Chapter 2: First Chair
[Wakefield & Gould, Midtown — May 9, 2011, 2:15 PM]
The deposition was dying and Don was the only person in the room who knew it.
Ellen Marsh — forty-six, divorced, co-owner of a commercial laundry service in Queens — sat across the conference table from a man whose lawyer had spent the last forty minutes trying to prove she'd breached a supply contract. The opposing counsel was good. Methodical. He had documentation and he knew how to use it, laying out invoices and delivery receipts with the steady rhythm of someone who'd done this a hundred times.
Wakefield had been sitting beside Don for the first half hour. Then Wakefield's phone buzzed, and his face did something complicated, and he leaned over and whispered: "Klein. Take over. Family emergency. I'll be back in an hour."
That was thirty-eight minutes ago. Wakefield was not back.
Opposing counsel — name tag said Draper, which Don tried not to find amusing — laid another document on the table. "Ms. Marsh, can you confirm this is the delivery schedule your company agreed to in the original contract?"
Ellen looked at Don. Her eyes said help me.
Don scanned the document. Standard delivery matrix, nothing unusual. But something nagged at the margins — a date discrepancy between the contract amendment and the invoice schedule. He reached for the feeling the way he'd been practicing for eight weeks, the way a man reaches for a light switch in a dark room, knowing approximately where it should be.
The Library flickered.
Faint. Unreliable. But present — a heat-haze shimmer at the periphery of his vision. Tags, the system called them, though Don had only discovered tags existed two weeks ago when the Library had started organizing itself into something more than vague impressions. A blue tag floated near the contract: #supply-agreement. And beside it, golden and faint, a connection he hadn't made consciously: #amendment-clause-17.
Don followed the thread. Clause 17 of the amendment — he'd read it three times in preparation but hadn't flagged it as significant. The Library pulled a case name out of the fog: Goldstein v. Metro Supply Corp, 2004. A Second Circuit ruling on delivery schedule modifications. If the amendment clause applied retroactively —
"Counsel," Don said, keeping his voice level. "Before we continue — I'd like to direct your attention to Clause 17 of the contract amendment, dated February third of last year."
Draper looked up from his notes. "What about it?"
"The clause specifies that delivery schedule modifications require thirty-day written notice. Your client's revised schedule was implemented fourteen days after the amendment was signed. Under Goldstein v. Metro Supply, that's an insufficient notice period, which means every delivery deviation your client is citing as a breach was, in fact, unauthorized by your own contract terms."
Draper's pen stopped moving.
Ellen Marsh's lawyer — Don — had just turned the breach claim inside out.
"That's..." Draper flipped to the amendment. Scanned it. His jaw tightened. "I'd like a recess to confer with my client."
"Take your time."
---
The conference room emptied. Ellen Marsh grabbed Don's arm on her way out. "That was incredible. Martin never — how did you catch that?"
"Careful reading," Don said. Which was true, from a certain angle.
He walked back toward his office. The hallway was empty — mid-afternoon, most of the associates hunched over desks in the bullpen two floors down. Don's office was barely an office. A desk, a chair, a window that faced a brick wall, and a door that closed, which at Wakefield & Gould qualified as a luxury for someone two years out of law school.
He sat down. Closed the door.
The Library sharpened.
The shift was subtle — like adjusting the focus ring on a camera. The perpetual fog behind his eyes, the one he'd been living with since March, cleared a fraction. Not dramatically. Not enough to call it a breakthrough. But the difference between yesterday's Library and this moment's Library was the difference between trying to read through frosted glass and trying to read through dirty glass. Still obscured. Less.
He tested it. Thought: breach of fiduciary duty.
Results came — vague, impressionistic, but faster than yesterday. Case names that had been fog-ghosts before now arrived as whispers he could almost hear. Three precedents, a statute reference, and the faint outline of a tag chain he could follow if he spent the points.
Points. That was the other thing he'd figured out. The Library ran on something — a resource, a fuel, a currency that depleted when he pushed and replenished when he won. He'd started calling them Legal Points, because the Library responded to legal work and nothing else, and because giving the thing a name made it feel less like madness.
The deposition win had fed it. Three points, maybe. He couldn't measure exactly — the Library didn't display numbers or charts. But the difference was tangible, the way a meal is tangible when you've been hungry for days.
The win gave him fuel. The fuel made the Library clearer. The clearer Library would help him win more. A cycle. A machine that rewarded success and starved on failure.
Don leaned back in his chair. The headache was mild today — present but manageable, a dull throb behind his right eye. The Library's way of reminding him that running searches cost something, even small ones.
His phone buzzed. Text from Wakefield: Back in 20. How'd it go?
Don typed: Deposition closed on our terms. Draper folded on the key point. Details when you're in.
He set the phone down. Stared at the brick wall outside his window.
Two months in this life. Eight weeks of learning Don Klein's routines — his commute, his coffee order, his colleagues' names, the particular way the original Don organized case files (alphabetical by client surname, which was psychotic, but consistent). Eight weeks of testing the Library's boundaries, mapping what it could do and what it couldn't, learning the difference between a search that cost nothing and a search that drained him.
The Library knew law. Federal statutes. State regulations. Landmark cases and obscure precedents and the kind of connective tissue between legal concepts that most associates needed Westlaw and three hours to find. What it didn't know was anything that hadn't been published, anything sealed, anything private. It was a research engine, not an intelligence network.
Which meant it couldn't tell him what was happening inside Pearson Hardman.
He'd tried. Two weeks ago, sitting at this same desk, he'd pushed the thought: Pearson Hardman client list. The Library had returned nothing. Not a flicker, not a shimmer, not a single tag. Published law only. Firm secrets lived in a world the Library couldn't reach.
Fine. He'd find another way.
---
Wakefield's office was on the corner of the fourteenth floor — larger than Don's, with two windows and a view that included a sliver of sky between buildings. Martin Wakefield was sixty-one, silver-haired, built like a man who'd played rugby in college and never entirely stopped carrying himself like one. He ran his section of the firm the way old-school partners did: personally, with handshakes and scotch and the assumption that loyalty was earned through proximity.
"Klein." Wakefield gestured to the chair across his desk. "Draper's counsel called. They want to settle."
"Good."
"More than good. You closed a deposition solo against a counsel who's been practicing since before you were born. That's not nothing." Wakefield studied him. "How long have you been here, Don?"
"Two years."
"Two years and I've barely noticed you. That's either a compliment to your discretion or an indictment of my attention span." He pulled a file from the stack on his desk and slid it across. "Landlord-tenant case. Small but complicated — rent stabilization dispute, building in Washington Heights. I want you first chair."
Don took the file. Opened it. The Library stirred — a faint shimmer at the edges of the pages, tags beginning to form. #rent-stabilization. #housing-court. He closed the file before the shimmer could develop fully. The last thing he needed was to zone out in front of his boss while his supernatural search engine booted up.
"Full autonomy?" Don asked.
"Full autonomy. You report to me weekly. Questions, you come to me. But the case is yours." Wakefield leaned back. "Don't make me regret it."
"I won't."
Don left with the file under his arm. The walk back to his office took thirty seconds. He shut the door, sat down, and let the Library expand across the case materials — tags blooming like flowers in time-lapse, connections forming between the rent stabilization statute and a string of Housing Court decisions that Don could follow like breadcrumbs.
His first case. First chair. Full autonomy.
The headache pulsed once and subsided.
After five, Don left the building. The liquor store on Forty-Third had a Macallan 12 on the shelf — amber bottle, clean label, the kind of scotch Harvey Specter kept in his office for celebrations and power plays. Don's hand reached for it.
He stopped.
Pulled it back. Reached instead for a Glenfiddich 15 — different distillery, different profile, a bottle Harvey Specter would never choose. Don's own preference. His own tradition. One small thing in this borrowed life that belonged to him and nobody else.
He paid cash. Walked home through Midtown. The evening air carried the smell of street vendors and taxi exhaust, and somewhere above the rooftops, the Pearson Hardman building caught the last of the daylight on its glass.
Don didn't look up. Not yet.
Back at the apartment, he poured two fingers of the Glenfiddich. Didn't drink it immediately — let it sit, let the smell fill the small kitchen, let the amber catch the light from the window.
Then he sat at the desk with the landlord-tenant file open and thought: Pearson Hardman client list.
Nothing. The Library returned silence.
It only knew published law. Not firm secrets. Not client rosters. Not the internal politics that would, in four weeks, produce the most famous fraudulent hiring in television history.
Don closed the file. Picked up the scotch.
I'll find another way.
The Glenfiddich burned clean going down. Outside, Manhattan hummed its ten-million-voice chord, and on his desk, the landlord-tenant file waited like a loaded weapon he was only beginning to understand how to aim.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1