Ficool

Chapter 1195 - Chapter 1196: The Unseasoned Spider-Man, Tempered by Trial

"You're really nothing like I was back then. I definitely didn't carry myself with this kind of poise—you've got the self-assurance of someone possessed by an alien symbiote," Tobey-Spidey remarked with a hint of amazement as he looked at Peter Parker.

"Are you calling me?" Before Tobey's words even faded, a pitch-black, inky liquid lifeform suddenly surged into view, forming a black, dome-shaped head as it waved at Tobey, grinning. "So, another version of you encountered another version of me, huh? We really are fated to meet!"

"Venom?!" Tobey-Spidey exclaimed in shock, instantly tensing up. In his experience, Venom was definitely a bad guy. When he'd been possessed by the symbiote, he had done all kinds of awful things—flirting, cringey dancing, demanding a raise. That wasn't who Tobey was—it was like a villainous, edgelord version of himself!

"You really seem to have a prejudice against Venom," Peter Parker said as he watched Tobey react, lifting his hands with a sigh. "Relax, Venom's actually a good guy."

"A good guy?" Tobey's voice spiked an octave. He didn't buy it for a second. Venom had definitely messed with his mind—why else would he have done things he never dared to before?

"Anyway, now's probably not the time to debate that. I can promise Venom won't cause trouble. Right now, I've got a few questions…" Peter waved his hand, steering the conversation away. "How exactly did I get transported here from my universe? And who among you is the Spider-Man of this universe?"

"This isn't my universe," Tobey said first. "I was just walking along and suddenly a ring of fire opened in front of me—next thing I knew, I was here."

"Not mine either," said Andrew-Spidey. "I was doing my usual patrol when the scenery around me changed. Then I heard someone calling for Peter Parker. I followed the fire ring—that guy summoned me." He pointed to Ned.

"Huh?" Peter blinked and looked at Ned. "Your magical ability's that advanced? I came straight here from my universe—I thought Kamar-Taj was calling me for something…"

"Who's Kamar-Taj?" Tobey asked.

"You mean what is Kamar-Taj," Andrew-Spidey corrected him.

"Kamar-Taj is where that portal magic comes from. But in our universe, you," Peter gestured at Ned, "aren't part of Kamar-Taj. So how did they end up here if they weren't summoned directly?"

"Don't ask me! I don't know anything!" Ned shrank back nervously. "We lost contact with our Peter, and he had just gotten the Sling Ring from the Sorcerer Supreme… I just tried it out. I didn't expect to summon you…"

"Sorcerer Supreme? What's that?" Andrew asked, confused.

"Maybe it's more like who is the Sorcerer Supreme?" Tobey revised thoughtfully. "Sounds like the leader of Kamar-Taj."

"Who's your universe's Sorcerer Supreme? The Ancient One? Doom? Or Constantine?" Peter asked, knowing far more than the other two Spider-Men.

"Huh?" Ned paled at the question. He barely understood the supernatural side of things. All he could say was that their Sorcerer Supreme was a guy called Doctor Strange. He also mentioned the recent chaos with villains from other universes arriving.

From Ned's scattered explanation, Peter pieced together the recent events.

In this universe, Spider-Man had encountered a villain named Mysterio, who specialized in high-tech illusions—combining movie special effects, hypnosis, drones, and robot doubles to deceive people.

After the "Endgame" battle where Iron Man snapped his fingers and died, this Spider-Man, having lost his mentor, was left aimless. That's when Mysterio appeared, claiming to be a hero from another universe.

Despite his experience, Spider-Man was still fooled by Mysterio's performance. Following his manipulation, Spider-Man handed over Tony Stark's legacy—a pair of glasses with the advanced AI "E.D.I.T.H."—to Mysterio.

With Stark tech and the AI at his disposal, Mysterio became much stronger. Eventually, Spider-Man saw through him and fought a hard battle, ultimately defeating him. Mysterio tried to kill him in the end, but accidentally shot himself.

That should have been the end, but Mysterio had one last trick. Footage of their final confrontation was leaked and edited—framing Mysterio as a hero hunted by Spider-Man, and revealing Peter Parker's true identity to the world.

The fallout was catastrophic. Not only did Peter's reputation collapse, but his real name was now public, drawing intense criticism and even harassment to his home.

His friends, Ned and MJ, also suffered—being denied college admissions due to their association with him.

With no one left to turn to, Peter sought out Doctor Strange, hoping he could cast a spell to make people forget he was Spider-Man.

It could've been a simple fix—just erase the memory of the altered video. But neither Peter nor Strange considered that. Peter kept modifying the spell so that MJ and Ned would still remember him, disrupting Strange's casting and triggering a multiversal breakdown.

That attracted villains from other universes who knew Spider-Man's identity—including Tobey and Andrew's foes—as well as the two other Spider-Men themselves.

Peter, however, had been summoned by accident—likely because the fabric of the multiverse was already damaged and Ned had no real magical training, just raw instinct with the Sling Ring. If he were skilled, he would've summoned his own Peter back by now.

As for why their universe's Peter hadn't reappeared—it was simple. After facing so many villains known to his counterparts, Peter was overcome by compassion.

The Avengers might not have a strict no-kill rule, but Spider-Man leaned toward one. Even Mysterio hadn't died by his hand.

Initially, Peter had helped Strange capture the intruding villains. But when he learned that sending them back meant death, Peter's heart wavered.

He believed these were good people corrupted by circumstance—and that they could be saved. Rather than send them back to die, he wanted to cure them.

His mindset was naive, perhaps too idealistic, failing to respect the paths others had walked.

Not all villains want redemption. Some are irredeemable. And though their backstories might elicit sympathy, their actions remain inexcusable.

Despite battling villains, fighting in Civil War, and twice confronting Thanos, this universe's Spider-Man was still a child—unseasoned, unaware of the true nature of human evil.

Even after Mysterio manipulated him, wrecked his life, and exposed his identity, Peter hadn't learned. He stole the Macchina di Kadavus—a device sealing the unstable spell—and took Strange's Sling Ring, using clever tricks and spider-sense to evade the Sorcerer Supreme in his own Mirror Dimension.

Peter then took the villains back to his home, intending to invent cures to revert them to normal.

But not all villains wanted to lose their powers or darker sides. Ultimately, Norman Osborn—the Green Goblin from Tobey's world—manipulated the others into rebellion.

They broke free, and in a tragic twist, the Green Goblin killed Aunt May with a pumpkin bomb, right in front of Peter.

This shook Peter to his core. Despite everything, he had still tried to help—and it had cost him his last family member.

Before dying, May uttered the iconic truth: "With great power comes great responsibility."

Maybe this would change Peter's heart. Maybe not.

What was certain was that Peter was drowning in guilt. He knew if he hadn't meddled, if he hadn't pressured Strange to cast the spell, May would still be alive.

But there's no going back. There's no magic to undo loss. Magic couldn't bring back Iron Man, and it wouldn't bring back Aunt May.

So Peter disappeared, choosing solitude—explaining why Ned and MJ couldn't reach him.

Perhaps it was the resonance of the spider-sense across universes, but Tobey, Andrew, and Peter (our Peter) eventually felt where he was and brought Ned and MJ to him.

When they found him, he was bloodied and despondent. MJ embraced him, trying to comfort him. Ned followed suit, wrapping his pudgy arms around him, while the three Spider-Men stood on a nearby platform, silently watching the scene.

"Hmm?!" Suddenly, Peter's eyes narrowed—his spider-sense flared. He stood up protectively, shielding MJ and Ned behind him, ready to fight.

The three Spider-Men leapt down from the platform, prompting Peter to raise his hand to stop them. "Wait! Wait!" he called out.

Tobey and Andrew quickly raised their hands in surrender. Tobey spoke first, gently: "I'm sorry… about May. I really am."

He apologized sincerely—because the Green Goblin was his villain, from his universe. Tobey had once defeated him after a brutal battle, and the Goblin had ultimately died when his own glider impaled him during a sneak attack.

Tobey knew what kind of monster Osborn could become—utterly deranged, evil to the core. But within him was another man: Norman Osborn, the uncle of Tobey's best friend Harry. They once had a good relationship.

"Please accept my condolences. I understand, more or less, what you're going through," Andrew added softly, walking toward Peter with sadness in his eyes.

"No, no, no!" Peter's voice was raw with pain and suspicion. "Don't talk like you understand me! She's dead—because of me! I let her die! I never should've… never should've done any of this…"

"If I hadn't been so stubborn, if I hadn't tried to help them… If only I'd listened to Doctor Strange… No! I'm going to do what he said now!"

"I'm sending you all—and those guys from your universes—back! They're your responsibility, not mine! Whether they die or you kill them—it doesn't matter to me anymore! I'm done!"

"I'm sorry for dragging you into this… but you all need to go back. Good luck."

Say what you will, but this Spider-Man was kind-hearted to a fault. Even now, drowning in grief and rage, he was trying to hold himself back, suppressing the explosion building inside. He even apologized to Tobey and the others…

More Chapters