Caroline's grip on my arm was the only thing keeping me from turning the truck around.
"It's Thanksgiving," she said, her voice carrying that particular Caroline Forbes tone that meant arguing was useless. "Normal human fun. Turkey and pie and pretending families aren't complicated. You need this, Matt. I need this. We're going."
She wasn't wrong about the need. I'd spent the past week training with Alaric until my muscles screamed, meditating with Grams' technique until my head throbbed, shadowboxing in my bathroom mirror until my reflection started to look like a stranger. A few hours of pretend normalcy might be exactly what I needed to stay sane.
But normal was hard to maintain when Stefan Salvatore was already visible through the Gilbert house window, helping Jenna carry dishes to the dining room table.
"You're doing that thing again," Caroline said as I parked.
"What thing?"
"The brooding thing. The staring-into-the-middle-distance thing. It's very Stefan of you, actually." She poked my shoulder. "Stop it. Today is about gratitude and carbs. Not whatever existential crisis you've been having lately."
I forced a smile. "No existential crisis. Just hungry."
"Better." She kissed my cheek and climbed out of the truck. "Now let's go eat our weight in stuffing."
We entered into controlled chaos—the good kind, the kind that only happened when too many people tried to share a kitchen that wasn't designed for crowd cooking. Elena was laughing at something Jeremy had said while stirring gravy. Jenna was directing traffic with a wooden spoon, somehow managing to oversee three conversations simultaneously. The air smelled like roasting turkey and cinnamon and something that might have been burned rolls.
And there was Stefan, carefully arranging napkins with the precise attention of someone who'd probably attended a thousand Thanksgiving dinners across a century and a half of existence.
Bonnie stood near the counter, ostensibly helping with salad but mostly watching Stefan with an expression I recognized all too well. The careful observation. The slight tension around her eyes. The way she positioned herself to keep him in her peripheral vision even when she appeared focused on chopping vegetables.
She knows something's wrong with him. Grams has been talking.
"Matt! Caroline!" Elena swept us into the festivities with the practiced ease of someone desperate for more bodies between herself and the kitchen disasters. "Perfect timing. You're on mashed potato duty. Try to save them from Bonnie's salt obsession."
"My salt usage is perfectly reasonable," Bonnie protested, but there was something mechanical about her response. Her eyes flicked to me—just for a second—and I saw the questions there. Questions she was saving for later.
"Some of us actually have functioning taste buds," she continued, recovering her rhythm. "Unlike certain people who think unseasoned chicken is acceptable dinner food."
"That was ONE time," Elena groaned. "And I was twelve."
The banter was warm, familiar, almost enough to make me forget the supernatural war simmering beneath the surface. Caroline dove into cooking with enthusiasm that far exceeded her actual skill, and I stationed myself at the stove to subtly correct her mistakes before they became disasters. Too much salt in the potatoes—I added more cream. Butter starting to burn—I adjusted the heat. The small domestic dance of saving a meal without letting your girlfriend know you were saving it.
"You're hovering," Caroline said without looking up from her aggressive mashing.
"I'm helping."
"You're hovering helpfully. There's a difference." She hip-checked me away from the stove. "Go be social. I've got this."
I retreated to the living room, where Jeremy was setting up some card game and Jenna was arranging appetizers on the coffee table. Stefan caught my eye across the room. The vampire's expression was carefully neutral, but I could read the question underneath: Is this safe? Should we be here?
I gave a slight nod. Thanksgiving at the Gilbert house, surrounded by humans who didn't know what lurked in their town. It was the safest any of us had been in weeks. No dark alleys, no empty parking lots, no opportunities for monsters to strike without witnesses.
Then Damon walked through the front door.
"Happy Thanksgiving!" His voice carried perfectly, pitched to charm with a century of practice behind it. "I brought wine. The good stuff, not that grocery store swill Jenna pretends to enjoy."
"Damon!" Jenna's face lit up with the particular warmth of someone who had no idea they were welcoming a predator into their home. "I didn't know you were coming."
"Stefan's idea." The lie came with a smile that made it impossible to challenge publicly. Stefan's jaw tightened, but he said nothing. "He mentioned you were hosting, and I simply couldn't resist. Family holidays are so important, don't you think? All those traditions. All that... togetherness."
His eyes found mine across the crowded room. The charm dropped for just a moment, replaced by something cold and calculating. A reminder of our conversation at my trailer. A promise that this wasn't over.
He came here to make a point. To prove he can reach me anywhere, anytime, surrounded by anyone.
"Matt." Damon crossed the room with predatory grace, weaving between furniture and people with the ease of someone who'd spent centuries navigating social situations. He extended his hand. "So good to see you again. I heard you've been spending time with my brother lately. Bonding over... history projects, was it?"
I shook his hand because refusing would draw questions I couldn't answer. His grip was controlled, but I felt the threat underneath—the strength that could crush my bones without effort, restrained only by the presence of witnesses.
"Something like that."
"Wonderful." He released me and turned his attention to Caroline, his smile sharpening into something that made my stomach clench. "And the lovely Miss Forbes. That's a beautiful bracelet you're wearing. Very... handcrafted."
Caroline beamed, completely oblivious to the layers of meaning beneath his words. "Matt made it for me. Isn't it sweet? He's surprisingly artistic for a jock."
"Sweet." Damon's eyes met mine again, and this time there was genuine amusement mixed with the menace. "Very sweet. You're quite the craftsman, Mattie. Working with your hands. Creating things. Protecting the people you care about."
"I try."
"I'm sure you do." He clapped me on the shoulder—hard enough to sting, soft enough that no one else would notice. "We should talk more. Compare notes on our respective... hobbies."
Dinner was an exercise in social torture.
Damon positioned himself directly across from me at the table, using every opportunity to probe and provoke. Innocent questions with poisoned undertones. Compliments that felt like threats. The kind of verbal warfare that only made sense if you knew what was really happening beneath the pleasant surface.
"So Matt," he said, passing the cranberry sauce with exaggerated politeness, "I hear you've been picking up extra shifts at the Grill. Working late nights. Walking home alone through those dark streets." He smiled. "Dangerous neighborhood, Mystic Falls. You never know what might be lurking in the shadows."
"I can take care of myself."
"Can you? That's admirable. Self-reliance. Independence." He took a deliberate bite of turkey. "Although I've always found that the people who say they can take care of themselves are usually the ones who end up needing the most... assistance."
"Damon," Stefan said quietly. A warning.
"What? I'm making conversation. Being sociable. Isn't that what holidays are for?" Damon raised his wine glass. "To family. And to the interesting people trying to be part of it."
Everyone drank. I drank. The wine tasted like ashes.
Under the table, Caroline's hand found mine. Her grip was questioning, concerned. She'd picked up on the tension even if she didn't understand its source.
She knows something's wrong. She just doesn't know what.
After dinner, I escaped to the kitchen under pretense of helping with dessert. Stefan followed moments later, and we spoke in whispers while loading the dishwasher with plates that still had gravy smears.
"He's testing boundaries," Stefan said, his voice barely audible over the running water. "Seeing how close he can get, how much he can provoke before someone breaks cover."
"Can he do anything here? With this many witnesses?"
"Damon doesn't care about witnesses when he's angry enough." Stefan's expression was grim. "He killed Mr. Tanner in front of the entire football team. Compelled everyone to remember it as an animal attack. He could do the same to anyone in this room."
My hands tightened on the plate I was holding. "Then why hasn't he?"
"Because he's not angry. He's entertained." Stefan paused, something dark flickering across his face. "That's almost worse. When Damon's entertained, he draws things out. Makes it a game. Plays with his prey before the kill."
"How do I end the game?"
Stefan had no answer. Just silence and the clink of dishes being stacked.
We returned to the living room, where Damon was regaling Jenna with stories about his travels through Europe. His charm was fully deployed, making him seem like exactly what he pretended to be—Stefan's handsome, worldly older brother who just happened to have excellent taste in wine and an encyclopedic knowledge of Italian architecture.
Caroline's mashed potatoes arrived for dessert—a side dish she'd insisted on adding to the spread despite my subtle attempts at sabotage. They were lumpy, under-seasoned, and somehow both too dry and too wet simultaneously. A culinary paradox that defied explanation.
I ate three servings and told her they were perfect.
She beamed at me, her whole face lighting up with pleasure at the compliment. "Really? I thought they were maybe a little—"
"Perfect," I repeated. "Best I've ever had."
For just a moment, the supernatural politics faded into background noise. This was why I fought. This smile. This girl who saw the best in everything and everyone, including my terrible lies and her own lumpy potatoes.
"They're really not that good," she whispered, laughing quietly. "But thank you for pretending."
"They're yours. That makes them perfect."
Damon caught the exchange from across the room, and something flickered in his expression. Disgust, maybe. Or jealousy. Or just the predatory interest of a creature watching prey exhibit attachment behavior. It was hard to tell with someone who'd perfected their masks across centuries of manipulation.
The party wound down around ten. Caroline and I escaped into the crisp November air, leaving the Gilberts to their cleanup and the Salvatore brothers to whatever private war they'd continue fighting once the humans were safely ignorant.
"What's the deal with you and Damon Salvatore?" Caroline asked as we drove toward her house, the streetlights washing over her face in rhythmic orange pulses. "You two kept staring at each other. It was kind of intense. Like, weirdly intense. Did something happen?"
I considered the truth. Considered telling her about vampires and blood magic and the monster who'd killed my sister. Considered the look on her face when she realized the bracelet she loved was actually supernatural protection against a predator who'd wanted to make her his victim.
Not yet. She wasn't ready. I wasn't ready to put that weight on her shoulders.
"Long story," I said. "Nothing important."
She didn't believe me—I could see it in the way she watched my face, in the slight furrow between her brows—but she let it go. That was Caroline's gift: knowing when to push and when to wait, even when waiting clearly frustrated her.
I walked her to her door and kissed her goodnight, the vervain bracelet warm against my wrist where our hands intertwined.
"Happy Thanksgiving, Matt."
"Happy Thanksgiving, Caroline."
I drove home with Damon's presence still echoing in my thoughts. He'd proven he could reach me anywhere, anytime, surrounded by anyone. The game wasn't over—it was just beginning.
And I needed more allies before he decided to stop playing.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0