Chapter 14: Bloody Mary — Part 2
[Toledo, Ohio — October 2, 2005, Night]
The antique shop occupied a narrow storefront between a dry cleaner and a pawn shop. Faded letters on the window spelled "HARRINGTON'S ANTIQUES & CURIOSITIES." A hand-painted sign declared it closed for the evening.
Dean picked the lock in thirty seconds.
Inside, the shop was a maze of old furniture, vintage toys, and dusty knickknacks—the accumulated debris of lives ended or moved on. And mirrors. Dozens of mirrors, arranged on walls and shelves and propped against display cases.
Ethan's skin crawled the moment he crossed the threshold.
"She's here," he said quietly. "I can feel her."
"Where's the main mirror?" Dean had his shotgun ready—rock salt rounds, useless against mirrors but effective against ghosts. "Sam?"
"Back room. The owner keeps the valuable pieces separate." Sam moved through the shop with careful steps, avoiding the mirrors, flashlight sweeping the darkness.
Ethan followed, acutely aware of every reflective surface surrounding him. The Spirit pressed against his consciousness, alert and wary.
SHE WATCHES. FROM EVERY GLASS.
"I know."
WHEN SHE STRIKES, WE MUST BE READY.
"I know."
The back room was smaller, cluttered, filled with pieces awaiting restoration. In the center, propped against a workbench, stood a full-length mirror in an ornate frame.
Even without the Spirit's senses, Ethan would have known this was the one. The glass seemed darker than it should be, reflecting the room's contents with subtle wrongness. Something lurked in its depths—a shadow that didn't match anything in the physical world.
"That's it," Sam said. "The Worthington mirror. Documented chain of custody going back to 1963."
Dean raised his crowbar. "Let's smash it and—"
Every mirror in the shop lit up simultaneously.
Not with light—with presence. Mary Worthington's face appeared in dozens of reflective surfaces, multiplied and magnified, eyes replaced with black pits that wept blood.
"I see your secrets," she whispered. The voice came from everywhere and nowhere. "I see your deaths."
Sam stumbled backward. His reflection in the nearest mirror began to change—blood welling from his eyes, running down his cheeks in crimson streams.
"Sam!" Dean swung his crowbar at the mirror. It shattered, but Sam was already falling, hands pressed to his face, screaming.
Ethan moved toward them, but Mary's attention shifted.
To him.
Her eyes—those endless black pits—locked onto his through a dozen mirrors. Ethan felt her gaze like a physical weight, pressing into his mind, searching for the guilt she could use to kill him.
She found it.
His sister's face. Katie, twenty-three years old, smiling in a photograph he'd kept in his wallet until the day he died.
Katie, calling him in the middle of the night, voice trembling. He hit me again. I don't know what to do.
Katie, alone in that apartment while Ethan was deployed ten thousand miles away, unable to help, unable to protect her, unable to do anything but listen.
Katie, dead. Knife wound to the chest. Her boyfriend found three days later, hanged himself in a jail cell, and Ethan hadn't even been able to punish the bastard himself.
The guilt crashed over him like a wave. Thirty years of suppressed grief, of self-blame, of rage at his own powerlessness.
Mary drank it in.
"You let her die," the ghost whispered. "You could have saved her. You CHOSE not to."
"That's not—"
"Your fire. Your judgment. Your SINS." Mary's reflection pressed closer, bleeding eyes filling the mirror's surface. "Let me show you what you really are."
Ethan's reflection began to change.
His skin darkened. Cracked. Burned away to reveal bone wreathed in flame. The Rider stared back at him from the glass—not the controlled transformation he'd learned to manage, but something wilder, angrier, hungrier.
The reflection grinned with teeth made of fire.
SHE CANNOT HAVE YOU.
The Spirit surged.
Not outward, into transformation, but through the mirror. Ethan felt it happen—a part of himself launching across the glass like a weapon, meeting Mary's judgment with judgment of its own.
The ghost screamed.
Battle lines formed in the reflective surfaces. Two forces of punishment colliding—one ancient and bound to glass, one older still and bound to fire. Mary's victims had been human, vulnerable to guilt and fear. The Spirit was neither.
Images flashed through Ethan's mind. Mary's death—the surgeon standing over her, knife in hand, cutting out her eyes because she'd threatened to expose him. Mary's victims—guilty people, yes, but killed without mercy, without understanding, without the chance to choose differently.
And the Spirit's judgment: You punish the guilty. So do we. But we do not hide behind glass and secrets. We face our prey directly.
Mary Worthington broke.
Her form shattered across a dozen mirrors—fragmenting, dispersing, reforming in smaller and smaller pieces. She tried to flee, to escape through any reflective surface that would hold her, but the Spirit pursued.
"Dean!" Ethan's voice came out ragged. Blood was running from his eyes now—real blood, not ghostly illusion. "The main mirror! SMASH IT!"
Dean's crowbar hit the Worthington mirror dead center.
Glass exploded. Fragments scattered across the back room, catching moonlight and firelight in equal measure. Mary's scream reached a pitch that shattered the remaining mirrors in the shop, and then—
Silence.
Ethan collapsed.
His knees hit the floor hard, hands catching himself before his face could follow. Blood dripped from his eyes, spattering the ancient wood beneath him. His vision swam, doubled, threatened to fade entirely.
"Ethan!" Sam was there, pulling him upright, pressing something soft against his face. Tissues, probably. "Can you see? Are you okay?"
"Define okay."
"Your eyes are bleeding."
"I noticed." Ethan let Sam help him to a sitting position, back against the workbench. The blood was already slowing—Spirit-enhanced healing kicking in. "Mary?"
"Gone. Dean got the mirror." Sam's face was pale, his own cheeks marked with dried blood from the ghost's earlier attack. "What happened? Your reflection—it transformed without your body transforming."
"The Spirit." Ethan's voice came out rough. "It fought back through the mirror. Judgment against judgment."
"That's possible?"
"Apparently."
Dean appeared in the doorway, crowbar still in hand, expression tight with concern he was trying to hide. "We need to move. Someone probably heard all that glass breaking."
They moved. Ethan leaned on Sam more than he wanted to admit, legs unsteady, vision still swimming at the edges. The fight had cost him—not physically, but something deeper. The Spirit had exerted itself in ways it hadn't before, and Ethan could feel the strain like an overworked muscle.
SHE IS GONE. HER JUDGMENT WAS WEAK.
"She almost killed me."
SHE ALMOST KILLED THE HOST. WE WERE NEVER IN DANGER.
The distinction wasn't as comforting as the Spirit probably intended.
[Motel Room — October 2, 2005, Later]
Ethan sat on the edge of the bed, pressing fresh tissues to his eyes. The bleeding had stopped, but his vision remained blurry, unfocused.
Sam sat across from him, waiting.
"What did she show you?" Sam's voice was quiet. Not demanding—just asking, the way someone asks when they've seen the same abyss and want to know if you found bottom.
"My sister. Her death. My fault."
"You said you were deployed—"
"I could have gotten leave. Could have gone home. Could have killed the bastard myself before he got the chance." Ethan lowered the tissues. His eyes were red, bloodshot, but functional. "I made excuses. Told myself she could handle it. Told myself she'd leave him eventually."
"That's not the same as killing her."
"Tell that to the part of me that watched her die every night for three years afterward."
Sam was quiet for a long moment. Then: "Jess burned on the ceiling. Same way as our mom. I was in the room when it started—I saw her eyes open, saw her realize what was happening. By the time I got to her, she was already on fire."
"You couldn't have saved her."
"Neither could you."
The words hung between them. Two men, carrying ghosts that had nothing to do with the supernatural. Dead women who lived in their memories, judging them more harshly than any mirror ghost ever could.
"The Spirit fought for me," Ethan said finally. "Through the mirror. I didn't ask it to."
"Maybe it doesn't want to lose its host."
"Maybe." Or maybe, after weeks of coexisting, the Spirit had developed something resembling loyalty. Ethan didn't want to examine that possibility too closely.
The newspaper still covered his mirrors. He should remove it—Mary was dead, the threat was gone.
He couldn't make himself do it.
Some things, once seen, couldn't be unseen. His sister's face. The fire. The Rider staring back with eyes full of hunger.
The Spirit settled deeper in his chest, satisfied with the night's work.
REST. WE HAVE EARNED IT.
For once, Ethan agreed.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1