The trail wound upward through Amon Hen's forested slopes, the Fellowship spread along its length like beads on a string.
Legolas moved near the front, his eyes scanning the trees with attention sharpened by knowledge of what was coming. Somewhere in these woods, Uruk-hai waited—Saruman's elite warriors, bred for speed and savagery, sent to capture the Ring and its bearer. The attack could come at any moment.
But before the orcs, before the battle, before everything shattered—there was Boromir.
The captain of Gondor walked at the rear of the column, his pace slower than usual, his eyes fixed on the back of Frodo's head with an intensity that made Legolas's stomach clench. The Ring's whispers had grown louder overnight. Legolas could see it in the way Boromir's hands trembled, the way his jaw worked as if arguing with someone only he could hear.
Now or never.
"Boromir," Legolas called back, keeping his voice casual. "Will you scout the eastern ridge with me? I want Elven and Mannish eyes on our approach."
Boromir's attention shifted from Frodo with visible reluctance. For a moment, Legolas thought he would refuse—would stay near the hobbit, waiting for the opportunity the Ring was promising.
"Yes," Boromir said finally. "That... would be wise."
They moved away from the column together, their footsteps quiet on the forest floor. Aragorn glanced up as they passed, a question in his eyes. Legolas gave a subtle nod—I have this—and the Ranger's attention returned to the trail ahead.
The eastern ridge rose gradually through a clearing where ancient stones lay scattered like fallen giants. Boromir walked beside Legolas in silence, his body tense, his breathing shallow. The Ring's pressure was almost visible on him—a weight that bent his shoulders and darkened his eyes.
"You love Gondor," Legolas said quietly. "I've watched you these months. Every story you tell, every memory you share—it all comes back to your city, your people, your home."
"My home is dying." The words emerged harsh, angry, grief transformed into fury. "Every year, the darkness creeps closer. Every year, more borders fall. My father sends me to seek aid, and what do I find? A ring that must be destroyed rather than used, and a council that debates while Gondor bleeds."
"Gondor has held for a thousand years—"
"Gondor is failing." Boromir stopped walking, turning to face Legolas with desperation naked in his eyes. "We fight and die and fight again, and still the enemy grows stronger. The Ring could change that. You must see it—you're not blind like the others. The Ring is power, real power, the kind that could turn the tide."
This is it, Legolas thought. The argument the Ring has been building toward. The final seduction.
"I've seen power," Legolas said carefully. "I've watched it work on those who believed they could control it. My own people have history with the Rings of Power—history that taught us harsh lessons about what such artifacts offer and what they take in return."
"Elves." Boromir's voice carried contempt that didn't quite mask the fear beneath. "You speak of distant history, of lessons learned in ages past. I speak of NOW. Of soldiers dying on walls that crumble, of children orphaned by orc raids, of a city that grows darker with each passing season."
"And the Ring would save all that?"
"It would give us strength to fight back. Real strength, not the borrowed power of alliances that may never come." Boromir's hand moved to his sword hilt, a reflexive gesture of comfort. "With the Ring, Gondor could break Mordor's armies. Could reclaim the lands we've lost. Could ensure that my brother—"
He stopped, something flickering across his face. Pain, perhaps, or love, or the desperate hope that drove him toward destruction.
"Faramir," Legolas said softly. "Your brother. Tell me about him."
The change of subject caught Boromir off guard. His aggressive posture softened slightly, the Ring's grip loosening just enough to let something human show through.
"He is... better than me," Boromir admitted. "Wiser. More patient. Our father favors me—the warrior, the captain, the heir who looks like he did in his youth. But Faramir has depths I cannot match. He sees things I miss. Understands things I cannot grasp."
"He sounds like someone worth protecting."
"He is. He is everything." Boromir's voice cracked. "And every day I'm away, he faces our father's disappointment alone. Every day, he defends borders I should be holding. Every day, I fail him by being here instead of home."
"You're here to help save your home."
"Am I?" The question came with desperate honesty. "Or am I failing Gondor by not using every weapon available? The Ring sits within reach—power enough to end this war—and I'm told to let a halfling carry it into fire. How is that saving anything?"
Legolas stepped closer, close enough to grip Boromir's shoulder. The man flinched but didn't pull away.
"Gondor's strength was never in artifacts," Legolas said, his voice firm but gentle. "It was never in rings of power or weapons of the enemy. Gondor's strength is in its people. In men like you, who fight when fighting seems hopeless. In men like Faramir, who think when thinking seems pointless. In the walls you've built and the bonds you've forged and the courage that refuses to yield."
For a moment—one brief, shining moment—Boromir's eyes cleared. The Ring's grip loosened, and Legolas saw the man underneath: the hero who had defended Osgiliath, the brother who loved Faramir, the captain who would die for his soldiers without hesitation.
"The Ring offers power," Legolas continued, pressing the advantage, "but Gondor's power was never in artifacts—it's in people like you."
Boromir's jaw tightened. His shoulders straightened. Something that might have been hope kindled in his expression.
Then his gaze slid past Legolas, toward the direction of the Fellowship, toward the clearing where Frodo walked with the Ring hanging against his chest.
"The Halfling carries what could save us all," Boromir said, and his voice had changed—harder, hungrier, the Ring speaking through his desperate love.
The hope that had kindled in his eyes flickered and died, consumed by golden whispers that promised everything and delivered only ruin.
Legolas felt his heart break. Not dramatically, not with tears or cries—just a quiet fracture, the recognition that he had tried everything he could and it hadn't been enough.
Some falls cannot be prevented.
"We should return to the others," Boromir said, already moving. His steps carried him toward Frodo with purpose that had nothing to do with scouting and everything to do with the Ring's final argument.
Legolas followed, the weight of failure pressing against his chest. He had planted seeds of doubt. Had reminded Boromir of who he was, of what he loved, of the strength that existed independent of corrupted artifacts. Maybe—maybe—when the moment came, some of those seeds would take root. Maybe Boromir would hesitate. Maybe the man beneath the Ring's grip would surface long enough to make a different choice.
Or maybe the Ring would crush everything he'd built, and Boromir would fall exactly as the stories said he would.
They rejoined the Fellowship in silence. Aragorn's eyes followed them, reading the tension in their movements, the failure written in Legolas's posture. But he said nothing—there was nothing to say.
The column continued upward. Amon Hen's summit waited ahead, and with it the moment that would shatter everything.
Frodo announced that he needed time alone to think. His voice carried exhaustion and resolve in equal measure—the Ringbearer preparing to make a choice that would determine the fate of nations.
Boromir's head turned to follow him as he walked into the trees.
Legolas watched them both, his hand moving to the phial of light that hung at his belt. Galadriel's gift. The choice between light and shadow.
The breaking that I came to change, he thought. Or die trying.
Within the hour, everything would be decided.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.