Chapter 6: THE ART OF LOSING
Monday morning. The bet began.
Jake arrived at the precinct buzzing with competitive energy, a coffee in each hand and a grin that suggested he'd been planning his victory speech all weekend.
"Cole! Ready to lose? Because I was born ready. Actually, I was born early and underweight, but that's not the point. The point is: I'm going to crush you."
"Morning to you too, Jake."
Charles had already installed the scoreboard by the break room door. It was exactly as elaborate as the outline had suggested—glitter, stickers, and somehow a photo of Jake's face in the center, wearing what appeared to be a crown made of solved-case folders.
"Charles," Amy said slowly, "where did you get that photo?"
"I have my sources." Charles adjusted a sticker that read PERALTA POWER. "The scoreboard must be worthy of the competition."
Jake examined his photo-kingdom with obvious satisfaction. "I look good. This is already the best week ever."
"The competition has begun, Host. And you're planning to throw it. I want you to know that I find this personally offensive."
I ignored the System and headed for my desk.
[Tuesday — 11:30 AM]
The car theft came in during the morning briefing.
2007 Honda Civic, silver, stolen from a parking garage on Atlantic Avenue. The owner was a teacher who'd come out of a staff meeting to find an empty space and a lot of broken glass.
Jake and I took the call together. Standard procedure for the week—Holt had assigned us as partners on most incoming cases, which made the bet's tracking cleaner.
The parking garage was dim, poorly maintained, and reeked of motor oil and stale cigarettes. Security cameras existed but hadn't worked since the Bush administration. The attendant was a teenager who'd been watching Netflix on his phone when the theft occurred.
Anomaly Detection activated the moment I stepped into the theft site.
[ANOMALY DETECTED: Glass pattern inconsistent with external break-in]
Yellow highlights materialized around the broken window's shards. The pattern was wrong—glass mostly inside the car, some scattered outside, but the distribution suggested the break had happened from within the vehicle, not outside it.
Someone had smashed the window from the inside to make it look like a theft.
Insurance fraud. Again.
"Seeing it, Host?"
I was seeing it. The scuff marks near the driver's door—someone had climbed in, not forced entry. The missing stereo system had been removed with tools, not ripped out in a hurry. This teacher had "stolen" her own car.
The answer was right there. All I had to do was point it out.
Instead, I turned away.
"I'm going to check the perimeter," I said. "See if there are any witnesses in the neighboring buildings."
"Good call." Jake was already examining the broken glass, not seeing what I'd seen. "I'll work the scene."
I walked around the corner of the parking structure and pretended to look for witnesses while Jake pieced together the evidence on his own. It took him forty minutes—longer than it would have taken me—but he got there.
"Cole! I've got it!" His voice echoed through the concrete structure. "The glass pattern's wrong. This was an inside job. The owner did it herself!"
I jogged back, doing my best surprised face. "Nice catch."
"Right? I knew something was off about her." Jake was already dialing the precinct. "Santiago, run financials on the Civic owner. Betting she's behind on car payments."
"This is painful to watch, Host. You had the answer in thirty seconds. He took forty minutes."
I know.
"You're letting him win."
That's the point.
[Wednesday — 3:15 PM]
The assault case should have been mine.
A bar fight that escalated, two guys in the hospital, and a witness who swore he'd seen the whole thing but whose story kept changing every time we asked. Standard he-said-she-said with blood involved.
Jake was working a separate B&E across town. This was my case, my collar, my points on the scoreboard.
Lie Detection pinged the moment the witness opened his mouth.
[LIE DETECTED: Timeline inconsistent] [LIE DETECTED: Position impossible given stated location] [TRUTH: Witness was participant, not observer]
The guy wasn't a witness. He was the third fighter—the one who'd started the whole thing and then pretended to be a bystander when the cops showed up. His injuries were hidden under his jacket, his story was garbage, and one pointed question would crack him wide open.
I didn't ask the pointed question.
"I'll need you to come down to the station for a formal statement," I said instead. "Can you do that tomorrow?"
"Sure, sure, anything to help."
"You're stalling. Why are you stalling?"
Because Jake needs this more than I do.
"Jake needs experience points more than you need survival? That's your position?"
My position is that I'm building a partnership, not a rivalry.
"Your position is going to get you killed."
Noted.
I let the witness go. Twenty-four hours later, Jake returned from his B&E with fresh eyes and caught the inconsistencies I'd deliberately overlooked. The "witness" cracked under Jake's interrogation—not because Jake was better, but because I'd set it up that way.
"Cole, you should have caught this!" Jake was half-laughing, half-incredulous. "The guy's story had more holes than Swiss cheese. Swiss cheese at a shooting range!"
"Must have missed it. Good work, Jake."
[JAKE PERALTA] [Standing: +34 → +36 (Victory Shared)]
[Thursday — 4:45 PM]
Amy noticed.
She cornered me in the break room while I was making my third coffee of the day. The line had dispersed—people had learned my schedule and timed their visits accordingly—which meant we were alone.
"Something's wrong with you this week."
"I'm fine."
"You missed the glass pattern on Monday until Jake pointed it out. You let a lying witness walk on Wednesday. Your case close rate is down forty percent from last week." She studied me with the same intensity she applied to spreadsheets. "You're not sick. You're not distracted. You're just... missing things."
[AMY SANTIAGO] [Standing: +30 → +28 (Suspicious)] [Flag: ANALYZING — She's building a case]
"Told you she'd notice, Host. Amy Santiago doesn't miss patterns. It's her whole thing."
"Bad week," I said. "Happens to everyone."
"Not to you. You don't have bad weeks. You have good weeks and slightly-less-good weeks." Amy frowned. "Last week you solved the bodega case in under an hour. You spotted evidence everyone else missed. This week you're making rookie mistakes. Why?"
"Maybe last week was the fluke."
"Or maybe this week is." She leaned against the counter, blocking my exit. "I like data, Marcus. And the data says something changed."
The coffee maker beeped. I poured my cup, buying time.
"I appreciate the concern, Amy. Really. But I'm fine. Just adjusting to the new precinct, new partner, new captain." I raised the cup. "See you out there."
I slipped past her before she could ask follow-up questions.
[AMY SANTIAGO] [Flag: UNCONVINCED — Will probably continue investigating]
"You're accumulating problems, Host. Amy's suspicious. The bet's not even over yet. And for what? Jake's ego?"
For Jake's friendship. There's a difference.
[Friday — 6:00 PM]
The final count: Jake, four cases. Marcus, two.
Charles updated the scoreboard with ceremonial gravity. Jake's photo-kingdom now included a scepter made of red tape and a cape constructed from solved-case reports. My side of the board featured a single sad sticker that said PARTICIPATION TROPHY.
"Victory!" Jake's celebration involved the entire bullpen, a carefully choreographed dance that absolutely no one had asked for, and a speech that somehow referenced both Die Hard and his childhood hamster.
I watched from my desk, genuinely smiling.
"You lost on purpose. The System is required to inform you that this has triggered a penalty."
[MISSION FAILED: Win Bet vs Jake Peralta] [Penalty: -15 EXP] [Current EXP: 25/200]
"Congratulations on your deliberate failure, Host. Hope it was worth it."
It was.
[JAKE PERALTA] [Standing: +36 → +40 (Victory Achieved)] [Flag: GENEROUS — Win has improved his mood significantly]
[Shaw's Bar — 8:30 PM]
Jake bought the first round with my money.
"To losing gracefully!" He raised his glass, grinning at me across the table. "And to Marcus Cole, who's a good sport even when he's getting absolutely destroyed in a fair competition."
I raised my own glass. "Fair competition."
"Totally fair. Completely fair. Some might say suspiciously fair, but those people are jealous of my detective prowess."
Amy was watching me. I could feel her analysis-eyes cataloging my reactions, building her case that something was off.
Rosa sat at the end of the booth, nursing her whiskey. She hadn't said much all night, but when Jake finished his victory lap and the conversation moved on to other topics, she caught my eye.
A microscopic smirk crossed her face.
[ROSA DIAZ] [Standing: +12 → +14 (Amusement)] [Flag: SHE KNOWS — Something about her expression suggests awareness]
"The scary one suspects you threw the bet."
I know.
"She's not going to say anything."
I know.
"That's very Rosa."
It really was.
[Shaw's Bar — 10:45 PM]
The crowd had thinned. Charles had left to pursue a lead on a rare Manchego. Amy was still asking questions, but her energy was fading. Jake was contentedly drunk, basking in the afterglow of victory.
Rosa finished her whiskey and stood.
"Cole. Walk."
Not a question. Not a request.
I followed her outside.
The night air was cool, carrying the smell of impending autumn and distant pizza. Rosa's motorcycle was parked at the curb, helmet hanging from the handlebar.
"You let him win."
Statement. Not accusation.
"Did I?"
"Don't." Her eyes met mine, sharp and uncompromising. "Don't insult my intelligence. You're better than your performance this week. We both know it."
[ROSA DIAZ] [Standing: +14 → +16 (Direct Confrontation)]
"She's testing you, Host. How you respond here matters."
I didn't deny it. With Rosa, denial would be worse than admission.
"Jake needed a win more than I did."
Silence. She studied me for a long moment, something calculating behind her dark eyes.
"That's either very smart or very stupid."
"Maybe both?"
Her lip twitched. That almost-smile again. "Yeah. Maybe both."
She mounted her motorcycle, pulled on her helmet. The visor stayed up.
"Don't make a habit of it," she said. "Playing dumb. It's annoying to watch."
"Noted."
The engine roared to life. She pulled away from the curb without looking back.
I stood on the sidewalk, watching her taillights disappear into Brooklyn's Friday night traffic, and wondered if I'd just made a friend or a problem.
"Possibly both, Host. With Rosa Diaz, it's usually both."
[Marcus's Apartment — 11:30 PM]
The apartment was quiet.
I sat on the edge of my bed, reviewing the week's damage. Bet lost—intentionally. Experience penalty applied—acceptable cost. Amy suspicious—manageable problem. Rosa aware—unclear consequences.
Jake happy. Partnership stronger. That was what mattered.
[CURRENT STATUS] [Level: 2] [EXP: 25/200] [Mental Stamina: 100/110]
Not great progress. The System made its disappointment clear through pointed silence rather than commentary.
But outside the numbers, outside the missions and rewards, something else had happened this week.
Jake trusted me more. Rosa acknowledged me as something other than furniture. Charles had already planned next week's scoreboard ("in case of rematch"). Amy's suspicion meant she was paying attention—not ideal, but it meant I'd registered as worth analyzing.
I was becoming part of the squad.
Not just a new transfer. Not just a warm body filling a desk. An actual member of the team.
The System didn't give points for that. There was no [+10 EXP: Made Friends] notification flashing in my vision.
But it mattered anyway.
"You're treating this like a social experiment rather than a survival situation, Host. I want you to understand that when things go wrong—and they will go wrong—you won't be able to friendship your way out of it."
"Maybe. But I'll have people watching my back."
"Will you? Or will you have people who don't know what you are, what you can do, what you're hiding? That's not the same thing as backup, Host. That's liability."
I didn't have an answer for that.
The System was right—I was keeping secrets from everyone. The transmigration. The foreknowledge. The abilities that made me better than I had any right to be. If any of it came out, the trust I'd been building would evaporate faster than Jake's attention span.
But the alternative was isolation. Working alone. Treating everyone like NPCs in a game I was playing solo.
I'd tried that in my old life. It hadn't ended well.
"Your old life ended in a car accident, Host. Not exactly a ringing endorsement of your decision-making."
Thanks for the reminder.
"I'm here to help."
I lay back on the bed, staring at the ceiling that was slowly becoming familiar. The water stain shaped like Florida. The crack in the corner. The faint hum of the radiator that would become crucial in a few months when winter hit.
Next week would bring new cases. New challenges. Maybe the Vulture—the case-stealing nightmare Jake had mentioned during my first day. Maybe something else entirely.
Whatever came, I'd face it with the squad.
Even if they didn't know everything about me. Even if I was lying every time I said "good instincts" instead of "supernatural detective system living in my brain."
Some lies were worth telling.
"That's either very philosophical or very naive, Host. I haven't decided which."
"Let me know when you figure it out."
"Will do. Now get some sleep. You've got a bet to not-lose next time."
I closed my eyes.
Tomorrow was another day in Brooklyn.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!