Chapter 26: Nightmare — Prelude
[Interstate 80 East — November 22, 2005, 3:47 AM]
Sam's scream tore through the darkness.
The Impala swerved as Dean jerked awake, his reflexes the only thing keeping them from veering into the opposite lane. Ethan, who'd been dozing in the backseat of his truck parked at the rest stop beside them, was out and running before his brain fully registered what had happened.
Sam was in the passenger seat, doubled over, hands pressed to his temples, breathing in sharp gasps that sounded like sobs. Dean had pulled onto the shoulder, hazard lights blinking, and was shaking his brother's shoulder with increasingly desperate motions.
"Sam! Sammy, wake up—"
"I'm awake." Sam's voice was ragged, wrecked. "I'm awake. I just—I saw—"
"Saw what?"
Sam looked up, and his eyes were wrong—dilated, unfocused, still seeing something that wasn't there. "A man. In his car. The garage door was closed, and the exhaust was on, and he couldn't get out. He was screaming, pounding on the windows, but they wouldn't break. He died, Dean. I watched him die."
"A nightmare—"
"It wasn't a nightmare." Sam's hands were shaking. "It was real. It's going to happen. I know the address—I saw the house number, the street sign. 1488 Maple Street, Saginaw, Michigan."
Dean and Ethan exchanged looks. The same thought crossed both their minds: Sam Winchester, having visions of deaths before they happened, wasn't normal. Wasn't natural.
Ethan's Sin Sense flickered involuntarily, reaching toward Sam. What he found made his blood run cold.
Something was inside the younger Winchester. Not possession—not the corruption of demonic influence—but something dormant, something that had been sleeping for years and was now beginning to wake. It pulsed with power that felt familiar in a way Ethan couldn't explain, connected to something vast and terrible that lurked at the edge of his awareness.
Azazel. The demon blood. Sam's destiny.
Ethan knew what this was. He'd watched the show, understood the mythology—Sam Winchester was one of the "special children," humans fed demon blood as infants, developing psychic abilities as they matured. Azazel's candidates for something apocalyptic.
He couldn't say any of that. Couldn't explain how he knew. But he could help.
"Sam." Ethan crouched beside the Impala's open door, meeting Sam's haunted eyes. "Tell me exactly what you saw. Every detail."
The vision spilled out in fragments—a middle-aged man, gray at the temples, wearing a cardigan. A car that wouldn't start, doors that wouldn't open, windows that wouldn't break. Exhaust filling the garage like poison fog. The man's face as he realized he was going to die.
"His name was on the mailbox," Sam finished. "Miller. Jim Miller."
"When?"
"I don't know. Soon. Today, maybe. Tomorrow at the latest." Sam's hands wouldn't stop shaking. "Dean, we have to go. We have to try—"
"Sam, it was a dream—"
"It wasn't a DREAM!" Sam's voice cracked. "I know the difference between dreams and... and whatever this is. I've been having them for weeks—flashes, images, feelings. This one was clear. This one was specific. And if we don't try to stop it, Jim Miller is going to die."
Dean looked at Ethan, clearly hoping for a reality check, for someone to tell him his brother wasn't losing his mind.
Ethan couldn't give him that.
"We go," Ethan said. "If Sam's wrong, we've wasted a few hours. If he's right, we might save a life."
"And if he's right about—about having visions of the future—what does that mean?"
"It means we figure it out. After."
[Saginaw, Michigan — November 22, 2005, 2:15 PM]
They were too late.
Jim Miller had been found that morning by his wife Alice, dead in his car in their closed garage. Carbon monoxide poisoning, ruled accidental—the car's exhaust system had malfunctioned, filling the space with lethal fumes while Jim was trapped inside by doors that had somehow jammed.
Exactly as Sam had seen.
The Miller house was quiet when they approached it, the aftermath of tragedy settling over the property like fog. A woman in her fifties answered the door—Alice Miller, her eyes red-rimmed, her movements mechanical.
"Mrs. Miller?" Sam's voice was gentle, practiced at this kind of deception. "We're from the insurance company. We're very sorry for your loss, but we need to ask a few questions about the circumstances."
Alice let them in without argument. The house smelled like casseroles and sympathy cards—the detritus of sudden death, neighbors bringing food no one would eat, condolences no one wanted to hear.
Ethan's Sin Sense expanded as they entered, reading the emotional landscape of the household. Alice's guilt was surface-level, ordinary—the guilt of a wife who'd been asleep when her husband died, who hadn't heard his screams, who'd woken to tragedy instead of preventing it.
But there was something else. Someone else.
A young man sat in the living room, early twenties, with hollow eyes and a posture that suggested he was trying to make himself invisible. Max Miller—Jim's stepson, according to the family photos on the walls. And the guilt radiating from him was anything but ordinary.
It was rage. Shame. Power barely contained.
HE CARRIES SOMETHING SIMILAR TO THE YOUNGER WINCHESTER.
Ethan's chest burned with the Spirit's observation. Another one. Another psychic, another "special child," sitting in the living room of a house where someone had just died under impossible circumstances.
Sam was interviewing Alice, gathering information about the accident, about Jim's state of mind in his final days. Dean had slipped away to examine the garage, looking for evidence of supernatural tampering.
Ethan sat down across from Max.
"I'm sorry about your father," he said quietly.
"Stepfather." Max's voice was flat, carefully controlled. "He married my mom when I was seven."
"Still. Family is family."
Something flickered in Max's eyes—not grief, not sadness. Something closer to satisfaction, quickly suppressed. "Yeah. Family."
Ethan's Sin Sense screamed. The guilt Max carried wasn't regret for failing to prevent a death—it was guilt for causing one. For using power he'd hidden all his life to murder the man who'd raised him.
"Max." Ethan kept his voice low, pitched for privacy. "I know what you can do."
Max's expression froze. His hands, resting on his knees, curled into fists.
"I don't know what you're talking about."
"Yes, you do. The doors that wouldn't open. The windows that wouldn't break. You did that." Ethan leaned forward slightly. "I'm not judging. I'm not here to hurt you. But I need to understand why."
For a long moment, Max said nothing. Then, slowly, his control cracked.
"You couldn't possibly understand," he whispered. "What he did to me. What they both did, for years and years and years. Do you know what it's like to be locked in a closet for days at a time? To have cigarettes put out on your arms? To be told you're worthless, that you're nothing, that you should never have been born?"
The words hit Ethan like physical blows. Abuse. Years of it, hidden behind the facade of a normal family.
"Max—"
"I didn't want to become this." Max's voice broke. "I tried to be normal. Tried to forget what I could do. But they kept pushing, kept hurting, kept reminding me that I was powerless against them." His eyes met Ethan's—and they were burning with something that wasn't quite human. "Until I wasn't."
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1