Chapter 43: First Kiss
[Rural Georgia — Day 17, Late Afternoon]
Maggie pulled Nelly to a stop at the creek crossing.
The same creek we'd splashed through on the way out — but now the light had shifted, the afternoon sun dropping toward the treeline, and the water caught the gold and threw it back in moving patterns that turned the crossing into something the morning's transit hadn't revealed.
"Horses need water," Maggie said.
They did. Boomer's flanks were warm and his breathing steady but elevated, the specific rhythm of a horse that had been working for hours and that would benefit from a pause. The justification was practical. The location was not — the creek here was lined with oaks, their canopy creating a pocket of shade and privacy that the open road hadn't offered, and Maggie had ridden past two other water-access points in the last mile without stopping.
I dismounted. The motion was better than this morning's — less graceless, the muscle memory of a body that was learning to work with a horse rather than against one — but my thighs protested the transition from saddle to ground with the specific, burning complaint of muscles that had been gripping a horse's barrel for three hours and that had opinions about the experience.
The horses drank. Nelly lowered her head to the creek's surface with the practiced ease of an animal who'd watered here before. Boomer followed her lead, the herd dynamic that placed familiar horses ahead of new riders in the hierarchy of decisions.
I sat on a flat rock at the creek's edge. The stone was warm from the day's sun, the heat soaking through my jeans and into muscles that received it with gratitude. The water moved past — clear, shallow, the specific Georgia creek that carried red clay sediment and the occasional leaf and the sound of moving water that was one of the few sounds the apocalypse hadn't changed.
Maggie sat beside me. Not across from me — beside, the specific proximity of a person choosing closeness over conversation distance. Her knee was eight inches from mine. The gap was deliberate and insufficient and charged with the particular energy that proximity generates between two people who are aware of each other in ways that proximity alone doesn't explain.
"Otis getting shot changed things," Maggie said. The statement arrived without preamble — the direct conversational style that her character demanded, the woman who said what she meant and who expected the same. "Not just Carl. Everything. Daddy was so certain we were safe. The farm, the fences, the way he kept... the way things were. Then Otis comes home bleeding from a deer hunt and there's a boy dying on our kitchen table and strangers on the porch and nothing's the way it was."
"That must have been hard."
"Hard?" The word was tested and rejected. "Hard is finals week and a broken truck. This is... I don't have a word for it. Everything I thought was true — about the farm, about being safe, about Daddy's way being enough — all of it cracked. Like ice on a pond. Still looks solid from a distance, but you put weight on it..."
"It breaks."
"It's already broken. We're just standing on the pieces pretending they'll hold."
The creek moved past. A leaf turned in the current — oak, brown, the late-October debris of a tree preparing for winter without awareness that winter this year would mean something different than it had ever meant before.
"What was it like?" Maggie asked. "Before the farm. Out there."
"Bad." The same answer I'd given on the ride out. But she was asking for more than the summary, and the creek and the shade and the proximity had created the specific conditions under which more was possible. "We lost people at the quarry. A woman named Amy — she was Andrea's sister. Twenty-four years old. Walkers came at night and she... she was right there. Right there and we couldn't—" The sentence broke. Not performance. The photographic memory supplied Amy's face with perfect clarity — the moonlight, the blood, the specific expression of a woman who was dying and who was scared and whose sister was holding her and whose death was one of the memories that the perfect recall would carry forever without softening.
"I'm sorry."
"Then the CDC. Government facility, supposed to have answers. Had one scientist and a self-destruct timer. Almost killed us all." Callback: The countdown clock, 00:58:14, the red numbers that had measured the distance between living and dying in a building that Jenner had decided was a tomb. "We got out. Barely. And then the road, and the highway, and your father's farm. That's the version."
"The version?"
"The short version. The long version has more... details."
Maggie's eyes found mine. The assessment was ongoing — the evaluation that had been running since the porch vigil, that had intensified during the farm tour and the pharmacy run — but the quality had changed. The calculation was softer. The distance smaller. She was looking at me the way a person looks at someone they've decided to trust before they've finished deciding to trust them.
"You carry a lot," she said.
"Everyone does."
"Not like you. Rick carries his family. Shane carries... whatever Shane carries. You carry the rest of it. The pieces nobody else picks up."
The observation was more precise than she could have known. The meta-knowledge, the future events, the deaths I was trying to prevent, the secrets that multiplied with every competence I demonstrated — the pieces nobody else could pick up because nobody else knew they existed.
"Someone has to," I said.
"That's what I thought about you." Maggie's voice was quieter now — the volume adjustment she made when processing emotions, the reduction that her character performed when the content required gentleness rather than efficiency. "At the porch. When you came back from the school with Otis and Shane. Daddy said you found the way out. Otis said you saved them. Shane didn't say anything, which told me more than the other two." A pause. "I thought — he's the one carrying the pieces."
The gap between her knee and mine had closed. Not a dramatic shift — the specific, incremental migration of two bodies that were gravitating toward each other through the small, unconscious adjustments that attraction produced. Her knee touched mine. The contact was warm through denim and the warmth traveled upward through my leg and into my chest and the specific, physical reality of Maggie Greene's knee against mine was different from every image the archive had stored because the images were flat and this was three-dimensional and warm and alive and here.
She moved first.
The distance between sitting beside someone and kissing them is measured in inches and in decisions, and Maggie Greene crossed both — turning toward me, her hand finding the side of my face, her fingers against my jaw, and then her mouth was on mine and the world contracted to the specific, immediate reality of her lips and the pressure and the warmth and the taste of creek water and the chapstick she'd applied at the pharmacy when she thought I wasn't looking.
I froze. One heartbeat. The archive screamed — this is it, this is the moment, this happened in the show, Maggie in the pharmacy, aggressive, surprising, wonderful — and the archive was wrong because this wasn't the pharmacy and this wasn't aggressive and this was nothing like watching it on a screen. This was soft. Questioning. A mouth asking a question that words couldn't frame.
I responded. My hand found the back of her neck — the specific, warm curve where her hair met skin — and the kiss deepened from question to answer to something that existed in the space beyond both.
When we broke apart, her eyes were close. Brown. The amber edge that the stained glass had suggested and that the afternoon light confirmed.
"That was—" I started.
"Shut up," Maggie said, and kissed me again.
The second kiss was longer. More certain. The questioning was gone, replaced by the specific confidence of a woman who'd made a decision and who was executing the decision with the directness that defined everything Maggie Greene did. Her hand moved from my jaw to the collar of my shirt, gripping the fabric, pulling me closer with a strength that farm work and horseback riding had built into her fingers.
I laughed. The sound escaped between kisses — involuntary, surprising, the specific, uncontrolled release of something that had been compressed inside my chest since the day I'd opened my eyes in Glenn Rhee's body in an empty Atlanta apartment and started counting the distance between survival and living. The laugh was the first real one in seventeen days. Not the tactical chuckle I deployed for social calibration. Not the humor-as-coping that T-Dog had taught me. This was joy, uncomplicated and enormous and escaping through whatever gap the kiss had opened.
Maggie pulled back. "What?"
"Nothing. Everything. This."
She didn't understand. The words were insufficient for the content — the transmigrator's specific, overwhelming experience of kissing a woman he'd watched on a screen and who was now real and warm and looking at him with brown eyes that carried confusion and amusement and the beginning of something that the word attraction couldn't contain.
She smiled. The full smile — the expression that the almost-smiles had been building toward, the muscular commitment complete, the warmth reaching her eyes and transforming her face from beautiful-and-guarded to beautiful-and-open, and the difference between the two was the difference between looking at a house and being invited inside.
"You're weird," she said.
"I've been told."
The horses drank. The creek moved. The afternoon light held its gold. We sat on the rock with our knees touching and the taste of each other on our lips and the specific, impossible reality of a moment that the archive had promised and that the present had delivered in a way the archive never could have prepared me for.
---
The ride back was slower than necessary.
Neither of us mentioned the pace. Maggie rode ahead on the trail, her back straight, her hair catching the last of the afternoon light, and I followed on Boomer's patient back with my thighs burning and my lips tingling and the supply bag balanced across the saddle horn. Her knee brushed mine where the trail narrowed. Neither of us pulled away.
The farm materialized from the distance — the white house, the barns, the tents in the far field. Reality returning, the specific gravity of a community reasserting its pull on two people who'd briefly escaped its orbit.
"This stays between us," Maggie said. The words were delivered with the directness that defined her, but the tone carried a vulnerability that the directness was trying to conceal. "For now."
"For now."
"Daddy would..." She stopped. The sentence led to Hershel's reaction, and Hershel's reaction was a variable that neither of us was ready to calculate. "For now."
"For now is enough."
We rode into the yard separately — Maggie ahead, me two minutes behind, the gap manufactured to preserve the secret that the creek had created. She was already unsaddling Nelly when I brought Boomer into the stable, and the distance between us was the distance that secrecy demanded and that the memory of her mouth made intolerable.
Our eyes met across the stable. The almost-smile was gone, replaced by the real one — brief, private, shared between two people who'd kissed by a creek and who were pretending they hadn't because the pretending was necessary and because the pretending made the truth feel like a secret worth keeping.
I unsaddled Boomer. My hands were steady and my heart was not and the distinction between the two was the distinction between what the world could see and what Maggie Greene had changed.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0