Chapter 92: The Architect of Self
—
I descended into the lower levels of Xavier's mansion, my steps echoing against polished stone floors. The temperature dropped a few degrees with every floor I passed, as I entered the more secure areas of the institute.
After my talk with Xavier and Emma, I found myself wandering toward the library instead of Madelyne's quarters. Emma mentioned Maddy there, buried in books since dawn. It seemed our meeting would happen on her terms, in her space.
The library itself was something out of a fantasy novel.
Two stories of floor-to-ceiling shelves packed with everything from ancient tomes to digital archives. Late afternoon sunlight poured through tall windows, setting dust motes dancing in golden beams that crossed the room like spotlights. The air smelled of old paper, leather bindings, and that indefinable scent of accumulated knowledge.
I spotted her immediately, tucked away in a corner alcove beside a stained-glass window that cast multicolored patterns across her workspace. The table before her had disappeared beneath stacks of books, papers covered in neat handwriting, and a sleek laptop whose screen illuminated her face with a pale blue glow.
She was so absorbed that she didn't notice my approach. I took the moment to observe her – this woman who looked exactly like Jean Grey but wasn't.
Her hair was pulled back in a messy bun, strands of copper escaping to frame a face etched with concentration. There was something both familiar and alien in her features; the same genetic blueprint as Jean, but animated by a different consciousness.
The titles of the books surrounding her told a story of their own.
I noticed Philosophy of Identity, The Paradox of Theseus's Ship, Twin Studies and Shared Consciousness, Nature vs. Nurture, and Psychological Development of Autonomous Identity. Heavy reading for someone whose entire existence had been upended just weeks ago.
"Light vacation reading?" I asked.
She startled violently, papers slipping from her fingers. When she looked up and registered my face, the tension visibly drained from her shoulders.
"Ah, Ben," she muttered, relief softening her features. "You're back. Welcome back. I've been... researching."
"I can see that." I pulled out the chair opposite her. "Mind if I join?"
She nodded, hastily reorganizing some of her materials to make space. Up close, I could see her notes – meticulously organized, color-coded by source, with her own observations in neat, precise handwriting in the margins. The analytical mind of a scientist trying to solve the ultimate puzzle. Herself.
I picked up a book on cloning ethics, flipping through pages dense with philosophical arguments about personhood and identity. "How long have you been at this?"
"Since 3 AM," she admitted with a self-conscious smile. "I couldn't sleep. Kept thinking about what happens after they remove his influence. Who will I be then?"
In the afternoon light, I could see the physical toll of her mental struggle. She looked totally human with those traits. Dark circles beneath her eyes, the slight tremble in her hands as she sorted papers, and the tension in her shoulders as if she was carrying an invisible weight.
"Find any answers?" I asked.
She ran a hand through her hair, dislodging more strands from her already loosening bun. "Some. Mostly more questions, though." She tapped a notebook filled with densely-packed notes. "Did you know there's a philosophical thought experiment called the Ship of Theseus? If you replace every plank and nail of a ship one by one, is it still the same ship at the end?"
"And that's how you see yourself? A ship with replaced parts?"
Her green eyes met mine, startlingly vulnerable. "That's the question, isn't it? Jean's memories in my head feel like borrowed parts. Sinister's programming, another replacement. When they remove his influence tomorrow, what's left that's authentically mine?"
The weight of her question was like the Ship of Theseus itself crushing my shoulders. I understood her fear more than she knew. The Omnitrix had forced me to confront similar questions – when I transformed, was I still Ben Tennyson? Or something else entirely? I didn't think much of it in the beginning, but sometimes I had wondered.
"There's something I want to show you," she said suddenly, standing and gathering a few papers. "Come with me?"
She led me to another table, more secluded, tucked behind a massive shelf of encyclopedias. On it lay a single sheet of paper with the heading "Declaration of Self" in bold letters. Below were numbered statements, some crossed out, others underlined or annotated.
"It sounds silly when I say it out loud," she said, embarrassment coloring her voice. "But I needed something concrete, I guess. Something I could hold onto during the procedure."
I scanned the document, reading statements like "I am not Jean Grey" and "My memories before waking in the medical bay belong to someone else, but my experiences since then are mine alone."
"It's not silly," I said firmly. "This is survival. The most human thing ever."
Relief flickered across her face. She handed me a pen. "Would you... help me?"
We sat side by side, shoulders almost touching as we bent over the paper. She explained her methodology – identifying traits, preferences, and memories that felt genuinely hers versus those she believed belonged to Jean.
"I prefer tea over coffee. Jean drinks coffee," she said, adding it to the list.
"That's crazy," I grinned. "Coffee is clearly superior."
"See? Another difference between Jean and me," she replied with the first genuine smile I'd seen from her. "You wouldn't tell Jean her taste in beverages is 'crazy.'"
"Fair point."
"I find comfort in classical music," she continued. "Bach especially."
"And Jean?"
"She's more into alternative rock," she replied, continuing her list. "I want to travel. See places Jean has never been."
As we worked, her pen moved more confidently, her voice growing stronger with each declaration. But underneath ran a current of fear I could sense in the tightness of her voice.
"What if," she said finally, "after they remove Sinister's influence, I discover that what I thought was 'me' was just his manipulation all along?"
I looked at my watch, the familiar green hourglass symbol glowing softly. The thing is, I never had as deep a thought experiment as she. Mostly thanks to having watched the Ben Ten cartoon in another lifetime. All this felt familiar to me. Regardless, the question was similar enough that I could fake an answer.
"The Omnitrix has forced me to question which parts of me are 'the real Ben' too," I exaggerated. "When I'm Heatblast or Diamondhead, I think differently, feel differently. There are moments I've wondered if I'm losing myself each time I transform." That last part was a lie.
"How do you handle it?" she asked, hunger for understanding in her eyes.
"I've realized we're not fixed things," I said slowly, finding the words as I spoke. "We're processes. Always becoming. The Ben who first found this watch isn't the same Ben sitting here now – and that would be true even without alien DNA rewriting my cells every few hours."
She absorbed this, fingers absently tracing the words on her declaration. "A process, not a fixed point," she repeated. "I like that."
The library had grown dimmer as we talked, the golden afternoon light fading to the cooler blue of early evening. Madelyne didn't seem to notice, too absorbed in our conversation.
"There are memories I can't place," she confessed, her voice dropping to nearly a whisper. "Scattered fragments that feel... strange. Neither fully mine nor clearly Jean's."
She demonstrated by describing falling from a tree as a child, analyzing it with clinical precision. "The emotional resonance feels distant, like watching someone else's home movie. I think it's Jean's."
In contrast, she described her first morning at Xavier's after the incident with vivid, sensory detail. "The sunlight through the curtains, the texture of the sheets, the silence – that memory has an immediacy. I know it's mine. But… that can't be true since I've only been here for a year or so, right? I wasn't the Phoenix."
There was a lot of confusion. Even so, I listened, struck by her approach.
Where others might have broken under the existential weight of her situation, Madelyne had turned it into a research project. Her analytical mind was becoming a life raft in a sea of uncertainty.
"What's it like?" she asked suddenly. "Having different forms, different minds in one body?"
I considered how to explain something I'd never fully articulated even to myself. "It's like... having access to different versions of yourself. Diamondhead thinks more rigidly – literally and figuratively. Ghostfreak is more intuitive, picks up on things human senses miss. Then there's Greymatter, who might be able to outsmart Beast, I think. That one always feels weird once I return to human. All that knowledge, all that mental power, suddenly gone. But they're all still me, filtered through different biology."
"I see… And that's the difference between being a copy and being a unique entity with shared origins," she said, making the connection to her own situation. "The blueprint may be the same, but the consciousness interpreting it is distinct."
Her insight impressed me. In days, she'd grappled with questions that had taken me a month to process, and she was doing it with a grace and determination that was distinctly hers. Not Jean's.
The light had shifted again, long shadows stretching across the library floor. Finally, Madelyne gathered her papers with precise movements, organizing them into a folder.
"Do you know what I've concluded from all this research?" she asked, gesturing to the books surrounding us. "That identity isn't discovered. It's built. Conscious choice by conscious choice."
There was something powerful in her declaration. A reclamation of agency that Sinister had tried to strip from her.
"After the procedure," she continued, "I want to leave the mansion. They don't want me here, Ben," she added quickly at my expression. "I need to experience the world on my own terms, collect experiences that are uniquely mine."
"I see."
"I need to be the architect of myself," she said with quiet determination. "Not Jean's shadow. Not Sinister's creation. Just Madelyne."
The metaphor resonated. I could almost see her like a builder laying foundation stones for a structure that was entirely her own design.
"I might be able to help with that," I offered. "I know people outside the X-Men who could help you get established. My PI friend Jessica Jones, for one. She's an independent superhero, forged her own path. She'd understand."
Madelyne considered this, her expression thoughtful. "Your Private Investigator friend? The one who calls herself Jewel?"
"That's her. She's got connections in New York, could help you find your footing."
She nodded slowly. "I'd like that." A pause, then: "Ben, what do you think I should keep? What seems most 'authentically Madelyne' to you?"
The question caught me off guard. It was both vulnerable and pragmatic, exactly the balance that seemed to define her approach to this impossible situation.
"I think you're more unique on your own, Maddy, beyond my words. Sinister created you to marry Scott, but instead you broke up with him. That shows how unique you are. Maybe the original Jean wouldn't have broken up? I don't think so, given how close those two have been lately after reuniting. But if I do have to choose… it's your analytical mind," I said without hesitation. "The way you've approached this whole mess like a research project. Your resilience. Your determination to choose your own path." I smiled. "And your terrible taste in beverages."
That earned a genuine laugh, a sound I realized I'd never heard from her before. It transformed her face, making her look younger, unburdened.
As we prepared to leave the library, Madelyne carefully packed her declaration and research notes into a shoulder bag. Just before we reached the door, she stopped me with a light touch on my arm.
"If something goes wrong in the procedure..." she began, her voice steady despite the fear lurking beneath the words, "if I lose myself... will you remind me of this conversation? Of the person I was trying to become?"
The weight of her request settled on my shoulders, somehow feeling heavier than any boulder or truck I'd carried as Four Arms. She was entrusting me with the safekeeping of her identity, the essence of who she hoped to be.
"I promise," I said, meeting her eyes. "But it won't come to that. You're stronger than Sinister. Stronger than you realize."
Relief softened her features. Without warning, she stepped forward and wrapped her arms around me in a tight embrace.
It wasn't romantic. No, it was something more fundamental. The touch of someone learning the boundaries of her own emotions, expressing gratitude in the most human way possible. I returned the hug, feeling her heartbeat against my chest, the warmth of her breath against my neck.
When she pulled back, her eyes were bright with unshed tears. "Thank you for seeing me," she said simply. "Not Jean or Jean's clone. Just me."
As she walked away, notes and declarations clutched to her chest, I watched her retreating figure – shoulders straight, steps purposeful. In just days, she'd faced questions and fought circumstances that would have destroyed most people.
Whatever happened tomorrow, Madelyne Pryor had already begun to build herself, brick by deliberate brick. And I couldn't help but feel that the foundation she'd laid was stronger than Sinister could have possibly anticipated.
I just hoped it would be enough to withstand whatever tomorrow's procedure might unleash. Because no way Sinister would just let it happen.
**
**
**
Come find fellow fans on Discord and more chapters on Patreon!
Patreon: Patreon.com/Master4thWall
Discord: https://discord.gg/dQeu27jBvf