We Were Beautiful Until We Broke
Cassandra Carter enters Crestwood High seeking nothing more than a quiet, ordinary life, despite coming from a powerful and protective family. Reserved, observant, and emotionally guarded, she navigates new friendships, academic pressure, and subtle romance alongside her brothers—Anthony, the steady protector, and Michael, the passionate defender.
Her world shifts when Lucas Hale, a transfer student from Eastwood High, becomes part of her everyday orbit. Their connection grows slowly, marked by shared silence, mutual understanding, and moments that feel more significant than declarations. Unknown to Cassandra, Lucas’s past is unresolved—tethered to people and choices he believes he has escaped.
As Crestwood life unfolds—exams, competitions, friendships, and breaks—new transfer students arrive, bringing buried histories with them. Old loyalties resurface. Boundaries are tested. Cassandra’s steady world begins to fracture quietly.
At graduation, just as Cassandra gathers the courage to choose love fully, she discovers Lucas in an intimate moment with a girl from his past—the very reason he fled Eastwood. The betrayal shatters her first love and etches his name permanently into her memory.
Years later, in the professional world, fate reunites them—not as teenagers, but as adults shaped by loss, ambition, and restraint. This time, Cassandra does not fall easily but, Lucas falls harder.