What happened next wasn't sex. It wasn't even about dominance or ownership or love. It was something raw and primal—something that tore right through the designer leather of her Mercedes and cracked into the kind of truth that people spend years in therapy trying to name.
It was Madison trying to take me back with everything she had—nails, hips, teeth, breath—and me reminding her, in no uncertain terms, why she never had to worry in the first place.
The car rocked on its suspension like it was trying to match our rhythm, and neither of us gave a damn who saw.
Except someone did see. Of course.
Some elderly woman walking her tiny rat-dog past the sidewalk glanced over at the shaking Mercedes. Her eyes locked on the motion. Her face morphed into that perfect cocktail of horror, disgust, and nostalgia for a youth she probably never had.
I watched her mouth a dramatic; "Kids these days," before she clutched her purse like it had a holy relic inside and dragged her poodle away at record speed.
Sorry, grandma. We're rewriting the commandments over here.
Eventually, the storm broke. Our breathing slowed, but our bodies were still stuck in orbit—sweaty, breathless, entirely tangled. Madison leaned forward, her forehead resting against mine, her chest still rising and falling like she'd run through fire and back just to get here. And then it came. Quiet. Unstoppable.
"I love you," she whispered. The words spilled out like a confession she hadn't planned, like a dam snapping under too much pressure. "I know it's crazy, and I know this whole thing is insane, but I love you, Peter Carter. Both versions of you."
Boom.
Just like that, she detonated my ribcage from the inside.
Didn't feel scripted. It felt real.
Raw and terrified and true. And the craziest part? I didn't doubt her for a second. Not one. I saw it in her eyes. That wild, broken, loyal kind of love. The kind that carves itself into bone and doesn't give a fuck who bleeds.
My chest pulled tight—not soft, not weak, just... full. Like my heart suddenly remembered how to beat in 4K.
I reached up and cupped her face, fingers threading into her hair with the kind of reverence people reserve for gods and ghost stories.
"Then you're mine," I said, voice like a promise etched in stone. "Forever. No take-backs. No second thoughts. Mine."
And when she smiled—wrecked and radiant—I knew.
That's how empires start.
Not with war drums.
But with two people in a rocking Mercedes, whispering vows that sound like possession.
"Yours," she whispered, still breathless, still wrecked from everything we'd just done. "Always yours."
Yeah. I felt that. Not just in my chest, but in my spine, in my bloodstream, in the ache behind my eyes. It was the kind of promise you don't shake off, even when the high wears off. Even when you're crashing.
*
By the time Madison dropped me off, I was running on straight fumes and stubborn pride. The whole day had been a whirlwind of power, lust, strategy, and supernatural transformation—and my body? My regular Peter Carter body? It was pissed. Every muscle screamed like it had just filed a formal complaint with HR. My bones felt like they wanted to resign.
We drove back and I barely managed to make it inside without collapsing on the driveway. The second I stepped through the door, I heard Sarah call something about dinner from the kitchen, but I didn't even pretend to care. I threw up a lazy hand in acknowledgment, stumbled down the hallway like a drunk ghost, and faceplanted onto my bed without bothering to remove so much as a sock.
I lay there, motionless. Brain fried. Skin buzzing with leftover heat from Madison's thighs and Isabella's lips. Heart thudding slow, but satisfied.
Note to self: Figure out how to build up stamina for longer Dark Lord sessions. Because this whole passing-out-after-sex thing? Not a power move.
Also? Strategic fuck-up of the day: I'd let "Peter" slip out during the whole Isabella situation. Which officially blew my shot at keeping both identities airtight. Not catastrophic, but definitely not ideal. Rookie mistake, Carter.
I'd gotten cocky.
I need a name, I thought as my eyelids started to give up the fight. A real one. Something that sounds like power without screaming 'I play too much Dungeons & Dragons.'
And, because the universe—or more specifically, my cursed system—lives to torment me, that's exactly when the UI decided to flash back into my field of vision like an uninvited ex.
[DING! New Missions Available!]
Mission 1: Get Your Ass to the Gym Your regular body can't handle much more Dark Lord action without proper conditioning. Requirements: Serious workout routine, 6 days a week for 2 months. Reward: +5 to all stats.
Mission 2: Pick a Name Already. You need a Dark Lord identity that doesn't blow your cover every time someone moans your real name. Deadline: 48Hrs Choose wisely – this name will inspire fear, desire, and probably way too much fan art.
Even half-dead, I had to admit—the system had immaculate comedic timing.
It wasn't wrong either. I couldn't keep throwing around "Peter" in situations where women were losing their damn minds for the Dark Lord and expect things to stay clean. Dual identity? That only works if the civilian version doesn't accidentally keep signing his real name on world-altering sex contracts.
Tomorrow.Tomorrow, I told myself, as sleep started dragging me under like a weighted blanket made of regret and victory. I'll figure it out. The name. The body. The empire. I'd build a version of myself that could carry all of this—power, women, secrets, and everything else that came with playing god in a teenage skin suit.
But tonight?
Tonight I was just Peter Carter. Exhausted, overstimulated, slightly paranoid high schooler who somehow managed to seduce his AP Biology teacher and leave her in post-coital bliss.
Not a bad day's work. Not bad at all.
Fade to black.