Chapter 32: THE DISTANCE
Kate's absence defined the shape of my days.
She'd restructured her schedule to minimize contact—button shifts opposite mine, meals at different times, jungle expeditions carefully timed to avoid overlap. The distancing was deliberate and obvious, noticed by everyone even if no one commented directly.
"Trouble in paradise?" Hurley asked during one of our occasional backgammon games.
"Something like that."
"Want to talk about it?"
"Nothing to talk about. She's made her choice."
"Dude." He set down his dice, expression serious beneath the usual gentle humor. "Kate doesn't just walk away from things. She runs. It's, like, her whole deal. If she's keeping distance, it means she's scared of something."
"Scared of what?"
"No idea, man. But maybe it's not about you specifically. Maybe it's about what you represent."
What do I represent? Impossible knowledge. Uncomfortable questions. The reminder that nothing on this Island makes sense.
"Thanks for the armchair psychology."
"Hey, I took an intro psych class once. Dropped it after three weeks, but still."
I laughed despite myself—the first genuine laugh in days. Hurley had that effect, the ability to cut through tension with humor that somehow didn't feel dismissive.
---
Claire found me that afternoon at my usual spot on the beach's edge.
"Kate's been asking about you," she said, settling beside me with the careful movements of someone in late pregnancy.
"Asking what?"
"Questions. About the rescue, about how you found Ethan's camp, about things you've said or done that seemed... off." Claire's voice carried no accusation—just curiosity and concern. "She writes things down now. In a notebook she hides under her bed."
She's building a case. Documenting the pattern. Just like Sayid was, before our alliance.
"How do you know about the notebook?"
"We share a living space. Hard to hide things completely." Claire touched her stomach absently. "She asked me once if I thought there was something wrong with you. I told her you saved my life, and my baby's life, and that was all I needed to know."
"What did she say?"
"She said that's exactly what she was afraid of. That you'd done so many good things, people wouldn't want to see the bad." Claire paused. "Is there bad, Sawyer? Something you're hiding that could hurt people?"
Yes. The lie I'm living. The body I'm wearing. The knowledge I shouldn't have. The deaths I've caused by changing things.
"Nothing that would hurt anyone here."
"Then why is she so scared of you?"
The question deserved a better answer than I could give. Kate's fear came from instinct, from the same survival mechanisms that had kept her alive while running from the law. She sensed the wrongness in me—the disconnect between who James Ford should be and who I actually was.
"Some people are easier to trust at a distance. Maybe she realized I'm not one of those."
---
Jack found Kate at the caves that evening.
I watched from the treeline as they talked—close conversation, intimate body language, the kind of connection that had formed the original triangle. Jack offered her water, a sympathetic ear, the comfort of someone who seemed safer than the man she'd been sleeping beside.
In the show, this dance lasted seasons. Back and forth, Kate choosing Jack, choosing Sawyer, choosing neither, choosing both. Here, now, the pattern is accelerating.
The jealousy surprised me.
It wasn't Sawyer's jealousy—the possessive fury of a man watching his woman drift toward a rival. It was something more personal, more painful. I'd started to care about Kate beyond the tactical value of the relationship. Her laugh, her competence, the way she saw through pretense and demanded honesty.
And I gave her everything except what she actually needed. The truth.
She touched Jack's arm. He smiled. The connection between them solidified visibly, two people finding common ground in suspicion of a third.
I turned away before they could spot me watching.
---
The distance grew.
Over the next two days, Kate and I occupied the same camp without occupying the same space. She smiled when necessary, spoke when spoken to, performed the minimum requirements of coexistence while building walls I could feel but couldn't breach.
I tried once to talk to her privately. Caught her near the water collection point at dawn, when the camp was still sleeping.
"Kate—"
"Not now."
"Then when?"
"Maybe not ever." She turned to face me, her expression carefully neutral. "I need time to think. About you, about us, about what I actually know versus what you've told me."
"I haven't lied to you."
"You haven't told me the truth either. There's a difference."
She's right. Omission isn't lying, but it isn't honesty either. Every kiss was real and fraudulent at the same time.
"What would truth even look like? In this situation?"
"I don't know. But I know what it doesn't look like." She stepped back, creating distance that felt physical. "It doesn't look like knowing things before they happen. It doesn't look like always being three steps ahead. It doesn't look like people following your advice and then good things happening, over and over, too consistently to be coincidence."
"I'm just—"
"Observant. I know. That's what you always say." Her voice cracked slightly. "I wanted to believe you, James. I really did. But wanting something doesn't make it true."
She walked away before I could respond.
I stood at the water collection point until the sun rose fully, watching the camp wake up, watching Kate laugh at something Jack said, watching the relationship I'd built crumble into something I couldn't save.
Foreknowledge doesn't prevent heartbreak.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
quick update: unwrittenrealm.com has bonus chapters and the story translated into 14 languages. no paywall for the translations, they stay free once unlocked.