The ancient stone corridors of Hogwarts Castle had witnessed many confrontations over the centuries—magical duels between rival Houses, passionate debates about curriculum reform, the occasional catastrophic experiment involving first-years and animation charms gone spectacularly wrong. But the particular brand of tension currently filling the Headmaster's office was something altogether different, something that suggested diplomacy might be losing a very slow but decisive battle against the combined forces of American pragmatism, British legal precision, and what could only be described as Constantine's general approach to authority figures, which was to treat them with approximately the same respect he afforded particularly persistent telemarketers.
Albus Dumbledore sat behind his desk like a monument to benevolent wisdom—or at least, like someone who'd spent decades perfecting the aesthetic. His robes were midnight blue scattered with silver stars that probably had symbolic significance if you were the sort of person who thought clothing should carry metaphorical weight. His silver beard was precisely groomed, his half-moon spectacles perched with studied casualness, and his blue eyes held the sort of twinkle that suggested he found the entire world gently amusing in ways that mere mortals couldn't quite grasp.
Behind him, Fawkes the phoenix observed proceedings with the kind of regal disinterest that only phoenixes and particularly self-satisfied cats could achieve. The portraits of former Headmasters lined the walls, pretending to sleep but absolutely eavesdropping because gossip was apparently the primary currency of painted personalities. The various silver instruments scattered throughout the office emitted occasional puffs of smoke and soft mechanical sounds, as if Dumbledore's predecessor had really enjoyed Rube Goldberg machines and decided to make that everyone else's problem.
Across from Dumbledore, arranged in what could charitably be called "visiting delegation" and uncharitably called "invasion force with paperwork," sat Giovanni Zatara, John Constantine, Ted Tonks, and approximately four MACUSA representatives who looked like they'd rather be literally anywhere else, including potentially at the bottom of the Black Lake being nibbled on by grindylows.
Giovanni occupied his chair with the kind of theatrical grace that suggested he'd learned posture from Renaissance paintings and decided to make it everyone else's problem. His dark hair was styled with more care than most people applied to their wedding days, his traveling robes were tailored with suspicious precision, and he sat with the relaxed confidence of someone who'd performed for audiences that included actual royalty and hadn't been particularly impressed.
Constantine, by contrast, had claimed his chair like it was a barstool in a particularly disreputable pub and he'd been coming there for years. His trench coat had seen better decades, possibly better centuries. His tie sat at an angle that violated several principles of formal attire. A cigarette dangled from nicotine-stained fingers despite the clearly posted "No Smoking" signs that Dumbledore probably thought would be respected because he was accustomed to people respecting his authority. The ashtray Constantine had conjured—because of course he'd conjured his own ashtray rather than use Dumbledore's perfectly good one—was filling with ash and the remnants of cynicism.
Ted Tonks occupied the space between theatrical elegance and determined dishevelment with the efficient competence of someone who'd spent decades navigating British magical society's numerous incomprehensible rules while maintaining his sanity through sheer bloody-minded persistence. His robes were respectable but not ostentatious, his briefcase was leather and looked like it contained enough documentation to wallpaper a small castle, and his expression carried the particular kind of patience that came from being a solicitor specializing in magical law, which meant dealing with people who thought "because magic" was acceptable legal reasoning.
The MACUSA representatives—three Aurors and one senior bureaucrat whose title was so elaborate it required abbreviation—sat with the rigid posture of people who'd been briefed extensively about British magical politics and had concluded that everyone involved needed therapy, better record-keeping systems, and possibly adult supervision.
"Gentlemen," Dumbledore said, his voice carrying the warm grandfatherly quality he'd perfected over decades of managing impossible situations, "I must confess, when I received your request for this meeting, I was both surprised and hopeful. It has been five years since young Harry vanished from his relatives' care, five years of searching without success, five years of wondering whether the Boy Who Lived survived his second great tragedy."
He leaned forward slightly, his expression shifting into something that managed to convey both concern and gentle reproach. "I trust your presence here means you have information about Harry's whereabouts? That you've located him and can assure me of his safety?"
Constantine took a long drag from his cigarette, exhaled smoke in a manner that somehow conveyed profound disrespect despite being just basic physics, and fixed Dumbledore with a look that suggested he'd met approximately ten thousand people who thought they were special and Dumbledore wasn't even in the top hundred.
"That's a very interesting way of phrasing things, Headmaster," Constantine said, his Liverpool accent making every word sound slightly accusatory even when technically neutral. "You're 'hoping' we have information about Harry's location. You're 'wondering' about his safety. All very passive, very concerned, very 'I'm just a worried educator who lost track of a student.' Except Harry Potter wasn't your student when he vanished—he was six years old, living with relatives you personally placed him with, under monitoring systems you personally established."
"I—" Dumbledore started, but Constantine wasn't finished.
"So let's perhaps rephrase the question, yeah?" Constantine continued, stubbing out his cigarette and immediately lighting another one because apparently nicotine was essential for tactical confrontation. "How about: 'Constantine, Zatara, why did you show up with American Aurors, an ICW investigation team, and Britain's most expensive magical solicitor if you're just here to have a friendly chat about a missing kid?' That seems like a more honest opening, don't you think?"
The MACUSA contingent sat very still, expressions carefully neutral in the way of people who were absolutely loving this confrontation but had been specifically instructed not to show it because international diplomacy required pretending to be professional.
Giovanni, who had been studying one of Dumbledore's silver instruments with apparent fascination, chose this moment to contribute with the sort of timing that suggested he'd been practicing dramatic interventions since childhood.
"Mr. Constantine has a point, Headmaster Dumbledore," Giovanni said, his accent adding musical quality to what was fundamentally an accusation. "Your letter to MACUSA requesting this meeting was carefully worded, expressing concern about Harry's welfare while simultaneously requesting any information we might have about his location. But you never explained why you lost track of him in the first place, why your monitoring systems failed, or what steps you took when you discovered he was missing."
"I am not required to explain my decisions to MACUSA," Dumbledore replied, and there was just a hint of steel underneath the grandfatherly warmth now—the tone of someone who was accustomed to his authority being respected and was discovering it might not be in this particular context. "Harry Potter is a British citizen, under British magical jurisdiction, and while I appreciate international concern for his welfare, the matter of his placement and monitoring was handled according to British protocols."
"Protocols that apparently involved placing him with abusive relatives and then failing to notice when they abandoned him in a foreign country," Ted Tonks interjected with the kind of precise legal delivery that suggested he'd been preparing this particular line of attack for some time. "Mr. Dumbledore, I'm here representing several interested parties who have concerns about how young Mr. Potter's guardianship has been managed since his parents' tragic deaths. Would you be willing to explain, for the record, why you chose to place Harry with the Dursleys despite them being non-magical, despite their documented hostility toward magic, and despite the availability of numerous magical guardians who volunteered to raise the Boy Who Lived?"
Dumbledore's expression grew more guarded, the grandfatherly warmth cooling slightly as he recognized this wasn't a friendly inquiry but something considerably more formal and potentially threatening to his carefully maintained image.
"Harry needed to be placed with blood relatives," Dumbledore said, his voice taking on the patient tone of someone explaining something obvious to people who really should understand already. "His mother's sacrifice created powerful magical protections that required reinforcement through blood connection. Placing him with Petunia Dursley, his mother's sister, ensured those protections would remain active, keeping Harry safe from Voldemort's remaining followers."
"Blood wards," Giovanni said thoughtfully, still examining the silver instrument with apparent fascination though his attention was clearly on the conversation. "Those are Dark Age magic, Headmaster. Very old, very powerful, very rarely used in modern practice because they require specific circumstances and tend to have unfortunate side effects when the people providing the blood connection don't actually care about the person being protected."
"The magic doesn't require affection," Dumbledore replied, and there was something defensive in his tone now. "It requires blood connection and the willingness of the guardian to take the child into their home. Mrs. Dursley provided both, which was sufficient for the wards' establishment."
"But not sufficient for the child's actual welfare," Ted Tonks observed with the kind of bland legal precision that was somehow more devastating than overt accusation. "Mr. Dumbledore, are you familiar with the concept of magical duty of care? It's a principle in British magical law that establishes that any person in a position of authority over a child—whether as guardian, educator, or designated protector—has legal responsibility to ensure that child's physical and emotional welfare."
"I am familiar with the principle, yes," Dumbledore said carefully.
"Then you'll understand why my clients have concerns about your decision to place Harry Potter with relatives who, according to witness testimony, treated him with what can charitably be described as profound neglect and what can accurately be described as systematic emotional abuse." Ted Tonks opened his briefcase with practiced efficiency, withdrawing a substantial stack of documents that had been organized with the kind of intimidating precision that suggested someone had been preparing for this conversation for quite some time.
"These are statements from Mrs. Arabella Figg, the Squib you designated to monitor Harry's welfare," Ted continued, placing the first document on Dumbledore's desk with the careful precision of someone laying explosive charges. "According to Mrs. Figg's testimony—which, I should note, she provided voluntarily and under Veritaserum at her own insistence—Harry Potter was frequently denied food as punishment, forced to sleep in a cupboard under the stairs, dressed in clothing so oversized it constituted a safety hazard, and generally treated as though his existence was an inconvenience to be tolerated rather than a child to be nurtured."
Dumbledore's expression grew pained, though whether from genuine distress or tactical recognition that this was not going to be the conversation he'd anticipated was unclear. "Mrs. Figg's reports to me indicated that while the Dursleys were not warm toward Harry, he was adequately cared for. I understood the situation was not ideal, but I believed the protection provided by the blood wards justified some... discomfort."
"Some discomfort," Constantine repeated, his voice flat and dangerous in the way it got when he was approximately three seconds from setting something on fire just to make a point. "Malnutrition, emotional abuse, and forced servitude—because yeah, making a kid cook and clean like a house-elf is servitude—that's 'some discomfort' in your assessment? Christ, Dumbledore, what exactly would constitute actual abuse in your framework? Do they have to use Crucio before it crosses the line?"
"I never—" Dumbledore started, but Ted Tonks was already placing another document on the desk.
"This is testimony from neighbors in Little Whinging who observed Harry's treatment over the years," Ted said with relentless legal precision. "They describe a child who was visibly underfed, poorly dressed, and frequently seen performing yard work and household maintenance while the Dursleys' biological son was encouraged to be, and I quote, 'a right little tyrant who terrorized the neighborhood children without consequence.'"
"The Dursleys were not ideal guardians," Dumbledore conceded, though his tone suggested he was being forced into admissions he'd rather not make. "But the alternative—placing Harry with magical guardians who would have raised him knowing he was famous, potentially developing the kind of arrogance that comes from being celebrated before one has actually achieved anything—that seemed more dangerous to his character development than temporary discomfort."
"Temporary discomfort lasting ten years," Giovanni observed. "Headmaster, I have considerable experience with child psychology through my work with young magical practitioners. What you're describing isn't character building through adversity—it's systematic trauma that would require extensive therapeutic intervention to address. The fact that you prioritized your theories about character development over Harry's actual wellbeing suggests either profound misunderstanding of child development or deliberate disregard for his welfare in service of some larger plan."
The MACUSA representatives, who had been maintaining diplomatic neutrality up to this point, exchanged glances that suggested they were rapidly revising their assessments of British magical leadership and finding those assessments increasingly unflattering.
Dumbledore was quiet for a long moment, his hands steepled in front of him in the sort of contemplative pose that probably looked wise in contexts where people weren't actively documenting his failures as a guardian. When he spoke, his voice carried the weight of someone who'd made difficult decisions and was prepared to defend them despite mounting evidence that those decisions had been catastrophically wrong.
"I believed," Dumbledore said slowly, "that Harry needed to grow up away from the influence of magical fame, away from adults who would either coddle him because of his parents' sacrifice or fear him because of Voldemort's downfall. I believed he needed to develop humility, resilience, and the kind of character that comes from facing adversity without magic as a crutch. I believed that when he returned to the magical world at eleven, he would be better prepared to handle his fame and responsibility than if he'd spent his childhood being celebrated and indulged."
"So you deliberately placed him in an abusive situation because you thought it would be good for him," Constantine summarized with the kind of flat affect that made the statement sound even more damning than loud accusation would have been. "You made a strategic decision that Harry Potter's childhood suffering was acceptable cost for your vision of what kind of person he should become. That's not guardianship, Dumbledore. That's social engineering with a child as your experimental subject."
"I did what I believed was necessary to prepare Harry for the burden he would inevitably have to bear," Dumbledore replied, and there was something approaching defiance in his voice now. "Voldemort will return—I have never doubted this. When he does, Harry will need to face him, and I believed that a childhood of comfort and adulation would ill-prepare him for that confrontation."
Ted Tonks set down his documents with the kind of controlled precision that suggested he was working very hard not to throw them at Dumbledore's face. "Mr. Dumbledore, what you've just described is using a child as a weapon. Not protecting a child, not ensuring his welfare—using him as a tactical asset in a war that may or may not actually occur, while justifying systematic abuse as preparation for hypothetical future conflicts."
"That is not—" Dumbledore started, but one of the MACUSA Aurors chose this moment to intervene.
"Sir," the Auror said, his American accent making the formal address sound slightly less formal and significantly more judgmental, "in the United States, what you've described would constitute child endangerment, reckless guardianship, and possibly criminal negligence. We have laws specifically designed to prevent authority figures from placing children in harmful situations regardless of their stated intentions or strategic reasoning."
"We are not in the United States," Dumbledore replied with the kind of formal courtesy that was technically polite but fundamentally dismissive. "British magical law governs British magical children, and while I appreciate American concern, I must remind you that MACUSA has no jurisdiction in these matters."
"Actually," the senior MACUSA bureaucrat interjected, her voice carrying the particular quality of someone about to deliver information that would make everyone's day considerably worse, "we do have jurisdiction in this specific case, Mr. Dumbledore. Harry Potter vanished from his guardians' care in Chicago, which falls within MACUSA's territorial authority. When we became aware that a British magical child had been abandoned in American territory, we initiated our own investigation—which is how we became connected with Mr. Zatara and Mr. Constantine, who had information about the case."
She produced her own documentation, placing it on Dumbledore's desk with the kind of formal precision that suggested she'd been waiting for exactly this moment. "This is a formal notice from MACUSA's Department of Magical Child Welfare. We are asserting temporary protective authority over Harry Potter's case until such time as British magical authorities can demonstrate that appropriate guardianship arrangements have been established and that previous failures of oversight have been adequately addressed."
The silence that followed was profound and dangerous, the kind of quiet that suggested diplomatic incidents were being born like particularly complicated babies that no one had asked for but everyone would have to deal with anyway.
"You are asserting authority over a British citizen," Dumbledore said slowly, each word carefully measured, "based on an incident that occurred five years ago, without consulting with British magical authorities, and apparently in cooperation with private citizens who have not disclosed Harry's current location despite claiming to have information about his welfare."
"That's an accurate summary, yes," the bureaucrat confirmed without apparent shame. "MACUSA takes the welfare of magical children very seriously, Mr. Dumbledore. When we discovered that Harry Potter—who is not just any magical child but literally the most famous child in the magical world—had been abandoned by his non-magical relatives in Chicago and subsequently vanished without any apparent search efforts from British authorities, we felt intervention was warranted."
"I searched," Dumbledore said with quiet intensity. "For five years, I have searched using every resource at my disposal. But Harry vanished completely—no magical signature, no trace, no indication of where he went or whether he survived. I attempted to coordinate with MACUSA, to gain access to American territory to conduct proper investigation, but I was..."
"Stonewalled," Constantine supplied helpfully. "Because MACUSA isn't part of your little International Confederation of Wizards club, which means they don't have to give a damn about your reputation or your political influence. Must have been quite frustrating, discovering that American wizards don't worship the ground you walk on."
"I never claimed—" Dumbledore started, but Giovanni was shaking his head with the sort of theatrical disappointment usually reserved for particularly poor magic trick execution.
"Headmaster Dumbledore," Giovanni said with the kind of gentle reproach that somehow felt more devastating than direct accusation, "you claim you searched for Harry for five years. Yet according to our information, you never reported his disappearance to the ICW, never filed formal requests for international assistance, never mobilized the resources that someone of your influence and connections could reasonably access. Instead, you kept the matter quiet, conducting what appears to have been a very private search while publicly maintaining that Harry was safe and well-cared-for."
"The boy's privacy—" Dumbledore began.
"The boy's *safety*," Giovanni corrected firmly. "Privacy is a concern when someone is secure and well-protected. Safety is the concern when a six-year-old child has vanished in a foreign country with no resources, no guardians, and no way to return home. You prioritized avoiding public scrutiny over actually finding Harry, which suggests your concern was more about your reputation than his welfare."
Ted Tonks was nodding along with obvious approval, clearly pleased that someone else was making the arguments he'd been preparing. "Which brings us to why we're here today, Mr. Dumbledore. We have several purposes for this meeting, and I suggest we address them systematically before this conversation devolves further into recriminations and defensive justifications."
He withdrew another document from his seemingly bottomless briefcase—seriously, the thing probably violated several principles of spatial geometry. "First: we are here to formally deliver Harry Potter's Hogwarts acceptance letter, as he has reached the appropriate age for magical education."
Dumbledore's expression brightened considerably, the grandfatherly warmth returning like someone had flipped a switch. "Harry is alive? You know where he is? You can assure me he's well?"
"We can assure you that Harry Potter is alive, well, and receiving excellent care from guardians who actually value his wellbeing," Giovanni confirmed. "We cannot, however, disclose his current location or the identity of his guardians without Harry's explicit permission, which we do not currently have and are not seeking on your behalf."
"But—" Dumbledore started, rising from his chair with obvious agitation. "I need to ensure Harry's safety! If he's been living among Muggles without magical education, without understanding his heritage, without proper protections—"
"Harry has been receiving magical education," Constantine interrupted flatly. "From qualified practitioners who understand age-appropriate instruction and don't think systematic abuse builds character. He's considerably more advanced than most children his age, both magically and intellectually. Your concern is noted and dismissed as unnecessary."
"How can you possibly—" Dumbledore's voice was rising now, genuine distress or extremely good acting making him sound like a grandfather who'd just discovered his beloved grandchild had been missing. "Harry needs to be protected! Voldemort's followers are still out there, searching for him, and without proper wards, without the protections I established—"
"The protections you established were centered on blood relatives who hated magic and treated Harry like a servant," Ted Tonks pointed out with legal precision. "Those protections ceased to be effective the moment the Dursleys abandoned him. Any argument you make about needing Harry's location for protection purposes is undermined by the fact that your previous protection arrangements were catastrophically inadequate."
Dumbledore sat down slowly, clearly recognizing he wasn't going to get Harry's location through emotional appeals or assertions of authority. "Very well. If you cannot disclose Harry's location, can you at least confirm that he's being raised by suitable magical guardians? That he's being prepared for eventual integration into magical society?"
"We can confirm that Harry's current guardians are extremely capable, highly protective, and have been providing comprehensive education in both magical and non-magical subjects," Giovanni said carefully. "They have considerable resources, extensive experience with complex situations, and Harry's best interests as their absolute priority. That's all we're prepared to disclose at this time."
"That is insufficient," Dumbledore said with quiet firmness. "Harry Potter is not simply another magical child—he is the Boy Who Lived, destined to face Voldemort, burdened with responsibilities and dangers that most people cannot comprehend. His guardians, no matter how capable, need to understand what he's facing, what he needs to be prepared for—"
"What he needs," Constantine interrupted with dangerous quiet, "is to have a childhood that doesn't involve adults treating him like a weapon they're sharpening for future deployment. What he needs is to develop as a person rather than as a tactical asset in your personal war against Voldemort. What he needs is for powerful wizards to stop making decisions about his life without his input or consent."
"He's eleven years old," Dumbledore protested. "Children cannot make informed decisions about their own welfare—they require adult guidance, adult protection—"
"Adult guidance that doesn't involve deliberately placing them in abusive situations," Ted Tonks supplied. "Mr. Dumbledore, your track record regarding Harry Potter's welfare is, to put it mildly, highly questionable. The guardians currently caring for Harry have done more for his development and wellbeing in five years than you accomplished in six, and they've done it without claiming moral authority over his entire life trajectory."
Dumbledore was quiet for a long moment, his expression cycling through various emotions before settling on something that might have been genuine concern mixed with frustration. "I understand that mistakes were made. I acknowledge that the Dursleys were not ideal guardians, that my monitoring of Harry's welfare was insufficient. But surely you understand that my intentions were good, that everything I did was meant to protect Harry and prepare him for the challenges he would face?"
"Good intentions," Giovanni said softly, "are not sufficient justification for bad outcomes. And Headmaster, the outcomes here were very bad indeed. A six-year-old child, abandoned in a foreign country, forced to survive on his own because the adults responsible for his welfare failed him catastrophically. That's not a minor oversight or an unfortunate miscalculation—that's systemic failure on multiple levels."
"Which brings us," Ted Tonks interjected before Dumbledore could mount further defense, "to our second purpose for this meeting. We are here to return an item that belongs to Harry Potter and should never have been in your possession to begin with."
Dumbledore went very still, his expression shifting into something carefully neutral in the way of people who'd just been caught with something they'd convinced themselves they had legitimate reasons to possess.
"The Invisibility Cloak," Dumbledore said slowly. "Yes. James Potter lent it to me shortly before his death. I had been studying its properties, its unusual durability, its resistance to detection charms. I had intended to return it to Harry when he came to Hogwarts, as a piece of his father's legacy."
"You've had this cloak for ten years," Ted Tonks observed with the kind of bland legal delivery that made the timeline sound increasingly problematic. "Ten years during which Harry Potter was growing up with relatives who provided minimal emotional support and no connection to his magical heritage. Ten years during which this cloak—which represents one of the few physical connections Harry has to his father—sat in your office rather than being held in trust by his magical guardian or stored with his family's other possessions at Gringotts."
"I was studying it," Dumbledore repeated, and there was something defensive in his tone now. "The cloak is an extraordinary magical artifact, possibly even a Hallow if certain legends are to be believed. Understanding its properties seemed important for understanding Harry's heritage and the protections he might need."
"Studying artifacts that don't belong to you without the owner's permission is called theft," Constantine pointed out with the casual bluntness of someone who'd committed enough actual theft to recognize the legal technicalities. "Doesn't matter if you're a respected Headmaster or the bloody Supreme Mugwump—taking someone's property and keeping it for a decade is theft, plain and simple."
"I intended to return it," Dumbledore protested.
"That's what they all say," Constantine replied with what might have been amusement. "Every person who's ever borrowed something and forgotten to give it back claims they intended to return it eventually. Intention doesn't actually matter if the item never makes it back to its rightful owner."
"We are formally here to retrieve said item on behalf of Harry Potter's current guardians. It will be returned to Harry along with his Hogwarts letter, and we strongly suggest you do not attempt to reclaim it through any official or unofficial channels."
"Of course," Dumbledore said with dignity that sounded slightly wounded. "I never intended to keep it permanently. Harry deserves to have his father's cloak."
"Glad we agree on something," Giovanni said with theatrical pleasantness that didn't quite disguise his continued irritation. "Which brings us to our third and final purpose for this meeting."
He produced his own documentation—a formal-looking parchment with multiple official seals that suggested involvement from bureaucracies that took themselves very seriously. "This is notification from the International Confederation of Wizards regarding Case File 1992-823: Investigation into the Arrest and Imprisonment of Sirius Black."
The temperature in the office seemed to drop several degrees. Dumbledore's expression, which had been cycling through various levels of defensive and conciliatory, suddenly went very still and very guarded.
"Sirius Black," Dumbledore said carefully, "was convicted of multiple murders and betraying the Potters to Voldemort. He is currently serving a life sentence in Azkaban for his crimes. I'm not certain what requires an ICW investigation—the case was quite clear, and Black's guilt was never in question."
"That's interesting phrasing," Constantine observed, lighting yet another cigarette because apparently his lungs were in competition with his liver for which organ could be most deliberately abused. "Black's guilt was 'never in question.' Not 'Black was proven guilty through trial,' not 'extensive evidence confirmed his involvement'—just 'never in question,' which is the kind of thing people say when they're not actually certain but don't want to admit it."
"The evidence was overwhelming," Dumbledore replied with the kind of calm certainty that suggested he'd been telling himself this for years and had started to believe it. "Sirius was the Potters' Secret Keeper. He was the only person who could have revealed their location to Voldemort. When Pettigrew confronted him about the betrayal, Black murdered him and twelve Muggles with a single curse. He was found at the scene, laughing maniacally. The case was straightforward."
"Straightforward," Giovanni repeated thoughtfully. "So straightforward that apparently no one felt it necessary to actually conduct a trial? To present evidence, examine witnesses, allow the accused to mount a defense?"
Dumbledore's silence was answer enough.
Ted Tonks leaned forward, his expression shifting into the kind of focused intensity that suggested they'd finally reached the core issue he'd been preparing for. "Mr. Dumbledore, are you aware that Sirius Black never received a trial? That he was imprisoned in Azkaban without any formal legal proceedings, without representation, without even a basic hearing to establish the facts of the case?"
"Sirius was caught red-handed," Dumbledore said, though there was something uncertain creeping into his voice now. "Barty Crouch Sr. had the authority to order immediate imprisonment during wartime conditions. Given the circumstances, a trial seemed unnecessary."
"Barty Crouch Sr. was later discovered to have been imprisoning his own son using Imperius Curse and maintaining him under house arrest for over a decade," Ted Tonks replied with legal precision. "His judgment regarding appropriate legal proceedings is, I would suggest, highly suspect."
He placed another document on the desk—this one bearing the seal of the ICW's Department of Magical Justice. "The International Confederation has reviewed the case files regarding Sirius Black's imprisonment. Or rather, they attempted to review the case files and discovered that no formal files exist because no formal legal proceedings ever occurred. No trial transcript, no evidence documentation, no witness statements—just an arrest followed by immediate imprisonment."
"The evidence was clear," Dumbledore repeated, but he was sounding less certain now.
"What evidence?" Giovanni asked with the kind of gentle persistence that made the question sound reasonable rather than accusatory. "I knew Sirius Black, Headmaster. I attended social functions where the Potters and their friends were present. I spent time with James, Lily, Sirius, Remus Lupin—all of them, during the years before the war made such gatherings too dangerous. And I can tell you with absolute certainty: Sirius Black worshipped James Potter. They were brothers in everything but blood. The idea that Sirius would betray James to Voldemort is psychologically implausible to the point of absurdity."
"People change," Dumbledore said quietly. "War changes people. Fear, desperation, the offer of power—these things can corrupt even the strongest friendships."
"Except Sirius had no need for power," Constantine pointed out. "He was from one of the richest, most influential pure-blood families in Britain. He had money, status, connections—everything that people usually betray others to obtain. What exactly could Voldemort have offered him that he didn't already have?"
"Survival," Dumbledore replied. "When Voldemort was at the height of his power, many people believed he was unstoppable. Joining him seemed like the only way to survive."
"Then why was Remus Lupin, who had considerably less to offer and considerably more to fear given his condition, never suspected of being the traitor?" Giovanni asked. "Why was Peter Pettigrew, who had the most to gain and the least standing in the group, never considered a potential security risk? You're suggesting that Sirius Black—wealthy, confident, deeply loyal to James—was the one who broke under pressure, while Pettigrew—who everyone describes as weak-willed and anxious—remained steadfast?"
Dumbledore was quiet for a long moment, his expression suggesting he was reviewing memories and finding them less certain than he'd remembered. "Peter died confronting Sirius about the betrayal. He was a hero who gave his life trying to stop his friend's murderer."
"Or," Constantine suggested with the kind of casual hypothesis that made uncomfortable alternatives sound reasonable, "Peter Pettigrew was the actual traitor, and when Sirius confronted him about it, Peter staged a spectacular public death—complete with explosion, witnesses, and conveniently obliterated evidence—that framed Sirius for betrayal and murder simultaneously. That would actually make considerably more sense from a strategic perspective."
---
Hey fellow fanfic enthusiasts!
I hope you're enjoying the fanfiction so far! I'd love to hear your thoughts on it. Whether you loved it, hated it, or have some constructive criticism, your feedback is super important to me. Feel free to drop a comment or send me a message with your thoughts. Can't wait to hear from you!
If you're passionate about fanfiction and love discussing stories, characters, and plot twists, then you're in the right place! I've created a Discord (HHHwRsB6wd) server dedicated to diving deep into the world of fanfiction, especially my own stories. Whether you're a reader, a writer, or just someone who enjoys a good tale, I welcome you to join us for lively discussions, feedback sessions, and maybe even some sneak peeks into upcoming chapters, along with artwork related to the stories. Let's nerd out together over our favorite fandoms and explore the endless possibilities of storytelling!
Can't wait to see you there!