The backyard fell quiet except for the soft lapping of pool water and four exhausted bodies breathing hard. Cum glistened on lounge chairs, on thighs, on Ava's swollen pussy lips. Marcus still had one arm draped possessively over Ava's waist, his thick cock softening but still half-hard against her ass. Sophia lay curled against Ava's side, lazily licking a stray drop of Ryan's cum from her friend's breast. Ryan sat on the far chair, chest heaving, his own stomach sticky with his final pathetic load.
Ava stretched like a satisfied cat, arching her back so her heavy tits thrust upward. "God… that was intense," she murmured, voice husky. But even in the afterglow she could feel Ryan's mood shifting. His eyes kept darting away from her, jaw tight.
Ryan cleared his throat. "We… we should head home. It's getting late."
Marcus gave a lazy grin and finally pulled out of Ava with a wet pop. "Yeah, man. Good call." He stood, still completely naked, massive cock swinging as he helped Ava to her feet. Sophia rose too, stretching so her own cum-smeared thighs parted for one last teasing second.
At the door, goodbyes were strangely polite on the surface. Sophia hugged Ava tightly, whispering "Same time next week?" into her ear. Marcus shook Ryan's hand like they were still just neighbors, then turned to Ava. His big palm cracked loudly across her bare ass cheek as she turned to leave — a sharp, possessive spank that left a red handprint glowing on her skin.
"Night, gorgeous," he said with a wink.
Ryan's stomach twisted. He felt weird — not exactly jealous, not exactly angry. Just… off. Like something inside him had cracked and he couldn't name the pieces.
The walk home was silent. The cool night air made Ava's nipples pebble under the tiny sundress she'd thrown back on. Ryan kept glancing at the faint handprint still visible on her ass when the fabric shifted.
Inside their bedroom, Ava slipped out of the dress and panties, leaving them in a pile. She climbed onto the bed naked, patting the spot beside her. Ryan stripped slowly, mind racing. He lay down, staring at the ceiling.
The images wouldn't leave him. Marcus's thick cock sliding into Ava's ass while he was buried in her pussy. The way her moans had changed — deeper, filthier. The way she'd looked at him while talking dirty, eyes locked on his as she came harder than he'd ever made her cum. And worst of all… the way his own cock had betrayed him over and over. He'd cum four times tonight — more than he usually managed in a week — and every single orgasm had hit him while watching his wife get destroyed by another man.
He hated that part most. Not that she'd been fucked in front of him. But that he'd loved it. That his body had reacted like a desperate little pervert. The guilt burned.
"Ava," he said quietly, voice tight. "Tonight… that was a one-time thing. We're not going back there. Ever. I mean it. No more pool parties, no more 'just this once.' We're done."
Ava turned onto her side, propping her head on her hand. Disappointment flashed across her face for half a second before she hid it with a soft, understanding smile. Inside, her mind was already spinning new plans. *Fuck. Back to sneaking around then. Tyler tomorrow morning, Derek after lunch, Vicky at the gym… maybe invite the delivery boys over while Ryan's at work.* But her voice stayed sweet.
"Okay, baby. If that's what you want."
She crawled over and straddled his lap, completely naked, her warm, still-creamy pussy pressing against his soft cock. She cupped his face and kissed him slowly, deeply, tongue sliding against his. "I love you," she whispered against his lips. "I'll do whatever you say. Always."
She was lying through her teeth. The words tasted like sugar on her tongue and poison in her heart.
Ryan's cock twitched beneath her anyway. The feel of her soaked, used pussy against him — still leaking Marcus's cum — made him harden fast. He grabbed her hips, flipped her onto her back, and pushed inside in one thrust. Ava moaned softly, but it was more for his benefit than real need. She was still satisfied from earlier — sore, stretched, and full of other men's loads. Ryan fucked her hard for maybe two minutes, grunting, eyes squeezed shut like he was trying to prove something. Then he groaned and came, adding one more weak load to the mess already inside her.
Ava stroked his back gently. "Mmm, I love you," she said again. She didn't cum. She didn't need to.
They fell asleep naked, tangled together, Ryan's face buried between her breasts like he was trying to forget what he'd seen.
The next morning, three houses away, Ethan Reed's bedroom smelled like stale cum and energy drinks. His computer screen glowed with the 4K footage from last night. He'd jerked off four times already — once during the topless pool scene, once when Ava got DP'd, once while watching Ryan slink back to his chair over and over, and once more just ten minutes ago while replaying Ava's dirty talk to her husband.
His lean, pale body was sticky with sweat and dried loads. His cock — average but rock-hard again — throbbed in his fist as Ava's voice moaned through the speakers: "Ryan, baby… look how deep he's going… Cum for me while you watch him fuck your wife…"
"Fuck," Ethan groaned, stroking faster. The power rush was intoxicating. He had everything. Close-ups of creampies, Sophia cleaning cum, Ryan's humiliated face, Ava's orgasm face while Marcus pounded her. This wasn't just porn. This was leverage.
He couldn't stop himself. Heart hammering, he pulled on a hoodie and shorts, grabbed a USB drive with the best clips, and slipped out his back door. He walked straight to Marcus's house like a man possessed.
Sophia answered the door in a loose silk robe that barely covered her thighs. Her eyes widened slightly when she saw the nervous, skinny neighbor standing there.
"Uh… hi. I need to talk to you and your husband. Together. It's important."
Sophia's lips curved in a curious little smile. "Come in." She called over her shoulder, "Marcus! Ethan from next door wants to talk to both of us."
Marcus appeared in the hallway, towel around his waist, still looking freshly fucked and dangerous. "What's up, kid?"
Ethan's hands shook as he plugged the USB into their TV and hit play. The footage started — Ava's tits spilling out in the pool, the threesome on the lounge, the DP, Ryan cumming hands-free while Ava talked dirty to him. Sophia's eyes lit up with unmistakable excitement; she even bit her lip. Marcus's face stayed completely blank, like he was watching the weather report.
Ethan tried to sound cocky. He puffed out his narrow chest and pointed at the screen. "If you want me to delete every copy of this, you're gonna let me fuck Sophia. Right now. Otherwise I upload the whole thing online — every site, every forum. Your perfect little neighborhood reputation will be gone."
Marcus stared at him for three long seconds. Then he laughed — a low, dangerous sound.
"Go ahead," he said calmly. "Upload it. Nobody believes random porn online anymore. We'll say it's deepfaked, morphed, whatever. And then we'll call the police and report you for harassment, extortion, and blackmail. You're on camera right now, by the way — our doorbell cam has been recording since you walked in. How's that sound, tough guy?"
Ethan's stomach dropped. *Fuck. He's smart.* The cocky act crumbled instantly. His face went pale.
Marcus stepped closer, towering over the skinny gamer. "Now fuck off before I break your bones."
Ethan turned and practically ran for the door. Sophia followed, closing it behind him with a sweet smile. Just before the latch clicked she whispered, "Only if you weren't so cocky, stupid."
Ethan stood on the porch, heart pounding, completely lost. *What the fuck did that mean?* His brilliant blackmail plan had exploded in his face. He felt small, pathetic, and horny all at once.
But then a new idea hit him. *Ryan.* The weak link. The guy who'd cum four times just watching. Maybe Ryan would fold.
He walked the short distance to the Bennetts' house and rang the doorbell, USB drive burning a hole in his pocket.
The door opened.
Ava stood there in a tiny white see-through crop top that did nothing to hide her hard nipples and a matching white thong that was already slightly damp. Her hair was messy, eyes still sleepy and satisfied from last night. She tilted her head, smiling curiously at the nervous neighbor boy.
**To be continued…**
------------
want to get early access and read 30 chapters ahead of current story?
Join patreon.
www.patreon.com/c/maddy32