(These are the unofficial minutes. They were written in a narrow hand on the back of a shipping invoice, then recopied into the town ledger with the prudence of people who understand that truth sometimes needs more than one copy to survive.)
---
08:11 — The summons arrives. Mr. Anas to be retained for an interview. We appreciate your cooperation in preserving public memory. The phrase is sweet and stainless like a spoon. Jeran reads it twice and says only, "We will go."
08:47 — The square is quieter than markets usually are. Children are humming the counting-song as if practice is armor:
> one for the stone we seed, two for the hand that keeps the seed…
They draw spirals with flour on doorsteps, but their spirals are made of dots, not a single line—pegs, not crowns.
09:03 — We set out: Cael, Liora, Serin. Meral blesses no one and everyone with a smear of rosemary under the thumb. Rook adjusts his ferry schedule and says, "If the river lowers by a hand, look under the second lip of stone past the weir." He never says anything in straight lines.
09:51 — The University gates receive us like a book that would prefer not to be dog-eared. A clerk in tidy gray leads us through a corridor that smells like paper warmed by sun. He says, "Miss Gavren will preside."
09:57 — We enter a room with no windows. Lamps do the work of daylight. A long table. Four chairs for the panel, one for the accused, two for "community observers." The walls are a restful color chosen by people who worry about the nerves of donors. Serin stands, declines the offered chair, and becomes another piece of furniture in the corner—a coat rack that can break your arm.
10:01 — Miss Gavren arrives. She is small and spare, her hair salted at the temples, her eyes the exact gray of a weather front that has not yet decided whether to rain. No rings, no lace. Her hands are neat, like someone who spends love on margins. She reads the charge in a voice that could slice paper: "Unauthorized transcription of marginal notations. Possible removal of interpretive context from Consolidated Memory."
10:03 — Anas is brought in. He straightens, fails, straightens again. Ink on the cuffs, rosemary in the pocket—a defiant sprig he forgot to be afraid of.
10:07 — Formalities: names, roles, a paragraph about the Charter. There is a bronze copy of the University seal on the wall: the Spiral threaded through laurel. Cael looks away before his face tells on him.
10:09 — Miss Gavren: "State, briefly, why you copied."
Anas: "Because margins die first."
Someone at the panel shifts in a chair. A small, expensive cough.
10:12 — Dr. Halim is present, not on the panel, not quite a witness. He has the look of a scholar pretending not to be a partisan and failing gracefully. He asks permission to submit a note regarding the relic's preliminary classification. Miss Gavren nods, not unkindly.
10:14 — The panel circles the word preservation like cats around a bowl. "Preservation requires control," says Panelist Two, a man whose spectacles make him look perpetually surprised by dust. "Uncontrolled copying breeds error."
Cael hears: A story we don't own is dangerous.
10:17 — Cael is asked to confirm his presence in the stacks last night. He does. He expects the classic rebuke. Instead Miss Gavren asks, "When your town keeps names, how does it keep them?"
Cael: "In too many hands."
Miss Gavren: "And when two hands disagree?"
Cael: "We bring both to the river and ask the ferryman which way the cross-current runs that season." It is not a joke. Rook's eyebrows would agree.
10:22 — Liora is asked what song she sang. She sings one line, so soft the lamps seem to tilt. Even Panelist Two remembers a father's kitchen for half a breath. Miss Gavren's mouth presses into what might be mercy or just a better word she hasn't found.
10:25 — Dr. Halim is recognized. He says, evenly, "The marginal notes they copied describe the Spiral not as a crown but as a peg-map: a device for tracking obligations distributed among neighbors and crossings. If true, the relic in our vault is a tool of public accounting, not a sacrament. That difference matters."
Panelist Three: "Words in margins are not dispositive."
Halim: "No. But three independent appearances across unrelated ledgers elevate rumor to record."
10:28 — The room inhales. Miss Gavren folds her hands. "Three independent appearances," she repeats, like a woman measuring cloth. "If such corroboration existed, our classification would be in question. The Charter requires us to return tools to the users they were shaped for."
Panelist Two blinks. "Clause?"
Miss Gavren: "Nine-point-seven, sub C. It is rarely invoked. Most people prefer their history clean."
10:31 — Cael feels the words like rain on parched ground. He also hears the trap in them: prove it. He thinks of last night's copies; of the page that smelled of glue and river; of Haman's scrawl: Do not allow the mark to become a god.
10:35 — The panel asks Anas whether he believes copying endangered the integrity of the records. Anas: "Integrity is not fragile when it belongs to everyone." Miss Gavren's mouth does something that could be the first stitch of a smile or a muscle cramp. It passes.
10:38 — An interruption: a young guard at the door, armored more by youth than by leather, clears his throat and asks to search the observers for "removed papers." His eyes land, of course, on Cael's jacket because guilt has a way of growing shoulders under cloth. Cael moves not at all. Serin moves without moving—the room realizes its corners have edges.
Miss Gavren: "Officer, this is a hearing, not a frisk. If papers were removed, they will return as copies. That is the problem we are discussing."
The guard blushes, retreats one step. Serin becomes furniture again.
10:42 — Liora asks permission to state a "community interest." Granted. She says, "When you put a thing in a glass case, it becomes an exhibit in a museum of victory. When we put it in our hands, it becomes a recipe. Which produces bread?"
Panelist Three, dryly: "Not all things are bread."
Liora, bright: "All people are hungry." It is too quick and a little theatrical, but the room has not had breath like that in months.
10:46 — Miss Gavren calls a brief recess. Lamps are trimmed. Someone brings in water as if thirst were a controllable event. During the pause, a custodian—older, with bookbinder's glue still sweet on his cuffs—edges near Cael and murmurs, "Cairnfold. Chalk road. Eighth mile. When the river's lip shows its second tooth. If you're the sort who listens to stones." Then he shuffles away, embarrassed by his own courage. Cael hears a door open that isn't in the wall.
10:56 — Back in session. Miss Gavren speaks directly to Anas. "You have two options. We may censure and bar you from the stacks. Or we may release you into town recognizance if a responsible party signs." She looks at Jeran's name where it has been written on the pass and, impossibly, as if she could see him sitting somewhere binding the morning back together, nods. "The binder will do."
10:58 — Cael asks to be heard. Granted, narrowly. He does not tell a parable this time. He holds up three phrases copied from three margins, reads them without adornment:
Spiral as peg-map. Tokens pledged to river. Keepers bound to mark.
Do not allow the mark to become a god. We mark to remember debt and favor.
When counting outgrows a lifetime, place stones at the crossing; call the crossing a court.
He does not add commentary. The room supplies its own.
11:02 — Miss Gavren: "If you can produce three independent attestations, authenticated by this office, and a working demonstration of such a peg-map in the present—that is, a living use—the classification will change to Public Tool. Under the Charter we would be obligated to share custody or, in some cases, relinquish it."
Panelist Two opens his mouth to object; she closes the matter with a look a school uses to teach discipline. "This is the law you wrote," she tells him without speaking.
11:06 — Terms are set: the attestations must originate from different decades and ledgers; the demonstration must bind a small web of obligations in town and at least one crossing and result in something measurable—grain moved, debts reconciled, a life tangibly righted. "We are not theologians," Miss Gavren adds. "We move food and law."
11:09 — Release: Anas is placed under recognizance. Jeran must sign by dusk. A clerk writes Town Custody, provisional. The words gleam like a bridge that might hold if you don't jump too hard.
11:12 — As we rise, Panelist Three, who has been quiet—the kind of quiet that says I am saving my one blow—says to Cael, "Do you think songs are evidence?"
Cael: "Only when they change what a man does next."
Panelist Three makes a face that means the conversation is not over. Good.
11:17 — Hallway. Dr. Halim falls in beside Cael. "There's an old charter map," he says lightly. "It marks places with triangles, not spirals. No key survives, but the triangles line up with river teeth and quarries. Some say they were the old Houses. If someone were to look where the chalk gives way to granite—" He lets the sentence simply unend. Cael hears Cairnfold again.
11:19 — Outside, the counting-song is waiting for us as if sound had fingers on the latch. Children sing it unfairly beautifully, and people clap on the wrong beats because they have better things to do than polish rhythm. A city rider frowns; a vendor sells dates; the world, in short, continues.
11:23 — Liora buys a paper cone of salted chickpeas and pours half into Anas's shaking hand like a sacrament she will never call holy. Serin watches roofs, gutters, corners; near his ear, danger is a small insect he expects and despises.
11:30 — Cael walks to the river before heading home. The water is low—lower than two days ago. On the weir's lip you can see a second tooth of stone. He remembers the custodian's whisper. He thinks of Rook's advisories that never arrive where you expect them and always arrive when you need them.
12:04 — Back at Binder's Reach. Jeran hears the terms, nods once: "Three attestations. A demonstration. And the river's tooth showing." He signs for Anas with a hand that does not shake. "They've given us rope," he says. "We'll show them a knot."
13:17 — Oris spreads the copies under a weight stone and inks a rough map: town, ferry, weir, chalk road disappearing into the hills, a small triangle at the eighth mile marked Cairnfold?. He is cautious about question marks; they breed hope, and hope is livestock you must feed.
14:02 — Rook has words while he coils a rope with sacramental precision. "You'll want boots stiff at the heel. The chalk slides sideways when you look at it. And watch for sinkholes. Chalk keeps the secrets of rain."
14:40 — Meral drafts, on rough paper, the frame for a demonstration: six households, three trades, one crossing, and a barrel of grain pledged along the pegs; pegs carved as tokens, two to a debt—one for each hand to hold. "If the web binds," he says, "someone eats who would not have eaten." That is as close to proof as towns get.
15:11 — Liora finds three elders and a midwife who still remember a winter when the spiral was laid with pegs on the floor of the mill and the miller's daughter kept the knots. One elder had a brother who tied a Keeper's knot he shouldn't have. He remembers the shape but not the reason, which is how memory behaves when you need it most.
16:33 — Anas stands in the doorway of the record house and touches the rosemary at his pocket as if it were armor. "I will go back for the third ledger," he says. "Miss Gavren gave us terms. I intend to beat them with their own book." His voice holds a new iron that was not there yesterday. Courage sometimes enters like a tailor measuring you for a better coat.
18:09 — As the sun drops, Cael walks out along the chalk road to test the ground with his feet and his head. He does not go far—just enough to see how the hills hold themselves when nobody is watching. On a rise he finds a line of old stones half-swallowed by scrub, not placed for beauty or for gods but for someone who once needed to remember where to turn when the fog sat down. On the flattest of the stones, someone long ago cut a shallow groove that would snugly snug a loop of rope. It could be a coincidence. Or it could be a lesson left on a table for a late student.
He threads a piece of twine through the groove and pulls. The line holds like a sentence that knows where it is going. The wind rises, makes the grass lean. The moment feels like a small rehearsal for a large thing.
19:21 — Back in town, a strange peace: we have a path and a challenge, and sometimes those two things together make fear stand back and blink. We are poorer by a relic and richer by a rule we can use.
20:03 — Cael lays out the plan as if setting cutlery: at first light, he and Serin will scout the chalk road to Cairnfold and look for the House of Stones or what time has left of it. Liora will begin the demonstration web: pegs to baker, ferryman, shepherd, mill; two hands to each promise; a tally every dusk at the ledger stone. Jeran will copy the three strongest marginal notes with his slow, relentless pen and send Rook with them to Miss Gavren for preliminary authentication—make them say no in ink, Jeran mutters, "because paper can be turned back on the hand that wrote it."
21:10 — Alone, finally, Cael sits with the fossil warm against his ribs and the pilgrim's line under his fingertips. He turns their weight the way smiths roll steel to feel its temper. He hears again Miss Gavren's voice: Three attestations. A living use. He hears the custodian's whisper: Eighth mile, second tooth. He hears Rook's counsel: Rivers keep what you throw; sometimes they give it back when you're ready to be humble.
He thinks about justice that never fits in a single ledger and about a day when accounts are read aloud without fear that the reader serves a lord. He does not use the word judgment because he has learned not to frighten his own heart, but the shape of it is there, like a mountain under fog.
21:47 — The lamps go down. The counting-song lifts from three houses at once as if conducted by something older than rhythm:
> Five for the bridge we owe,
Six for the hands that let us go,
Seven for the stone that knows,
Eight for the tooth the river shows.
Cael smiles despite the day. The eighth line was new; children are better at exegesis than committees.
He tucks the bowl-and-sword token in his pocket for morning and, before sleep, knots a loop of twine the way his grandfather taught him: a simple bend that will hold in either direction—pull and it tightens, slack and it remembers its shape. He thinks: a knot that keeps the line honest. He hopes there is a bigger version cut into stone somewhere up in the chalk, overseen by no one but watched, always, by the river.
22:03 — He sleeps, finally. The town's breaths file into the night like pages laid in order on a desk. Across the fields, the University glows politely, and in a room with no windows Miss Gavren reads Clause Nine-point-seven, sub C, three times, and then sets her pen down as if she has remembered a recipe for bread.
In the morning, the chalk road will take its first footprints in years that know what they're looking for. And if the House of Stones exists, and if the knot knows how to keep a promise across the length of more than one life, then the story the University tried to seal will have to learn to live in daylight again—untidy, useful, and hard to put behind glass.