[Lightscreen]
[We all learned a saying in school: "Objective laws do not bend to human will."
But what exactly are objective laws?
Take Wu Zetian's little project of changing the Tang dynasty's name, for example. For the sake of appearances, she had the Wanxiang Divine Palace and Heaven built not once, but twice. Then there was the Tianshu bronze pillar, which swallowed tens of billions in construction costs. Add the Dayun Temples, grand Buddhist assemblies, conveniently manufactured auspicious omens, the Feng Shan ceremony at Mount Song, and the countless other projects that came with the whole production.
Every single one of them cost money. A truly spectacular amount of money.
And let's be clear. During the Wu Zhou period, the population wasn't exploding, and there certainly wasn't an Industrial Revolution.
The old lady lived in splendid luxury while the common people struggled to survive, cursing their miserable lot. That was the objective reality.
Wu Zetian wanted to attain immortality through supernatural spectacles that could neither advance technology nor manufacture armies, let alone build spaceships. That was human will.
As for the results? Well, I think we can all guess how that turned out.
Just as Wu Zetian was thoroughly enjoying herself, changing era names and handing out amnesties like holiday discounts, alarming news arrived from the north.
The Khitan had rebelled!
The court's first reaction was disbelief.
Of all the northern tribes, the Khitan had never been particularly ambitious. They weren't exactly known for dreaming of conquering the world or picking fights with every dynasty that crossed their path.
During the Northern Qi, their limited strength had left them at Gao Yang's mercy. When the Turks rose to prominence during the Sui dynasty, the Khitan found themselves caught between the Turks and the Sui, getting beaten up by both sides like a punching bag nobody wanted to take responsibility for.
It was only during the Tang dynasty that things began to improve. When the Khitan chieftain learned that Emperor Erfeng intended to deal with Jieli Khan, he promptly submitted to the Tang, accepted the imperial surname Li, and was invested as the Khitan Khan.
From the second year of Zhenguan until the present, the Khitan had followed the Tang dynasty's lead for sixty-eight years.
Sixty-eight years!
And now they were rebelling?
What on earth had gone wrong?
The sequence of events was actually quite straightforward. It all began with natural disasters.
In 695 and 696, while the old lady was busy changing era names at every opportunity, hailstorms struck the prefectures east of Luoyang in the second lunar month. The people were already anxious enough as it was.
Then, in the sixth month, right in the middle of summer, frost fell across Jiangdong. Agricultural production took a severe hit.
By the time the new year arrived, the common people were facing spring famine and a devastating drought.
Just imagine the situation. With crops failing and food becoming increasingly scarce, the only thing ordinary people could count on was the government's distribution of relief grain.
The Khitan were in the same predicament.
Now, you would think that a senior official responsible for governing the frontier would possess at least a basic understanding of politics.
Nobody expects you to suddenly transform every tribal community into a harmonious society where everyone treats everyone else as equals. That might be asking a little too much.
But surely, at the very least, you should know how to manage the people under your jurisdiction and put their strength to good use, right?
Unfortunately, Zhao Wenhui, the Wu Zhou Grand Protector of the Eastern Yi, apparently missed that particular lesson.
From the moment he assumed office under Wu Zetian's orders, he treated the surrounding minority peoples like household servants. They were expected to obey, not complain.
And when famine struck?
His attitude remained exactly the same.
The starving people wailed for help, but Zhao Wenhui couldn't have cared less. He simply issued a strict order forbidding the opening of the granaries for famine relief.
Apparently, in his administration, starving to death was preferable to inconveniencing the authorities.
Under these circumstances, the era name Wansui Tongtian was adopted. And its first major historical event was hardly auspicious.
Li Jinzhong, commander of Songmo, joined forces with his elder cousin Sun Wanrong and raised an army against Wu Zhou. They killed Zhao Wenhui, captured Yingzhou, and advanced to lay siege to Tanzhou.
After confirming that the rebellion was real, the old lady made preparations on two fronts.
First, she appointed Yan Zhiwei as chief envoy and dispatched him to the Turks with a proposal for an alliance.
The message was simple enough.
I accept your marriage proposal. As long as we join forces against the Khitan, we're still one big happy family.
There was, however, one tiny problem.
The Turkic Khan had originally wanted to marry Wu Zetian's daughter. At the very least, he would have been willing to accept the old lady herself as his sworn mother. Either arrangement would have established a meaningful bond between the two sides.
Instead, Yan Zhiwei arrived carrying a rather different proposal.
On Wu Zetian's orders, he brought along Wu Yanxiu, the son of Wu Chengsi, to marry the Turkic Khan's daughter.
The Khan was furious.
What kind of marriage alliance is this? First, you want my daughter to marry into your family. Then you send over one of your own clansmen and expect me to accept it? At this rate, will the entire Turkic nation end up bearing the surname Wu in another generation?
The negotiations promptly fell apart.
Some of the envoys were imprisoned. Some were killed. Others surrendered and ended up trapped among the Turks.
So much for the diplomatic solution.
With foreign assistance out of the question, Wu Zhou had no choice but to handle the rebellion alone.
It took two years and two military campaigns before the Yingzhou rebellion was finally suppressed.
During the first campaign, a member of the Wu clan led tens of thousands of troops into battle. The result was a catastrophic defeat that wiped out his entire force.
The second campaign was considerably more successful. Yang Xuanji and Zhang Jiujie jointly commanded an army of two hundred thousand and eventually crushed the rebellion.
If Xue Rengui's defeat at Dafeichuan marked the end of the early Tang dynasty's aura of invincibility, then the Yingzhou rebellion was an ominous sign that the prosperous High Tang era would eventually begin to decline.
And the consequences didn't stop there.
After the fall of Goguryeo, much of its population was scattered and relocated throughout Tang territory. The Mohe people were settled in Yingzhou.
When chaos erupted there, Mohe leaders Da Zuorong and Qiqi Zhongxiang seized the opportunity to lead their followers eastward across the Liao River, returning to their ancestral homeland.
Along the way, the Mohe and Khitan even joined forces to inflict a crushing defeat on Tang troops at Tianmen Ridge.
From that point onward, the Bohai Kingdom emerged as an independent power.
In the following years, Bohai skillfully maneuvered among the various powers of Liaodong and the Korean Peninsula. Over more than a decade, it fought the Tang in upwards of thirteen major engagements, including battles at Dengzhou, Madu Mountain, and Bohai itself.
One border crisis followed another, each pressing closer to the heart of the empire.
Eventually, Emperor Xuanzong adopted the strategy of using barbarians to control barbarians.
And that, ladies and gentlemen, was how An Lushan finally entered the picture.
Oh, and there was one more interesting detail concerning Yan Zhiwei himself.
Among the envoys sent on that mission, Yan Zhiwei proved weak and indecisive, completely losing his nerve when things went wrong. Wu Yanxiu, meanwhile, simply dropped to his knees.
Only the deputy envoy, Pei Huaigu, remained steadfast. He refused to surrender and would rather die than betray his country.
Yet to the Turkic Khan, neither Wu Yanxiu nor Pei Huaigu was particularly valuable.
The man he truly wanted was Yan Zhiwei.
Why?
Because Yan Zhiwei was the grandson of Yan Lide, and he himself enjoyed considerable prestige at the Tang court. Forcing such a prominent official to surrender would send a powerful message and might encourage other Tang officials to defect.
So the Khan compelled Yan Zhiwei to submit and bestowed upon him the title of Khan of the South, hoping to use him as bait to attract more defectors.
When word of the incident reached the Wu Zhou court, Wu Zetian responded with her customary efficiency.
The entire Yan clan was wiped out.
Only two Yan relatives who had married into the Wu family managed to survive.
Later, when the fighting subsided, Yan Zhiwei returned to Wu Zhou.
His reward for returning?
Execution by dismemberment, with chariots tearing his limbs apart.
Wu Zetian then ordered the assembled officials to shoot arrows into his corpse. After that, his flesh was stripped away, his bones were crushed, and the extermination of his entire clan to the third degree was carried out.
A truly magnificent display of imperial mercy.
As for Wu Yanxiu, things turned out rather differently.
After returning to Wu Zhou, he was rewarded with the title Duke of Heng.
He continued to enjoy his position until Li Longji beheaded him at Suzhang Gate during the Tanglong Coup.]
A brush clattered against the floor. Every head in Ganlu Hall turned.
Yan Lide was already bending down to retrieve it.
The man who usually wore an easy, untroubled smile as head of the Directorate of Palace Construction now looked as though someone had suddenly pulled the floor out from under him.
And who could blame him?
Yan Lide was only thirty-five years old. His eldest son hadn't even reached his coming-of-age ceremony yet.
He was still looking forward to watching his descendants grow up and build their own futures. Who could possibly have anticipated learning, out of nowhere, that his grandson would suffer such a gruesome fate, and that his entire clan to the third degree would be exterminated along with him?
Those last three words struck harder than any report from a battlefield.
Even Yan Lide, a man normally blessed with an enviable amount of optimism, was left speechless.
Li Shimin hesitated.
Then, after catching an encouraging glance from Empress Zhangsun, he finally tried to offer some comfort.
"Lide..."
Yan Lide shook his head.
"Your Majesty need not say another word. From this day forward, the Yan family will have nothing more to do with government service."
There.
No need for Li Shimin to continue. Yan Lide had already drawn his line in the sand.
The Yan family was officially done playing this game.
And honestly, who could blame them?
Painting, mathematics, engineering, any one of those fields could keep a person studying for decades before they mastered even a fraction of what was involved. Yet despite all that effort, serving the imperial family could apparently end with one's descendants being torn apart by chariots and the entire clan dragged into the grave with them.
And that wasn't even considering whether future generations would prove capable enough to carry the family legacy forward.
When you looked at it that way, the solution was obvious.
Why enter government service at all?
Why gamble your family's future on a career that could turn into a death sentence simply because some ruler woke up in a bad mood?
Better to stay away from the palace, pursue your own interests, and live long enough to enjoy the fruits of your labor.
A perfectly reasonable decision.
Unfortunately, that simple declaration left Li Shimin sitting in silence for quite some time.
Du Ruhui sighed inwardly.
Thank heavens the Yan family is only interested in architecture and painting.
And thank heavens the emperor in question was His Majesty himself. Under a different ruler, words spoken in a moment of frustration like those might well have earned the entire family a visit from the imperial executioner.
Before Du Ruhui could step forward to ease the tension, however, Zhangsun Wuji, who had been unusually quiet for some time, rose from his seat.
"What Director Yan resents, and what later generations will condemn, is ultimately the system of laws and decrees established under Wu Zhou."
His expression remained calm and composed.
Inside his sleeves, however, his hands were clenched tightly together, and his palms were slick with sweat.
Standing in Ganlu Hall, Zhangsun Wuji was absolutely unwilling to leave the future of the Zhangsun family entirely in the hands of the empress.
But with the future already laid out before them, a return to political office was no longer something he could take for granted.
He had spent a great deal of time thinking about the lessons revealed by later generations.
And he had reached a conclusion.
In the Zhenguan court, his presence didn't make an irreplaceable difference. Remove him, and the empire would continue to function. Keep him, and things would still function just as well.
That was the uncomfortable truth.
If he wanted to fulfill his lifelong ambitions, he needed to become someone the court simply could not do without.
So what was Zhangsun Wuji's greatest strength?
He possessed a certain grasp of both civil and military affairs, certainly. But his real expertise lay in the law.
And he had spent days carefully considering how to turn that expertise into an opportunity.
Now, at last, the moment had arrived.
"From what we have learned about later generations, without a ruler, there can be no imperial relatives. Without nobles, there can be no privileged class standing beyond the reach of the law."
He paused briefly before continuing.
"So how, then, does one establish order among the people? After giving the matter considerable thought, I believe the answer lies in four words that later generations used almost casually when assessing Zhuge Liang's handling of Marquis Wu's affairs."
His voice grew firmer.
Govern the state according to law.
Li Shimin listened attentively.
As Zhangsun Wuji spoke, the image of Ma Su's execution flashed through his mind. Then he thought of Yan Zhiwei's brutal punishment, followed by Wu Yanxiu receiving honors and a noble title for his trouble.
Placed side by side, the contrast was almost absurd.
One man had been executed for his failure. Another had been rewarded despite his disgraceful conduct. And somewhere in between, an entire family had paid the ultimate price for an official's decision to surrender.
The irony practically wrote itself.
Considering the attitudes of later generations toward Confucianism, along with the broad-minded tone they seemed to favor, Li Shimin had already begun to understand where Zhangsun Wuji was heading.
The others were no fools, either.
Within moments, several pairs of eyes turned toward Zhangsun Wuji.
Is he really going that far?
At the very center of everyone's attention, Zhangsun Wuji continued to face forward, his expression solemn and his voice full of conviction.
"Han Fei once said that the strength or weakness of a state depends upon the strength or weakness of those who uphold its laws."
"I would argue that the true strength of those who enforce the law lies in one question. Can the law refuse to bow before the powerful?"
"When Wei Yang governed Qin, he declared that the law could not be effective if those in high positions were allowed to violate it with impunity. He therefore punished Prince Qian and Gongsun Jia. As a result, the people of Qin came to obey the state's decrees."
"Our Tang dynasty is still relatively young. We possess the Wude Code, but it is little more than a derivative of the Kaihuang Code."
"Emperor Yang followed that same legal tradition, and yet he lost his empire."
He drew a breath before continuing.
"If Your Majesty wishes to accomplish achievements unparalleled in history, then we must establish a legal code capable of governing the people across generations, one that can stand the test of time rather than merely imitate the past."
"I respectfully request permission to compile the Zhenguan legal code. To consolidate the principles of Zhenguan, extend their authority, clarify their provisions, and establish their virtues for generations to come."
Having finished his proposal, Zhangsun Wuji bowed calmly.
He raised both hands above his head and waited for the emperor's verdict.
As for the expressions on Wei Zheng's and the other officials' faces, Zhangsun Wuji didn't need to turn around to imagine them.
They were probably less than pleased.
After all, at its core, Confucianism emphasized ritual and moral cultivation rather than the supremacy of written law. What Zhangsun Wuji had proposed touched on something fundamental to the empire's political and philosophical foundations.
He wasn't simply asking to revise a few regulations.
He was raising the banner of Legalism right in front of a court dominated by Confucian principles.
But Zhangsun Wuji had considered the matter carefully.
By borrowing the slogan of later generations, invoking the Legalist tradition, and offering to compile a comprehensive legal code, he was creating the safest possible route back into the center of political power.
It was a calculated gamble.
If he remained inactive, he might preserve his wealth, status, and noble title. But he would risk being remembered by later generations as nothing more than an imperial relative who happened to become a duke.
That was not the legacy he wanted.
He wanted to leave behind something substantial, something that would make his name matter in its own right.
And so he stood there with his hands raised, awaiting the emperor's answer.
Every passing second dragged like a year.
Finally, after what felt like an age, a voice reached him from the other end of the hall.
"Approved."
The stillness shattered.
The atmosphere in Ganlu Hall suddenly grew lively, and the room, which had felt rather cool when they first entered, now felt uncomfortably warm.
Zhangsun Wuji could feel sweat soaking through the back of his robe. The damp fabric clung unpleasantly to his skin.
Yet beneath that discomfort lay a surge of excitement.
His plan had worked!
His only regret was that Hou Junji wasn't present to witness the moment.
If that blockhead had been here, Zhangsun Wuji would have made absolutely sure he saw the whole thing. The man might even have been forced to acknowledge that Zhangsun Wuji's scholarship, and his political maneuvering, deserved some respect.
For now, though, Zhangsun Wuji could only exhale softly, allowing himself a brief moment of satisfaction.
Li Shimin, for his part, hadn't thought quite as far ahead as Zhangsun Wuji had.
He was familiar with the teachings of Han Fei and Wei Yang. He also remembered two other famous principles associated with Han Fei.
When punishing wrongdoing, do not spare even the highest ministers. When rewarding good deeds, do not overlook even the lowest commoner.
With his own ambitions and determination, Li Shimin believed he could uphold those principles himself.
But what about his sons?
And his grandsons?
Could he guarantee that they would possess the same resolve?
Could he be certain that future rulers would resist the temptation to bend the law for their relatives, reward their favorites, or punish their enemies?
For the moment, he set those concerns aside.
Instead, he looked back at the Light Screen and sighed thoughtfully.
"This Yingzhou rebellion..."
He shook his head.
"Compared with her scheming within the inner palace, the way this later ruler handled the northern frontier seems to come from an entirely different person."
In Li Shimin's eyes, there wasn't much difference between his son and his daughter-in-law when it came to governing the various frontier tribes.
Both had grown up deep within the imperial palace. Neither truly understood the peoples beyond the frontier, yet both were perfectly willing to issue orders from thousands of li away and expect everything to proceed according to plan.
A dangerous combination.
The various frontier tribes respected strength and had little regard for benevolence when it was not backed by power.
That was the reality of the world they inhabited.
You could erect a bronze pillar made from four million jin of red gold in the capital, cover it with elaborate decorations, and spend a fortune on ceremonies celebrating its magnificence.
But none of that would be worth half a jin of ordinary iron if you laid the iron across a barbarian's neck and forced him to acknowledge your authority.
First, make them fear the might of the Hua-Xia. Only then can you compel them to appreciate the virtues of the Hua-Xia.
Without that foundation, talk of benevolence and virtue was little more than empty boasting.
It reminded Li Shimin of the famous Song-era saying that virtue, rather than geographical advantage, was what truly mattered.
A nice sentiment, perhaps.
But when applied to the realities of the frontier without any regard for military strength, it was nothing more than laughable wishful thinking.
By contrast, the later generations had made one point abundantly clear. Appointing incompetent officials to guard the frontier could have consequences far beyond the border itself.
A grand protector had two responsibilities.
He had to preserve the authority of the central government, ensuring that the frontier tribes did not mistake restraint for weakness.
At the same time, he needed the ability to win their trust, manage their affairs, and gradually bring them into the imperial order.
It was a delicate balance between might and virtue.
Either one without the other could bring disaster.
Li Shimin mentally noted the lesson.
As for the Khitan who had once submitted to the Tang, their situation could be addressed later. They had already demonstrated that they could be brought into the imperial fold, and there would be time to reconsider how best to manage them.
The Turkic threat, however, was another matter entirely.
That was the problem that needed to be settled once and for all.
One by one, Li Shimin filed these conclusions away in his mind.
Meanwhile, Du Ruhui had picked up on two unfamiliar terms from the Light Screen's explanation.
The first was population explosion.
The second was Industrial Revolution.
He frowned.
Population explosion. Industrial Revolution. What on earth were those?
