All five formations gathered for Tolkien's reckless venture were together again, bloodied and exhausted, carrying their wounded and accompanied by Günther's squad, one tank, two armoured trucks and a handful of motorcycles.

Behind them, French troops advanced through the smoke to reclaim the abandoned streets.

Günther had no intention of stopping a few blocks away, or even a few kilometres. His immediate objective was the town of Compiègne, nearly eighty kilometres distant, reached by the northern roads and forests. He did not consider even that a final refuge.

The radio had told him enough to recognise what many commanders were only beginning to admit: the German advance in the west was about to recoil.

It had not been defeated by a single decisive blow. It had become too extended, too thinly supported and too poorly informed about the ground behind it.

The Marne had been crossed, Paris entered, and Sens and Troyes threatened. Yet the armies resembled a spear driven too deeply into flesh. Its point remained sharp and deadly, but the shaft was exposed.

The Entente was finding that weakness.

That same day, the British Expeditionary Force struck towards Amiens with infantry and artillery, advancing through countryside where the German occupation was far thinner than its reputation suggested. Belgian formations moved south and west of Compiègne, pressing through villages and road junctions held by scattered detachments.

On the Eastern Front, Oskar's Black Legion had made preparations for precisely such a threat. Small units dug shelters, erected wire, laid mines and traps, observed the approaches and prepared to withdraw in stages. The first defensive belt was intended to establish contact and delay an attack; the second would receive its full weight. Retreat there was meant to follow a design.

In France, no comparable system existed.

The western armies had advanced with too much speed and confidence. Many rear-area garrisons consisted of new conscripts, exhausted supply guards, scattered reservists and clerks issued rifles. Some of their officers had spent the previous evening drinking French wine and eating stolen bread, reassured by reports that Paris was about to fall.

Then the British and Belgians arrived, bringing a less comfortable version of events.

Faced with superior numbers and limited ammunition, many German detachments made the only sensible decision available: they ran.

Some withdrew in order. Others were surrounded and destroyed before they understood that their supposedly quiet village had become part of the front. A few fired several volleys, collected what they could carry and retreated towards stronger formations.

Wagons were abandoned, telephone lines cut and horses lost. Lorries took roads that no longer led to safety. Headquarters maps became less reliable with every report.

General Alexander von Kluck recognised the danger to his northern flank and reacted with the aggression that had carried his First Army so far into France. Troops were redirected north and northwest by rail, truck, horse and forced march. Battalions advancing towards Paris were ordered to turn, batteries changed position, and roads filled with columns attempting to move in conflicting directions.

For several hours, the response worked.

British progress slowed, Belgian formations encountered stronger resistance, and the French Sixth Army found German machine guns still waiting on approaches where it had expected a defeated enemy.

But Kluck's countermeasure carried its own danger. As troops moved north, the gap between his First Army and von Bülow's Second widened.

General Charles Lanrezac's French Fifth Army saw the opening.

Abrasive though he was, Lanrezac remained cautious. His formations entered the gap carefully at first, testing what lay ahead. As the weakness became apparent, their advance accelerated, spreading between the German armies like water through a widening crack.

Suddenly, the attacks towards Melun, Sens and Paris mattered less than the question passing through German headquarters: where was the enemy?

Was he in front of them, on their flanks, between the armies or approaching the supply roads?

Increasingly, the answer was all of those places.

Communications deteriorated. Corps could not locate their neighbours, and divisions received instructions made obsolete during transmission. Supply columns encountered French patrols on roads they had been told were secure. Couriers failed to arrive, telephone lines went dead, and overlapping wireless traffic buried useful information beneath static and competing voices.

German troops continued killing their enemies. That had never been the central problem.

Where Entente infantry advanced too eagerly, machine guns tore through them. Charges broke apart in open fields, leaving bodies scattered between the lines. German artillery, where it could be brought to bear, disrupted French and British attacks before they developed. Aircraft struck exposed columns whenever the weather permitted, while the relatively few tanks and armoured trucks still caused panic wherever they appeared.

Entente soldiers had already learned that courage alone could not overcome armour. Charging it was often little more than suicide performed before witnesses.

Nevertheless, thousands of enemy casualties did not restore the connections between German formations. Local victories could not repair a front that was ceasing to function as a single offensive line.

By evening, rain clouds had gathered over northern France. Distant thunder rolled beneath a sky already darkened by smoke, and the light failed early.

German aircraft returned to their fields one after another, low on fuel and ammunition. As their presence diminished, the Entente moved with greater confidence.

Under failing light and then rain, French, British and Belgian formations approached more closely. Infantry assembled in orchards, villages, railway cuttings and roadside ditches while guns were dragged into new positions. Flares rose through the murk. Orders passed in English, French, Flemish and Walloon, followed by the renewed thunder of artillery.

The attacks continued into the darkness.

Von Bülow was the first to accept what the danger required of the advancing armies. His Second Army was exposed, with a widening gap on its right and increasingly uncertain information about the formations beyond it. During the night, he began withdrawing towards the Marne and beyond, unwilling to risk encirclement for ground that no longer justified the effort of holding it.

Von Kluck resisted longer. His troops had reached Paris. Some had entered its streets. To retreat now felt like surrendering a victory already within his grasp.

The reports left him little choice.

Forward positions were being overrun, his flanks remained under pressure, and enemy troops were cutting into his supply routes. French, British and Belgian units seemed to appear wherever the line was weakest, slipping through gaps faster than headquarters could close them.

If First Army remained too long, it risked being divided into isolated pockets and destroyed.

Kluck began pulling back, reluctantly and with considerable bitterness.

Throughout the tenth of September, Helmuth von Moltke had struggled to assemble these developments into a coherent picture. Reports reached him in fragments: German troops inside Paris, Paris still unconquered, Verdun holding, British attacks, Belgian advances, French formations between the armies, Second Army withdrawing and First Army exposed. Third and Fourth Army reported their own difficulties, while supply officers warned of broken routes and commanders complained of failed communications.

The campaign he had plotted on maps had become a multitude of smaller wars, each demanding attention and obscuring the others.

To discover what was actually happening, he sent Lieutenant Colonel Richard Hentsch west with the authority of the Chief of the General Staff. Hentsch's task was not to ride into battle in search of a cavalryman's glory. He was to reach the army headquarters, examine their positions and, where necessary, speak with Moltke's voice.

That authority included the power to order a withdrawal.

Hentsch first reached Prince Eitel Friedrich's Fifth Army, still engaged against Verdun and the French Third Army. From its headquarters, removed from the immediate firing but surrounded by incoming reports, he began to grasp the condition of the front.

Above all, he grasped how little anyone could establish with certainty.

Maps no longer reflected the positions they purported to show. A courier reported French troops behind the German line, while another insisted the same sector remained secure. Telephone messages and wireless reports placed enemy columns in conflicting locations. Staff officers warned of French movement between First and Second Army, even as commanders elsewhere maintained that their attacks were succeeding, their flanks protected and their neighbours still in place.

Read separately, some of the reports suggested success. Compared with one another, they revealed something darker.

The enemy was not collapsing. It was entering the spaces between the German armies.

The advance had carried formations beyond their ability to maintain contact or sustain themselves. Neighbouring units could no longer be relied upon to occupy neighbouring ground. Supply columns entered dangerous roads, and orders arrived too late to remedy problems that had already moved elsewhere.

Pride could not conceal what that meant.

Further advances might capture villages, kill more Frenchmen and furnish headquarters with heroic accounts. They would not restore a coherent front. Unless the armies withdrew far enough to reconnect and replenish themselves, entire formations could be cut off.

Hentsch was neither a coward nor a fool. Captured farmland mattered less to him than preserving the men who had taken it. He could not wait for perfect clarity, because by the time the situation became undeniable it might no longer be recoverable.

The casualty returns, failed communications and enemy movements supplied enough evidence. The Entente had not been defeated and would not allow Germany to march unopposed into victory.

Acting with Moltke's authority, Hentsch ordered a general withdrawal.

The armies were to fall back beyond the Marne. Behind the Aisne, they could restore contact, establish defensible positions and begin the more difficult work of deciding how the war might actually be won.

Second Army led the movement, First followed with bitter reluctance, and Third and Fourth adjusted their positions in turn. The great German bulge between Paris and Verdun began contracting, not through a universal collapse of discipline, but because remaining in place had become more dangerous than surrendering the ground.

It would take far more than a day to establish the new line.

The withdrawal would extend over days and perhaps weeks, with columns forcing their way through rain and mud, bridges repaired or replaced under pressure and wounded men filling the roads. Lorries would break down, horses die in harness, and rearguards fight through villages while the main formations struggled north.

In places, more than a hundred kilometres of hard-won territory would have to be abandoned.

The armies had not lost their capacity to fight. They had advanced beyond the point at which that capacity could be supplied, directed and brought to bear as a whole.

Oskar had anticipated such a reversal long before his forces approached Paris. It had come later than in the history he remembered, and Germany had advanced farther, even entering the capital itself. The destruction was greater and the Entente's losses heavier, but the underlying result remained familiar.

French determination had been underestimated, along with that of the Entente as a whole. Even the capture of Paris would not necessarily have ended the war. France might have continued from the south, Britain would still have commanded the seas, and Russia would still have sent men forwards in the east.

The war was not a lock that one captured city could open. It was a machine with too many moving parts for a single victory to stop it.

While armies struggled through northern France and the Entente pressed forwards with renewed confidence, the Eastern Front burned with equal fury.

There, too, the Entente forces were advancing.

More Chapters