The cellar smelled of damp earth, stale wine, and fear. A single oil lamp cast long, dancing shadows across the faces of the dozen men and women huddled within the cramped space. They were merchants, craftsmen, farmers—the quiet, desperate heart of the Creed of True Silence. Days ago, their gatherings had been filled with a serene, if somber, sense of purpose. They were believers in a gentle release, a quiet exit from a world of unending pain. Tonight, that serenity had been shattered, replaced by the frantic, panicked whispers of a flock that has just seen a wolf.
The news from Carnuntum had spread not like a flowing river, but like a flash flood of terrified rumor, each retelling more monstrous than the last.
"He held up his hand, and the man turned to glass!" a baker whispered, his eyes wide, his flour-dusted hands trembling. "My cousin's boy is a legionary, he saw it with his own eyes."
"Worse," countered a weaver, her voice a thin, reedy thing. "He brought the man back from the Silence first. Made him remember everything he'd lost, just so he could feel it all being torn away again."
"He can raise the dead," an old man murmured, his voice cracking with superstitious dread. "He is a god. A vengeful god. And we have turned our backs on him."
The fear was a contagion, spreading through the small group, twisting their faith into a liability. Their promise of a peaceful release felt weak, pathetic even, in the face of an Emperor who could apparently reach beyond the veil of death itself to exact his terrible price. What was their quiet creed against a deity who wielded miracles like a headsman's axe?
The heavy wooden door at the top of the cellar stairs creaked open, and a figure descended into their midst. He was a man named Nerva, a former scribe whose gentle demeanor and sharp mind had quickly elevated him within the Creed's nascent structure. He moved with a preternatural calm, his eyes taking in the fear in the room not with judgment, but with a deep, knowing empathy. He was the Conductor's chosen instrument for this new, ideological war, and his mind was a far sharper weapon than any sword.
He let the silence settle, allowing their fear to reach its peak before he spoke. His voice was not loud, but it commanded the space, a calm anchor in their sea of panic.
"Brothers and sisters," he began. "You have heard the stories from Carnuntum. You are afraid. Good."
The word hung in the air, unexpected and jarring. Good?
"You are afraid because for the first time, you have seen the truth of the Emperor's 'gift,'" Nerva continued, his expression unreadable in the flickering lamplight. "He offers you a choice, does he not? A choice between the cage of the flesh and the quiet of the soul. But what did he truly show you on that stage? He showed you his nature. The nature of a tyrant. The nature of a jailer."
He began to pace slowly in the small, confined space, his words weaving a new narrative, a startling and brilliant reinterpretation of the day's terrible events.
"Think of it," he urged, his voice hypnotic. "Imagine a man, trapped his entire life in a dark, cold prison. His days are filled with pain, his nights with fear. One day, he finds a key. He unlocks his cell door, steps out into the warm, quiet sunlight, and finally knows peace. He is free."
He paused, letting the image settle in their minds.
"What does the jailer do?" Nerva's voice grew harder, edged with a cold contempt. "Does he rejoice for the freed man? Does he celebrate his escape from suffering? No. The jailer is furious. He has lost a prisoner. He has lost control. So he storms out into the sunlight and he drags the man back by his hair. He shoves the man's soul back into the broken, bleeding clay of his body. And for what purpose? Why perform such a cruel act?"
He stopped pacing and looked at them, his eyes burning with a dark, intelligent fire. "He does it for one reason only: so the man can feel the pain of the lash one last time. He resurrects him only to torture him. He brings him back to life only to execute him. The Emperor did not perform a miracle of life. He performed a miracle of torture."
A stunned silence fell over the cellar as his logic, so perverse and yet so compelling, began to take root. He was twisting the narrative, reframing the Emperor's awesome power not as a sign of divinity, but as the ultimate act of cosmic cruelty.
"He is so desperate to keep his slaves, so terrified of you finding true release, that he will reach into the afterlife itself to drag you back for one final, agonizing moment of suffering," Nerva declared, his voice rising with righteous passion. "His power is not a gift; it is a threat. It is the raging of a master who discovers his chattel have found a way to be free."
This was the Conductor's brilliant counter-attack, delivered through its intelligent mouthpiece. It was a piece of ideological jujitsu, taking the full force of Alex's terrifying display and turning it back against him. The Creed of True Silence was no longer just offering peace from the hardships of life. It was now offering a sanctuary from the Emperor's terrible "mercy."
Nerva raised his hands, his face illuminated from below by the lamp, making him look like a prophet from some ancient, forgotten religion.
"The Emperor offers you a body so he can tax it, conscript it, and work it to death. When your suffering becomes too great and your soul seeks its rightful peace, he will drag you back into that failing body just to make you suffer more. The Silence offers you a true escape. A gentle, permanent freedom for your soul."
He leaned in, his voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper. "He proved on that stage that he is the ultimate master of the flesh. And in doing so, he proved he is the ultimate enemy of the spirit. His 'miracle' was a threat. The Silence is a promise. He is the God of Pain. The Silence is the path to peace." He let the final choice hang in the air, a question that now had a new and terrifying weight. "Now… who is your true savior?"
He did not need to wait for an answer. He could see it on their faces. The fear was still there, but it was being forged into something new, something harder and more resilient. It was annealing into a new kind of fanaticism. They were no longer just peaceful nihilists seeking an escape. They were the chosen few, believers in a sacred truth that offered the only real protection from a tyrannical, flesh-obsessed god-emperor who would deny them even the peace of the grave. The uncaged idea was now loose, and it was far more dangerous than it had ever been before.
To be the first to know about future sequels and new projects, google my official author blog: Waystar Novels.