The messenger arrived at my door at 6 PM.
Not the usual rotation — this one was different. Older, more polished, carrying himself with the particular confidence of someone who operated at higher levels of Jamie's organization. He handed me an envelope without speaking, waited for me to open it, and departed only after I'd read the contents.
The invitation was printed on heavy cream paper, the kind that cost more than most people's weekly groceries. No handwriting this time. This was formal.
Le Bernardin. Private dining room. Thursday, 8 PM. Discussion of expanded arrangements. —J.M.
I stood in my doorway, reading the words three times while the implications settled into my understanding.
Le Bernardin was one of the most exclusive restaurants in Manhattan — three Michelin stars, reservations months in advance, the kind of place where business deals were conducted over meals that cost as much as cars. Jamie choosing it meant something. This wasn't the gallery meeting, which had been intimate and personal. This was professional.
She was treating me like a potential asset, not a curiosity.
"The tone has shifted," Vex observed from her position on my desk.
"From interesting to useful. Or potentially useful." I set the invitation down beside Jamie's portrait — the painted version of myself that still watched from its position against the wall. "She tested my methods. Now she wants to discuss my future."
"Your future under her control."
"That's what I need to prevent."
---
I spent the next two days preparing.
The Memory Palace unspooled everything I knew about Jamie Moriarty — the canon knowledge from the show, degraded but still useful, and the direct observations from our previous meeting. Her psychology, her methods, her particular combination of brilliance and cruelty. She manipulated people for entertainment as much as profit. She destroyed lives because she could.
But she also valued interesting things. Sherlock had survived because he interested her. I'd survived so far for the same reason.
The question was whether I could remain interesting without becoming a tool.
"What do you actually know about her current operations?" Vex asked during one of our planning sessions.
"Less than I'd like. My meta-knowledge tells me what she'll do eventually — the Irene Adler reveal, the confrontation with Sherlock, the patterns of manipulation. But this timeline has diverged. She's engaging with me directly, which never happened in the show. I don't know how that changes her plans."
"You're flying blind."
"Partially. I know her psychology. I know what she values, what she despises, how she thinks about power and control. That hasn't changed."
"But her specific plans have."
"Yes."
Vex was quiet for a moment. Then: "What's your objective for this meeting?"
"Maintain independence. Expand the information exchange if it benefits me, but don't accept integration into her organization. No loyalty calls, no directed operations." I paused. "I need to be useful enough to keep around, but not so useful that she decides to own me."
"That's a narrow line."
"It's the only line I have."
---
Thursday arrived too quickly.
I dressed carefully — good suit, not ostentatious, the kind of understated professionalism that suggested competence without trying too hard to impress. Jamie would notice everything about my appearance and draw conclusions from each choice. Better to be intentional than to give her data I hadn't meant to provide.
Le Bernardin occupied a corner of West 51st Street, its exterior elegant but restrained. Inside, the dining room was all white tablecloths and soft lighting, the kind of atmosphere that made conversation feel intimate even across crowded tables.
The maître d' recognized my name before I gave it. "Mr. Dalton. Ms. Moriarty is waiting in the private room."
He led me through the main dining area, past patrons who probably included half a dozen people I'd seen in business magazines, to a door at the back that opened into a smaller space. One table. Two chairs. And Jamie Moriarty, already seated, watching my entrance with eyes that catalogued every detail.
"Cash." She rose to greet me, her handshake firm and brief. "Thank you for coming."
"Thank you for the invitation."
"Please, sit."
The room was beautiful in an understated way — art on the walls that probably cost more than my annual income, lighting that made everything look soft and expensive, a window that overlooked a private courtyard. Jamie had chosen the setting deliberately. Everything she did was deliberate.
Her perfume reached me as I settled into my chair — subtle, expensive, designed to be memorable without being overwhelming. She'd probably selected it specifically for this meeting, another detail meant to reinforce her presence in my mind long after the conversation ended.
"You survived my test," she said, once we were both seated. "That's rarer than you'd think."
"The corporate intelligence was fabricated."
"Of course it was. I wanted to see how you'd respond to valuable information — whether you'd verify thoroughly, act impulsively, or find some middle path." She smiled slightly. "You found the middle path. Verified enough to seem cautious, acted quickly enough to be useful. Exactly what I'd hoped for."
"I'm glad I met expectations."
"You exceeded them. Most people in your position would have either sat on the information too long or rushed into disaster. You showed judgment." Her eyes held mine steadily. "Judgment is valuable. Rare, in our world."
A waiter appeared with menus and wine — selections I hadn't ordered, probably pre-arranged by Jamie. The food would be excellent. The wine would be exceptional. And every detail of this meal would be designed to remind me that she operated at levels I couldn't match.
I let her pour the wine without comment. The battle wasn't about control of the dinner.
"Let's discuss why we're here," Jamie said, once the waiter had retreated. "The information exchange we established has been... adequate. But adequate isn't what interests me. I think we can do better."
"I'm listening."
"You operate independently in spaces that are useful to my organization. You have skills that complement our capabilities. Your reputation as 'Moriarty' gives you access to people and situations that would require significant investment for us to reach otherwise." She paused, swirling her wine. "I'm proposing a closer association."
"What would that look like?"
"Integration. Not full membership — you're not suited for that, and frankly, neither would you want it. But sanctioned operation under our organizational umbrella. You'd have protection, resources, access to intelligence networks you can't currently reach. In exchange, I'd occasionally direct your operations toward my interests, and your loyalty would come when called."
The proposal landed with weight. Integration meant becoming Jamie's tool. Sanctioned operation meant operating with her permission. Loyalty when called meant being used for whatever purposes she deemed appropriate.
"That's a significant change from our current arrangement," I said carefully.
"It is. But our current arrangement has limits. You're useful, Cash, but you could be more useful with proper support. And I could be more confident in you with proper... commitment."
Commitment. The word hung between us like a blade.
"What happens if I decline?"
"Then we continue as we are. Information exchange, mutual usefulness, no deeper ties." She smiled, but the warmth didn't reach her eyes. "I'm not threatening you with consequences for refusal. That would be crude. I'm offering you an opportunity. Whether you accept is your choice."
But we both knew the subtext. Declining Jamie's offer didn't mean staying independent — it meant staying independent for now. Until she decided otherwise. Until the opportunity became an ultimatum.
Every invitation from Jamie was also a warning.
"I need time to consider," I said.
"Of course. Take the weekend. We'll discuss terms on Monday."
The rest of the dinner passed in conversation that was pleasant on the surface and probing underneath. Jamie asked about my operations, my connections, my assessment of various players in the underworld. I answered carefully, giving enough to seem cooperative while protecting the details that mattered most.
When we parted, her handshake lingered slightly longer than necessary. Another reminder. Another signal.
She could close this anytime she wanted. She was choosing not to. For now.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.