Chapter 9: The Arrest
[Beacon Hills High School — Monday, September 26, 2011, 8:04 AM]
The squad car was parked in front of the school when Jackson arrived.
Not hidden — displayed. A Beacon County Sheriff's cruiser angled across the visitor spot nearest the main entrance, lights off but present, its very visibility a message. Deputy Graeme stood by the hood talking to Vice Principal Curtis, and between them passed the particular body language of authority figures exchanging information they didn't want students to hear.
Jackson parked the Porsche in his usual spot and sat for a moment. His phone — the iPhone, not the burner — was already filling with texts. Lydia: did you hear about derek hale?? the guy who lives in the burned house? ARRESTED. Danny: dude check the news. A group chat notification from the lacrosse team: someone had screenshot the Beacon Hills police blotter and circled Derek's name in red.
He let the messages accumulate and walked into school.
The hallway ran on a single frequency: Derek Hale. The name moved through the student body like an electrical current, jumping from cluster to cluster, gaining distortion with each transfer. By the time Jackson reached his locker, the story had mutated through at least four versions — Derek had killed someone, Derek had killed two people, Derek had been found with bodies in his basement, Derek was a serial killer who'd been living in his murdered family's house for years.
None of it was true in the way they meant. All of it was close enough to hurt.
Jackson opened his locker and swapped books for first period. Two lockers down, a freshman was showing someone a news article on his phone. The photo was grainy — Derek in handcuffs, head down, being led from a patrol car into the station. The leather jacket looked wrong under fluorescent light. The posture was wrong too — not defeated, but contained. A man conserving energy.
He'll be released. They don't have physical evidence connecting him to the video store killing because he didn't do it. The forensics won't match. Peter is careful — animal-style kills, no fingerprints, no weapons. Derek becomes a suspect because he's the convenient monster: the loner in the burned house with the dead sister and no alibi.
In canon, this plays out over a few episodes. Derek gets released. Scott and Stiles investigate. The real Alpha stays hidden until the midpoint revelation. Letting Derek sit in custody is tactically sound — it keeps him safe from Peter, keeps the police focused on the wrong target, and buys time.
Tactically sound. Two words that were starting to taste like ash.
The bell rang. Jackson shouldered his bag and headed to first period.
---
[Beacon Hills High — Hallway, 10:30 AM]
Jackson spotted them before they spotted him.
Scott and Stiles were tucked into the alcove near the chemistry lab, speaking in the kind of urgent whisper that broadcast conspiracy to anyone within fifteen feet. Stiles was gesturing with both hands — full wingspan, like a bird trying to achieve liftoff — while Scott leaned against the wall with his arms crossed and his jaw set.
Jackson caught fragments as he walked past. Not because he was trying — the acoustics of the alcove bounced sound into the hallway at chest height, and Stiles Stilinski had never in his life spoken at a volume below "audible from space."
"— Derek didn't kill anyone, Scott, think about it. The claw marks match the ones from the preserve, from the thing that bit you, and Derek's not — he wasn't the one in the preserve that night, he—"
"I know." Scott's voice was tight. "But the police don't know that, and we can't exactly tell them—"
"Tell them what? Hey, Sheriff Dad, the murders were committed by a werewolf but not that werewolf, a different werewolf, possibly an Alpha werewolf? Yeah, that'll go great."
Jackson kept walking. He'd heard enough. Scott and Stiles had connected the dots — Derek to werewolves, the Alpha to the murders, the police to the wrong suspect. They were three steps behind the answer and ten steps behind Jackson.
Let them work it out. That's how they grow. That's how Scott becomes the person who can face Peter. You can't hand them the answers — they need to find them.
The rationalization was getting smoother every time he used it. That worried him.
---
[Beacon Hills High — Outside the Library, 12:15 PM]
Scott found him at lunch.
Jackson was sitting on the low wall outside the library entrance, eating a sandwich Margaret had packed — turkey, provolone, mustard, the same combination she'd been putting in Jackson's lunch bag since middle school according to the stacked containers in the kitchen pantry. The sandwich was good. The sun was warm. Two girls from the track team were studying on the grass nearby, and the normalcy of the scene felt like a costume Jackson was wearing over something that didn't fit.
"Hey." Scott stopped three feet away. His hands were in his jacket pockets, his posture a study in teenage awkwardness — weight shifting, eyes finding the ground, bouncing back up.
"McCall."
"Can I — can I ask you something?"
Jackson set the sandwich down. "Depends on the question."
Scott sat on the wall, leaving two feet of space between them. He stared at the grass for a moment. Then: "Someone saw your car at the Hale house. Last week. Before Derek got arrested."
Who saw me. When. The access road was supposed to be empty.
"I was out there for a project," Jackson said. "Local history. The Hale fire is public record."
"A project."
"Research. I told you, I'm adopted. I was looking into county records and the Hale case came up."
Scott processed this with the visible, earnest thoroughness that made him simultaneously infuriating and impossible to dislike. He chewed his lip. Looked at Jackson. Back at the grass.
"Do you know Derek?"
The question was a blade with a dull edge — blunt enough not to cut, but the weight was there. Jackson measured the response in real time. Denial was clean but would crack under scrutiny; Danny could confirm Jackson's car had been near the preserve. Admission was risky but controllable.
"I've talked to him. Once." Half-truth, sharpened. "I brought him the research I'd compiled on his family's fire. Figured he'd want to see it."
"Why?"
"Because eleven people burned to death in that house and nobody did anything about it. I thought someone should."
Scott's expression shifted. The suspicion was still there, but layered under it was something else — recognition. The particular look of a person who'd just heard someone say the thing they believed but hadn't been able to articulate.
"That's..." Scott trailed off. "That's actually pretty cool of you."
"Don't spread it around. I have a reputation."
The joke landed. Scott almost smiled — a brief softening of the mouth that disappeared before it fully formed. He stood up, brushed off his jeans, and looked at Jackson with an expression that was ten percent suspicion and ninety percent something warmer.
"If you hear anything about Derek — about what's happening with the arrest — would you tell me?"
He's asking me for help. Scott McCall, the future True Alpha, is coming to Jackson Whittemore for information. That's not canon. That's not even close to canon.
"Why do you care about Derek Hale?"
Scott's jaw tightened. A flash of something behind his eyes — not gold, not the wolf, but the decision-making calculus of a boy deciding how much truth to spend.
"He helped me," Scott said. "With something. And I don't think he killed anyone."
"I don't think he did either."
The words hung between them. Two boys on a wall outside a high school library, agreeing about a werewolf's innocence in the middle of a Monday afternoon. The track girls laughed about something. A bird landed on the library roof and took off again.
"I'll let you know if I hear anything," Jackson said.
Scott nodded. Walked away. His stride was still wrong — still too fluid, too efficient, the wolf's mechanics overriding the teenager's awkwardness in ways Scott hadn't learned to hide yet.
Stiles was waiting at the end of the hallway. Jackson could see him through the library's glass doors — leaning against the wall, arms crossed, watching Scott walk back with an expression that carried the specific fury of a best friend watching his person seek help from the wrong source.
He doesn't trust me. That's fine. Stiles Stilinski doesn't trust anyone he hasn't vetted, and the vetting process for Jackson Whittemore is going to take a while.
But Scott had come to him. Had sat on this wall and asked for help and left with something adjacent to trust, and that was a thread Jackson hadn't planned for but could weave into the pattern.
---
[Beacon Hills High — Parking Lot, 3:20 PM]
The Porsche was warm from sitting in the afternoon sun. Jackson tossed his bag in the back seat and was reaching for the ignition when he saw it — Stiles' Jeep, the powder-blue CJ-5 that had become iconic in his memories of the show, peeling out of the student lot with the kind of velocity that suggested urgency and poor impulse control in equal measure.
Scott was in the passenger seat. His head was turned toward Stiles, mouth moving fast.
They were heading east. Toward the Sheriff's station.
They're going to see Derek. Or try to. Stiles will use his father's access, or he'll try some absurd gambit to get into the holding area, and Derek will either tell them nothing or tell them just enough to point them toward the Alpha without identifying Peter.
In canon, this sequence leads to Scott and Derek's uneasy partnership — the reluctant mentor and the terrified student. Derek teaches Scott about anchors and control. Scott keeps Derek honest. The dynamic builds over weeks and becomes the foundation of everything that follows.
Jackson started the Porsche. He could follow them. Could show up at the station and insert himself into the conversation, leverage his existing relationship with Derek, accelerate the alliance.
He turned the key and let the engine idle.
No. This is their story. Scott and Derek's bond has to form organically — forged in crisis, not brokered by a third party. If I wedge myself between them now, I become a dependency. They need to build trust the hard way, the way that sticks.
He pulled out of the lot and turned west. Toward home. Away from the station, away from the Jeep's disappearing taillights, away from the two boys about to do something reckless and necessary.
The burner phone sat in his pocket. Silent. Derek hadn't texted since before the arrest, and wouldn't — they'd have confiscated his belongings at booking. But Derek knew Jackson's face, knew his name, knew where to find him. When he got out — and he would get out, because Peter needed him breathing — the alliance would resume.
Jackson drove through downtown. The video store on Main was closed, yellow police tape across the entrance, a patrol car parked outside. He didn't slow down. Didn't look twice. The tape was a line drawn around someone's death, and Jackson had made the choice to let that death happen, and looking at the tape wouldn't change the math.
His phone buzzed. Lydia: saturday dinner still on? green dress, remember.
He typed back: wouldn't miss it.
Normal. All of it normal. Saturday dinners and green dresses and the mechanical certainty of maintaining a social life while the town frayed at its edges. Margaret's turkey sandwich still sat half-finished in his bag. Chris Argent's SUV had been in the school parking lot this morning — Jackson had clocked it at 7:58 AM, same spot as Friday night, same deliberate positioning.
Three blocks from home, his phone buzzed again. Not Lydia. Not Danny.
The burner.
Jackson pulled over. Checked the screen. One text from the only number in the phone's memory.
Unknown: Released. Tomorrow night. Bring what you have on the animal attacks.
Not Derek's usual tone. The message was longer, more structured. Someone who'd spent forty-eight hours in a holding cell and come out with a refined sense of urgency.
Jackson typed: Same place? Same time?
The reply came in four seconds.
No. The school. Parking lot. Midnight.
Jackson stared at the message. The school at midnight was a terrible meeting spot — exposed, surveilled by security cameras, adjacent to residential neighborhoods. Derek wouldn't choose it unless he had a reason that outweighed the risk.
Unless Derek was planning to be at the school for another reason, and he was folding Jackson into an existing operation.
Tuesday night. The school. Midnight.
In canon, the Alpha attacked the school at night early in the season. Chased Scott and whoever was with him through the building. Red eyes in the hallways. Locked doors. The kind of horror-movie setup that the show had used to establish Peter's threat level.
Jackson pocketed the burner and pulled back into traffic. His hands were steady on the wheel. His breathing was controlled. Inside his chest, something was rearranging itself — the comfortable distance between observer and participant narrowing to a width that no longer felt safe.
Tuesday night. The school. Something with red eyes.
And Jackson Whittemore, who was human and breakable and had exactly zero supernatural defenses, had just agreed to be there.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0