Chapter 121 – 74 Laurel Street and the Long-Lost Diary (Part Two)
"Grandma? It's me, Phoebe." Her voice carried a tremor she barely noticed. "I need to ask you something, and I really need you to be straight with me this time. My dad — you told me he was a tree surgeon. Living in Burma. That was the truth, right?"
On the other end of the line, the old woman held to the story for a moment longer, her voice carrying the stubborn, practiced quality of someone who has told a lie so many times it has calcified into something that feels like memory.
Phoebe cut through it. "Grandma. Listen to me. There's a boy sitting across from me right now. His name is Frank Junior. He says his father is Frank Buffay — my father. And he has a diary. Dad's diary. It's right here in front of me, and it says in his own handwriting that he came back to New York. That he used to stand across the street and watch me and Ursula when we were kids." Her voice broke slightly on the last word. "So I'm asking you one more time."
The line went completely silent. Not the comfortable silence of someone thinking — the specific, airless silence of a secret that has just run out of room.
When her grandmother finally spoke, her voice was different. Lower. The particular tone of someone setting something down that they've been carrying for a very long time. "Oh, Phoebe, sweetheart. All right. I know. I've always known." A long pause. "I lied. For years. It was your mother's idea, really — she didn't want you to have anything to do with your father after he left. He broke her heart. And honestly, as far as I was concerned, any man who walks out on his family and then drives off in someone's beloved car deserves whatever story gets told about him."
Phoebe's hand tightened around the phone. "What was he actually? If not a tree surgeon in Burma?"
"A pharmacist," her grandmother said quietly. "He worked at the CVS in Middletown. Lived at 74 Laurel Street." A pause. "If you pass a place called Queen's Diner, you've gone too far." Another pause, softer now. "Phoebe? Sweetheart, are you still there?"
Phoebe didn't answer. She set the phone carefully back in its cradle, turned around, and looked at Frank Junior across the table. Her face was pale, but her eyes had gone very clear.
"74 Laurel Street, Middletown," she said. "He was a pharmacist."
Frank Junior's eyes went wide. He sat forward. "Yes. Exactly. That's — yeah, that's the house. That's where we lived." He stared at her. "You really are my sister."
"Half-sister," Phoebe said automatically, and then smiled in spite of herself. "But yeah."
The room exhaled.
Phoebe looked at him for a moment — this kid in the too-big denim jacket who had walked into Central Perk an hour ago and turned her entire understanding of her own history upside down — and something settled in her expression. Not resolution, exactly. But the beginning of it.
"So," she said carefully. "Our dad. How is he?"
Frank Junior's face shifted. He scratched the back of his neck with the sheepish expression of someone about to deliver news that is both bad and, in a specific way, absurd. "Honestly? I haven't seen him in about four years."
"Four years?" The reaction came from multiple directions simultaneously — Monica, Rachel, Ross, all of them.
"Yeah." Frank Junior shrugged with the resigned ease of someone who has had time to make peace with a ridiculous fact. "About four years ago he said the fridge was getting low and he was going to run to the store. Milk and bread." He looked around the table. "He didn't come back."
The table went quiet.
Chandler broke it first, in the tone of someone who cannot physically stop himself. "So he's been in the dairy aisle for four years. That is an extremely thorough grocery run."
Ross elbowed him. Chandler's expression said he agreed that was probably uncalled for, while also being unable to fully commit to regret.
The absurdity of it did something useful — it cut through the emotional intensity of the last few minutes and let everyone breathe. Even Phoebe managed a small, disbelieving laugh.
"Did he ever—" She stopped, steadied herself, tried again. "Did he ever mention me? Either of us?"
Frank Junior shook his head, and he was honest about it in the way that teenage boys sometimes are — no softening, no hedge, just the plain truth delivered without drama. "No. Not once. I didn't even know you existed until I found that diary." He thought for a second. "My mom probably didn't know about you guys either. I don't think he told her."
A flicker of something moved across Phoebe's face. But she nodded. "Okay," she said. "Okay." And then, because she was Phoebe and that was how she worked through things: "Tell me something good about him. Something real."
Frank Junior thought about it. Then his face changed — the particular brightening of someone accessing a memory they actually like. "He's really into stilt-walking."
Several people around the table processed that word individually.
"Stilt-walking," Phoebe repeated.
"He built them himself, out in the backyard. Really tall ones. He'd just — walk around out there when he had nothing else to do. Or go a few laps on the empty lot down the block." Frank Junior grinned. "He said the view looked different from up there."
"That is either very philosophical or very concerning," Chandler said.
"One time," Frank Junior continued, warming to the story, "I was like eight years old, sneaking into my parents' room to grab a couple bucks from my mom's purse. Candy money. I was being super quiet, totally convinced I was pulling this off — and then I turned around." He paused for effect. "Dad's face. Right outside the second-floor window. Big grin. Right at eye level, because he was on the stilts."
"Oh no," Rachel said.
"I screamed. Fell off the chair. He thought it was the funniest thing that had ever happened." Frank Junior was laughing now. "Then he took a dollar out of his own wallet, slid it through the window gap, and whispered, 'Don't tell your mother.'"
Laughter broke around the table — genuine, warm, the kind that arrives when a story lands exactly right.
Phoebe was laughing too, but her eyes were bright in a way that had nothing to do with amusement. Through two minutes of a story about stilts and candy money and a second-floor window, she had gotten more of her father than she'd ever had before.
"What else?" she said.
Frank Junior settled in. He talked about their father the way people talk about someone who was genuinely, specifically, incorrigibly themselves — he collected vintage jazz records and played them at volumes that upset the neighbors, he named every houseplant in the house after a different Supreme Court justice, he was a catastrophic cook who ate his own disasters with complete satisfaction and declared them "interesting," he tinkered endlessly with old radio parts and built things that didn't work and was tremendously proud of them anyway. He forgot his umbrella every single time it rained, without exception, for as long as Frank Junior could remember.
Each detail landed in Phoebe like something being placed carefully in a space that had been empty for a long time.
By the time Frank Junior looked up and registered that the light outside had shifted considerably, the stiffness between them had dissolved entirely. He wasn't a stranger with a notebook anymore. He was a kid who shared her last name and a father who walked on stilts and named his plants after judges.
He stood up and checked his watch. "I gotta catch the last bus back to Middletown." He picked up the diary from the table and held it out across the table to her. "Here. You keep it."
Phoebe looked at it.
"Most of it's pretty heavy reading," Frank Junior admitted. "He was kind of brooding in private, apparently. But it's honest. And it's his actual handwriting." He paused. "I thought you should have it."
Phoebe took the diary. It sat in her hands with the particular weight of something that had been waiting a long time to be found.
She looked up at him as he turned toward the door, and something shifted in her expression — a decision made, quick and warm and very Phoebe.
"Hey." He turned back. "Have you eaten?"
Frank Junior blinked. "Not since the bus."
"Okay." She stood up and grabbed her coat. "There's a burger place on the corner. You're coming." She pointed at him with the authority of someone who has just promoted herself to a new role and intends to take it seriously. "And for the record, as your older sister, I feel it is my responsibility to tell you that jacket is at least two sizes too big and that is absolutely something we are going to discuss."
Frank Junior stared at her.
Then he broke into the biggest, most unguarded grin she'd seen from him all evening. "Okay. Yeah. Let's go."
Phoebe tucked the diary under her arm, linked her free arm through his, and steered him toward the door with the easy confidence of someone who has been doing this forever, even though she hadn't been doing it for even an hour.
She glanced back at the group as they reached the door. "Don't wait up!"
The door swung shut behind them. Through the window, the group watched them disappear around the corner of Bedford Street — Phoebe doing most of the talking, Frank Junior listening with the expression of someone realizing that finding a sister was considerably stranger and better than he'd expected.
Inside Central Perk, nobody said anything for a moment.
Then Monica said, quietly and with genuine feeling: "She's going to be so good at that."
Nobody disagreed.
[Community Goals Ongoing]
500 PS = +1 Extra Chapter
10 Reviews = +1 Extra Chapter
Reviews are always appreciated.
P1treon Soulforger (20+advance chapters)