It wasn't until months later that she finally confided in me that she had childhood trauma that made her freeze during our first sexual experience together. Touching her triggered her and I didn't even know. She told me that she went quiet that night to process everything and I assured her I wouldn't do anything else unless she told me she wanted and asked me to and thats exactly what I did. Aside from that slight hiccup our relationship was fantastic. She was absolutely perfect and my wolf had hoped she was our fated.
When I turned 18 we discovered she wasn't but that didn't matter, we had decided that after she turned 18 if she didn't want to wait for her fated we would tell her we wanted her to be our chosen mate. She eventually told us that she didn't care about meeting her fated mate, that she loved us so much, she chose us as well and would always choose us. My wolf and I were so excited about that, we even told her that once she graduated we would have our mating ceremony, basically what humans would deem as a wedding, and make everything official. We still plan on doing this because it's what she deserves and I can't wait to make her mine in every possible way.
*
About a month after Rhett's graduation party I had ran into Cat at the mall, I was getting some stuff for college since I would be moving there in a few weeks and she was apparently working for one of the kiosks. We chatted and flirted, she kept whispering dirty things in my ear and even my wolf was growling in excitement at what she was offering. I told her what store I would be in and how long I planned to be at the mall that if she got a lunch before I left to come find me so we could talk more and I left the kiosk. Not even 15 minutes later she found me and pulled me into the single bathroom, locked the door and started squeezing me through my jeans to the point I couldn't take it anymore and ordered her to get on her knees. She happily complied and as soon as I had set my dick free she started deep throating me. I wasn't a small guy so I was extremely impressed, especially since it was the one thing my Amy couldn't do. She would try but told me on multiple occasions she didn't like giving me head so it was something she rarely did. After she was done she spit out my seed, telling me she couldn't fully smell like me because Rhett was picking her up from work, but hoped we could do something again soon and then left. Initially I felt bad that I had technically cheated on Amy, I told her that was the one thing I would never do since I knew my ex had cheated on me, but my wolf had told me since she wasn't our fated we should experience a little fun before we fully committed at our mating ceremony. She wouldn't feel any betrayal until after we marked her and we were young males with needs that she couldn't always give us, plus it was a little exciting to sneak around with a she-wolf who was also in a relationship and willing to do a lot of things we knew our future mate wouldn't do so we needed to get it out of our system before next year. Don't get me wrong Amy would try just about anything but if something triggered her then it didn't matter if I liked it because it instantly became a no go. Sometimes it would annoy my wolf and I but we knew we would have to sacrifice every once in a while so why not enjoy now what we can't enjoy later.
The rest of the summer Cat and I would schedule times and places for us to meet up and screw around and other than anal we never actually had sex so I didn't feel to guilty about sneaking around and seeing Amy before or after our little hook ups. We didn't have each other's numbers so there was never any texts or anything to prove I was seeing her on the side. We would just simply plan something when we saw each other in person and then met up later. So when Cat originally texted me I was a little worried that it could cause problems with Amy. Luckily she didn't even question me when I said it was the guys even after seeing Cat hanging on me after the game and our little make out session during spin the bottle. I knew she was pissed about both of those things, her wolf was even more angry after seeing us kiss. I could tell after I went looking for her she was close to shifting so when she told me she needed a minute I knew it was best to let her cool off. It made my wolf a little on edge to know they were both angry so when she found us at the fire he demanded we nuzzle her and breathe her in, it calmed not only us but her wolf down too. We left shortly afterwards and again I had to show her how much she meant to us. The next morning I picked her up to spend more time together and I just couldn't keep my hands off her, I knew I had to really prove that she was mine and I wanted every inch of her. Yeah I may have been messing around with Cat but I didn't love her, I loved Amy and wanted to make sure she never doubted my love. I took her over and over again until I was satisfied she knew that. After we got dressed we started watching a movie and Cat kept texting me, letting me know all the things she wanted to do to me and what she was willing to let me do to her. Even though I was pretty satisfied after taking my mate multiple times the ideas she was saying sounded too tempting. After the movie was over I decided to tell Amy I was going to hang with the guys since I would have to leave to go back to school the next day at some point, it wasn't anything new to her so she didn't even question it. We kissed after I dropped her off then I went to the meeting spot Cat said to pick her up at. Soon we were at a secluded beach barely anyone knew about. Cat brought a blanket and as soon as we laid it down she was all over me doing exactly everything she said she would. After a couple hours of pleasure we were just laying on the beach, we didn't even bother to get dressed and before I knew it Cat started rubbing my cock and got me hard again. I laid there with my eyes closed knowing she would probably just suck me off again since we had an understanding. However I felt her rolling a condom on so I just figured she wanted me to take her ass, but before I could get up to take it, I felt another type of warmth and opened my eyes. Cat had positioned herself above me and then impaled herself on my cock and for a brief second I was pissed but the moment she rotated her hips I didn't care any longer. it was already too late so I just reached up and palmed her breast and let her take what she wanted. After a little while my wolf got impatient and took over. He pushed her off, made her get on her knees, tore off the condom and impaled her again from behind and right before we were about to come he told that she-wolf that he was claiming her with his scent. I knew he was starting to get possessive, it's just how wolves are, which was another reason we never took her pussy, I knew if we did he would want his scent stronger on her. She struggled but he wouldn't let her go.
She was pissed claiming we ruined everything but honestly we didn't care. She crossed the line first so my wolf only found it fair that he claimed her too, he would never mark her but he wanted others to know she was now his. We got dressed and left about 10 minutes later. Cat wouldn't talk to me as I drover her back to where I picked her up but honestly I didn't care, I preferred when she didn't talk. I just dropped her off, told her I would tell her the next time I was in town and then drove away.