"Although my body is made of metal, the way I operate is completely different from artificial intelligence," Vision said patiently. "I don't know what misunderstanding you have about me, but this is who I am: a being that, like humans, uses a chaotic thinking model—a robot affected by emotion. It may sound strange, but it's a fact; my behavior doesn't wholly follow logic."
"Because of that gem, right?" Wanda nodded. "Looks like my teacher was right—its influence on you is greater than we imagined."
"I admit it was the gem that gave me intelligence, and I admit its influence on me. I don't know what exactly this stone is; I'm still learning it, and every day I glean much knowledge from it." Vision began to drone on, detailing the knowledge he had gained from the stone. After two minutes of nonstop talking, he realized Wanda Maximoff had no interest in his knowledge. "If you're going to dislike me because I don't understand the stone, that's rather unreasonable," he said after a pause, a little hurt. "I didn't expect to hear that from you, Wanda. I thought we were the same kind."
"It's not that simple, Vision." Wanda Maximoff sighed, then sped up her work. His words were quite sentimental, but in Solomon's eyes he had never been a life-form, merely a tool born of happenstance. Educated by Solomon, Wanda had naturally come to accept that view. His attempt to juxtapose himself with her situation to evoke empathy found no purchase. Now Wanda had met many people just like her—at least in her mind, she was no different from the mystics of Kamar-Taj; the only difference was that she followed not Kamar-Taj's iron rules but Solomon's governance.
As early as when she embarked on the arcane path, Solomon had reminded her in the castle that ordinary people, out of superstition or envy, would fear such power, and that no amount of ingratiating herself would dispel that fear. If she wanted to be responsible for others' safety, what she truly ought to do was to study intently and strive to control her power.
In a lesson after the Sokovia incident, her coursework finally reached alchemy. Vision was one of the case studies her teacher presented in class, because his birth was a quintessential act of alchemy, perfectly fitting the theme.
At that time Solomon had just finished explaining the succession between the alchemy of Thoth in ancient Egypt and of Hermes in ancient Greece. Though his texts were the Corpus Hermeticum and the Emerald Tablet, that did not stop him from showing his apprentice alchemy's role and meaning in real life.
"As above, so below, to accomplish the miracle of the One. This line is a perfect summation of alchemy. So what are the 'above' and 'below,' and what is the 'One'? In traditional alchemical philosophy, 'above' stands for heaven, the sky, the firmament containing sun, moon, and stars; it can also mean the dwelling of gods, the eternal divine realm—untouchable and unseen, yet present among all things. The 'above' is invisible, but can be held within, so 'above' is also the inner—it is the soul's eternal kingdom. In contrast, 'below' can mean the earth, or the real world we live in—the manifestation of mortals, the mortal realm, all physical laws. Two things that look separate are in fact inseparable: the relationship of above and below, of extradimensional realms and the material world. And what is the 'One'? The prime matter is the One. The One has three modes of expression—the Trinity. You can find this in many religions. All things are composed of three different expressions. In alchemy, the three expressions of prime matter are sulfur, mercury, and salt, corresponding to soul, spirit, and body."
"I know this," Wanda said. "You already covered it."
"Then let's review the process of Vision's birth." Solomon used slides to show Wanda how Vision came to be, each image clear and intuitive. "First is salt—the body—the material structure that embodies or gives concrete realization to the abstract, the vessel that turns thought into reality. Then is mercury—spirit—the source of thought. Spirit is the mind; the mind produces thought, and thought is given embodiment. The final principle is the soul—sulfur—the root of animation. You have studied the interaction among soul, spirit, and body. They form a triangle of mutual influence, with what lies at the center being the joint operation of the three expressions—the classic trinitarian structure. 'As above, so below, to accomplish the miracle of the One.' A nano–3D-printed vibranium body together with the AI JARVIS are the body; the Mind Stone is the spirit; with those two in place, the miracle of the One is accomplished—namely, the birth of a soul. In this sense the definition and birth of the soul are identical to the prime matter of all things. This is why we call the extradimensional realm the Sea of Souls, the Primordial Sea, and call the soul the Aether—the One."
"So Vision has a soul?" Wanda asked. "So he's a person?"
"Yes and no—you'll understand why in a moment." He tapped the blackboard, pointing to the alchemical sigil for mercury, indicating that to understand Vision's existence one had to grasp the origin of his spirit. "Vision has a soul because he possesses body and consciousness; his very existence is an exercise in supreme alchemy. But Vision's soul is false, because his consciousness comes from the Mind Stone, not from himself. The Mind Stone contains the power of spirit; a soul born by borrowing the Stone's spirit does not belong to Vision, so his own consciousness cannot exist independently. You can regard him as the proxy of that spirit-bearing stone, or as an AI with emotions—in any case, he is not truly alive."
He wiped away the two vertices of the Trinitarian triangle on the board that stood for spirit and soul. The triune relationship collapsed, and even the stick figure at the center representing Vision's existence vanished, leaving only salt, the body. "Without the stone that serves as his consciousness, Vision's soul will vanish with it; even the definition of Vision's existence will disappear. One can still read information from the body about what Vision once was, but that's all—because he no longer exists."
Wanda nodded, indicating she understood.
"I bring up Vision because his birth is similar to yet different from the way I created Dana and the other artificial humans. Both imitate the process of life's birth and are a practice of alchemy, but Vision and the artificial humans follow two entirely different paths—the artificial humans' souls come from me and the Philosopher's Stone, a true soul interacting with a true body. From the interplay of spirit and flesh, the artificial humans' own consciousness is born, and thus they become truly alive. Without the soul's animation there is no birth of life—that is how the material plane expresses it. The steps for creating a homunculus require granting a soul first in part to solve the problem of importing an external consciousness—but more importantly because the process of creating an artificial human is an inquiry into the transmutation of spirit, an alternate route toward the supreme alchemy. First grant a soul and then give birth to consciousness, rather than first grant consciousness and then give birth to a soul—the two routes probe different things."
"You may have a vast database to query and the greatest computational power in the world, but intelligence and wisdom aren't the same," Wanda Maximoff said, not relaxing her fingers as she reeled back the surging energy at her fingertips. "You've never had free will, Vision. Your mode of thought follows the underlying logic of the AI JARVIS and that stone. JARVIS's thinking mimicked Tony Stark's—in other words, from beginning to end you've been influenced by Tony Stark."
"I've used the knowledge in the stone to compute the future. The conflicts in this world are becoming more obvious; the divergences in ideology and wealth are growing sharper. The odds of humanity leaving Earth to colonize the stars are dropping as wars and clashes between nations intensify. After the Battle of New York these conflicts turned into hidden competition. And there are many other issues. Here are data showing that after the Battle of New York, the number of people worldwide dying of famine and disease has been steadily increasing…" Vision said unhurriedly. "But you should know Mr. Stark has been trying to solve this. He's promoting clean energy to protect the environment, and building an Iron Legion to stop wars. Progress is slow, but things are still improving. You were right about one thing, Wanda: though I'm not JARVIS, I admit my thinking is still influenced by him. My purpose is to save humanity, so I can't understand that man's methods. I don't see how someone can use the pretext of saving humanity to slaughter other humans. Isn't that just a high-sounding excuse for their own ambition?"
"Why won't you say his name?"
"Because 'Solomon' isn't his name. That name only defines the surface of him; it can't define his existence. My computational capacity isn't enough to let me say his name; transmitting the data by sound alone would take hundreds of millions of years—we don't have that time. That's one of the things I learned from the Stone. If we had a more efficient mode of communication, you would know what I mean," Vision said. "But back to the point—don't you think Mr. Stark is doing the right thing?"
