Chapter 19: THE FUNERAL
Sayid's voice carried across the morning air like something precious and breakable.
"She was more than what she showed us. More than the complaints, the frustration, the difficulty of adaptation. Shannon Rutherford was brave in ways she never let anyone see—brave enough to translate a signal no one else could read, brave enough to survive when survival meant abandoning everything she'd known."
I stood at the back of the gathered mourners, far enough that my presence wouldn't trigger Boone's rage, close enough that Perfect Memory could capture every word, every pause, every tremor in Sayid's controlled voice.
He was falling in love with her. In the original timeline, they had more time—weeks, months, a real relationship that ended with a bullet and a terrible mistake.
I stole that from him. From both of them.
The grave was small, marked with driftwood and salvaged metal, Shannon's name scratched into aluminum with a borrowed knife. Rose had woven flowers from jungle blooms—the kind of maternal care that kept the camp functional when grief threatened to tear it apart.
"She deserved better than this Island," Sayid continued. "Better than any of us. But she faced what came with a strength I will always remember."
A strength I will always remember.
The words burned into my consciousness, filed away alongside the pilot's death screams, Ethan's final expression, the wet crack of the beam hitting Shannon's spine. Perfect Memory didn't discriminate between things worth keeping and things that would haunt me forever.
Jack spoke next—generic comfort, the kind of words doctors learned to deliver at besides and gravesites. Then Claire, voice wavering, talking about the few conversations they'd shared about pregnancy fears and uncertain futures. Then silence.
Boone didn't speak at all.
He stood beside the grave with an expression carved from something harder than grief—fury compressed into stillness, blame radiating off him like heat. He hadn't looked at me once since his accusation on the beach. He'd meant what he said about staying away.
The service ended without ritual. People drifted back to their morning tasks—water collection, food preparation, the endless labor of survival that paused for nothing, not even death. I stayed until only Sayid remained, kneeling by the grave with one hand pressed against the sandy soil.
"You blame yourself."
His voice made me jump. I hadn't realized he'd noticed my presence.
"What makes you say that?"
"Because I've seen that expression before. In mirrors, mostly." Sayid rose slowly, dusting sand from his knees. "Boone told Jack you knew the beam was unstable. That you warned him away from the salvage site."
"I warned him about the plane. Not the beach."
"Same principle, isn't it? You see danger others don't. Act on information no one else has." His dark eyes studied me with the particular intensity of a man trained to extract truth from evasion. "I've been curious about you since the crash, Ford. The way you killed that polar bear. The military training you deny having. Now this."
"Now what?"
"Now a woman is dead, and you're standing at her grave like you caused it."
The accusation was too close to truth for comfort. "People die on this Island. It's not anyone's fault."
"Perhaps." Sayid turned to face the ocean, his profile sharp against the morning light. "But I don't think you believe that."
He walked away without waiting for a response. I stayed at Shannon's grave until the sun had climbed high enough to make my shadow disappear.
---
Hurley found me three hours later, sitting on a rock formation at the camp's edge.
"Hey."
"Hey yourself."
He settled beside me with the comfortable weight of someone who didn't need conversation to justify proximity. We sat in silence for several minutes, watching the waves, listening to the distant sounds of camp routine.
"Boone's been telling people you're responsible," Hurley said finally. "Not directly, just... implying stuff. The way you always know things. The way bad stuff follows you around."
"He's not wrong."
"Dude." Hurley turned to face me, his expression serious beneath the usual gentleness. "You saved his life. That beam could have fallen anyway—structural damage from the storm, weakened supports, whatever. It's not on you."
"Isn't it?"
The question hung between us. Hurley had no answer, and I hadn't expected one. Some guilt couldn't be argued away, especially when the argument would require explaining transmigration, butterfly effects, and the particular mathematics of how saving one person could doom another.
"I know you've got this whole... thing going on," Hurley said slowly. "The knowledge stuff you mentioned. The things you see coming that no one else does. But that doesn't make you responsible for everything that happens."
"You don't understand."
"Then help me understand."
I saved Boone from the plane. The Island expected a death—some cosmic balance sheet that keeps everything even. When I prevented Boone's death, the weight shifted. Found Shannon instead.
I can't tell you that. Can't tell anyone. Because it sounds insane, and because understanding wouldn't change anything.
"Some patterns can't be broken," I said. "You push one thing out of place, something else moves to fill the gap. I pushed. Shannon filled the gap."
"That's not how the world works, man."
"It's how this Island works."
Hurley didn't argue. He just sat beside me, solid and present, offering the kind of companionship that demanded nothing and gave everything. The sun moved across the sky. The camp continued its routines. And somewhere in the jungle, the Island kept its ledger.
It's not on you.
I wanted to believe that. Perfect Memory wouldn't let me.
---
Boone passed my position late in the afternoon, a pack slung over his shoulder, heading toward the caves.
He didn't look at me. Didn't slow down. Didn't acknowledge that I existed in any way that mattered. But as he passed, his voice reached me—quiet, final, carved from the same stone as his expression at the funeral.
"Don't talk to me. Don't help me. Don't come near me."
"Boone—"
"I mean it." He stopped, still not turning. "I don't know what you are or what you're doing, but I know Shannon is dead and you're not. I know you saved me from that plane like you could see what was coming. I know you've been three steps ahead of everyone since the crash."
"I just—"
"I don't want explanations. I don't want apologies. I want you to stay away from me and everyone I care about." His voice cracked slightly. "Because whatever you touch, whatever you change—it has a cost. And I'm done paying it."
He walked away.
I let him go.
The afternoon stretched into evening. The camp fires flickered to life across the beach. And I sat alone with Shannon's grave visible in the distance, running numbers I couldn't solve.
How long until Kate discovers who I really am?
How long until Hurley's trust turns to fear?
How long until the next intervention costs someone else their life?
Perfect Memory offered no answers. Just endless perfect recall of everything I'd already lost.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.