Eileen was terrified by the looks on Eva and Brenna but she couldn't help but enjoy the intense way she was being taken by Sterling. Eva rubbed her dildo's tip on Eileen's asshole. She started sweating as Eva's breath was felt on her back. Sterling paused for Eva to enter. "Wait...that feels rough. Please put some lube on it! I've never tried anal." As per her request, Eva tilted her head to the right at Brenna looking for permission.
"You didn't mention anything about lube when you were planning to fuck my sister, didn't you!"
"I only wanted to hurt you. I wasn't actually planning on it."
"You can say that to every ex-boyfriend of our friends you fucked over the years. That's right, you hated us that much, you even went that low!"
"It's just a coincidence...!" Before she could finish, Eva went inside.
"Sorry, I was sick of seeing her fake apologies. Plus, she fucked my ex behind my back." Eva started moving along.
"Ooooh, fuck she's getting tight! Get her good babe!" Sterling moaned as he threw his head back gaining more pleasure as his hips moved subconsciously.
"Babe, are you two together?"
"You didn't know?" Brenna got closer to Eileen's head. "Eva and Sterling are dating! If you were a good girl, I would have let you date my brother. You could have had his dick just for yourself but you decided to play with the fire." Brenna grabbed her head. All four of them were on the bed. Eva and Sterling were on their knees fucking Eileen from the back and front. Brenna yanked her head towards her dildo pressuring her to suck her dildo. "Suck my dick, you filthy piece of shit! If you don't, everyone you wronged will know about your secret relationships."
"Please...!" The moment she opened her mouth Brenna pressed her dildo.
"That feels so good! You know how to blow a dick, bitch! No wonder, your experience shows!"
"Brenna, you do realise she's sucking a plastic, right? You can't feel it!" Sterling said.
"Shut up and fuck her! Why hasn't she cum yet?" Brenna yelled as she skull fucked the girl who made her life hell.
"Babe, I'm having trouble with this position," Eva said as she slowed down a bit.
"I'm going to lie down. Take her in doggy! Bren, let go of her head for a moment." Brenna let go of Eileen. Eileen started gasping for breath but she was pulled in as Sterling leaned back on the bed. Eileen got some balance as she tried to ride him but Eva got back to her ass immediately.
"You thought I was done with. Destroya doesn't stop until you're destroyed!" Eva pulled her ponytail and fucked her ass. Sterling moved his hip into a comfortable position.
"I hate this soooo...much fuck that's the spot, mmmnnn!" Eileen moaned as she enjoyed the sex that she wasn't supposed to.
Brenna was confused. She leaned in closer to Eileen's face and yelled at her. "You hate this, you say! Then why aren't you asking us to stop?" Brenna got angrier. "Answer me, bitch!"
"Bren, she's getting wetter. I think it's turning her on."
"He's right. She's fucking us back. That's new for me. Even you've never done it with me" said Eva.
"I...fucking knew it...you too are fucking...that's why Eva likes you."
"You money laundering slut. You think I like Brenna because she fucks me. That's my future wife. I love that woman. I will do anything for her. You got that into your head." Eva got mad as she increased her speed. "Fuck her skull, babe!" Brenna forgot about her revenge for a moment. She was just happy that Eva finally agreed to their arrangement. With joy-filled eyes, Brenna positioned herself in front of Eileen.
"You heard what my fiancé said! Put your mouth on it, fucking whore!" Eileen started blowing the plastic dick.
Eileen made a disgusted face but she liked having something in her mouth. She liked how she was being treated. It's like for the first time, she's being taken care of instead of doing all the work on her own. Ever since she started having sex, she's been doing anything to make herself feel better by stealing her friend's exes and having private relationships to get her way to the top. She knew who Drew was. She thought sleeping with Drew would make Brenna even madder because she is her aunt but she realised Drew and Brenna weren't that close. So, she started pulling her strings on Catherine. Little did she realise, Catherine was protected by her siblings after her incident with the mysterious god. Here, Eileen found herself being led to have sex with Sterling. In her mind, she wanted to take advantage of the situation and disturb Brenna's peace of mind but it all turned out in Brenna's advantage. Eileen was being taken by all her holes. She finally climaxed. The dicks were pulled out of her as Eileen dropped with a smile.
"Babe, did you cum inside her?" Eva asked.
"You were squeezing her so tight! I felt every thrust of yours."
"Thanks but what if she ends up preggers with all the load you released in her?"
"Fuck, Eileen, is it..?"
"We don't give a shit if it's safe or not!" Brenna lifted the energy-less body of Eileen. "Let's give her a round two! She'd better know what she's going to miss!"
"That wasn't the plan, Bren!" Sterling rested on his elbows behind his back.
"The plan has changed since she likes it. Eva, take her pussy! I'll destroy her ass." Brenna let go of Eileen lay down on the bed and demanded her. "Ride me, bitch!"
Eileen slowly crawled up to her dildo. She was yearning for it because she put it in her ass without any complaints and started riding her in reverse cowgirl. Eva gestured to Sterling that she didn't understand what Brenna wanted. "Eva, her pussy is waiting for you!" Brenna called her best friend. Eva knelt in front of Eileen and grabbed her waist making her pause before entering her vagina. This time, she got a great view of her face.
"Holy shit, I think we broke Eileen." Eva started fucking her pussy. Eileen was taking both dildos with the little experience she had. Sterling was getting a great view of his girls breaking their rival. Suddenly, Eileen started weeping as she extended her arm towards Sterling. "Babe, I think she wants the real deal in her mouth!" Eva said as Sterling moved towards where the action was.
He showed his cock filled with his cum and Eileen's for her to suck it. She grabbed with a disgusted face and pulled him into blowing it. The moment she tasted his cum, she started blowing it while riding the dildos at the same time. "How is she doing this?" Sterling leaned his head backwards. His cock got hard again. "Girls, is it okay if I take her on my own?"
"Only if you take her in her ass!" Brenna tilted her head to her right and winked at her brother. Brenna and Eva backed away as Eileen looked at Sterling with a blush.
"Why are you blushing? You think I'm not going to be as ruthless as these two!"
"Huh...?" Eileen looked at him in horror.
"No one threatens my family!" He yanked her by the hair and put his dick inside her ass. "It's been a while since I've done anal."
"We should do that next time, babe! I've always wanted you in my ass!" Eva said as she stroked her plastic cock. Eva and Brenna sat next to each other on Brenna's sofa. Eva leaned in on Brenna's breasts resting her head. Brenna protectively caressed her hair.
Sterling on the other hand crushed Eileen in a doggy position. She crouched as Sterling put his arms underneath her thighs. "What are you doing?"
"Whatever the fuck I want because that's what you were going to do to Catherine!"
His arms came through her armpits and he grabbed her in a full Nelson. Then he lifted her as she couldn't even move in his pin. Sterling fucked her ass in that position as Eileen's eyes rolled up to her skull.
"You really want to do anal with him, Eva?"
"I'm rethinking about it. It looks hard but Eileen's having fun. It's written all over her face."
"Look at her breasts getting crushed!" Brenna asked Eva.
"I know. I was jealous of her figure back in the day. She made sure that I felt that way. But you, you made me think of how special I am." Eva leaned in to kiss her. Brenna kissed her back.
"It's weird to be all romantic with strap-ons attached around our waists."
"I know, right!" Eva chuckled. "Do you want to go at it?"
"Let's finish what we started. Then we can enjoy our session as an engaged couple, without the strap-on that is, I want to feel your skin on mine as much as possible."
"Fuck, I love you so much!" Eva and Brenna kissed each other on the lips as Sterling released his load inside of Eileen. With her whole body in pain, Eileen was dropped on the bed.
Sterling walked towards the girls and sat next to his girls. "She's out, girls!"
"We broke her good!" Brenna smirked.
"I'm not proud of what we just did!" Sterling sighed. "It's not how I treat people but I did it for you, Bren!"
"Now that I think about it, the revenge plan has changed right?" Eva asked.
"Once she wakes up, we're going to break the ice to her." Brenna got up. "She likes being treated like a bitch. Now we're going to reveal to her that she's never going to have this again. Knowing her, she's never getting this kind of treatment somewhere else." Brenna approached the unconscious Eileen. "Now that she's felt Sterling's cock inside of her, there's no way she will be satisfied with another one."
"I take that as a compliment for my skills!" Sterling said while he was playing with Eva's breasts.
"She will never get the same feeling as today." Brenna smiled as she put her foot next to her feet with her arms crossed.
_________________________
Brenna was waiting for Eileen to wake up in her room. Eva and Sterling left them alone and went downstairs. Drew was waiting for them. "So?" She asked.
"It didn't end up as we thought it would," said Sterling.
"She actually enjoys anal." Eva followed.
"What happened with Hunter?" Sterling asked with concern.
"I'll tell you all about it later. I have some calls to make." Drew walked past them. Sterling could see that Hunter must have said something to upset her.
"Is she going to he alright?" Eva asked.
"Yeah, Eileen is an awful person. Drew deserves someone who cares about her not someone who would take advantage of her for a personal vendetta."
"Okay, then I'll be leaving then!" Eva was about to leave but Sterling grabbed her wrist preventing her from walking away.
"Let's go to the dining table!" Sterling said as they both went to the dining area.
________________
Sterling was sitting at the head of the table. Eva sat next to him. Sterling asked his question. "All of a sudden, you agreed to marry her!" Eva looked down fiddling with her fingers. "Eva, why did you change your mind?" All of a sudden, Eva started crying. Sterling got up and wrapped her unto a hug around his belly. "Hey, I got you! Tell me what's wrong?" Sterling stroked her hair.
"I'm pregnant!" Sterling paused. He tilted her chin up. "It's alright. I'll get it aborted. We don't need too much burden..!" Sterling leaned in to kiss her. After pulling away from it, Sterling smiled at her and said.
"Be honest with me, why did you want to get an abortion?"
"You already have a baby. One more will be too much for you!"
"But you want it, right?" Eva looked away. Sterling tilted her head to look at his gaze. "Tell me the truth!"
"Of course, I want to keep it. It's your fucking baby!" Eva wiped her tears off.
"Hey, you're going to be a great mom! Don't worry! Both of us are loaded enough to keep the baby!"
"But what do we do with my parents?"
"We will talk about it later. Now, let me hold you!" Sterling held her in his arms.
"What are you two doing alone?" Lisa showed up. "I'm not jealous that you spend too much time with my boyfriend." She took a seat opposite them.
"Guess who's going to be a new mom!"
"Holy shit! Really!" Lisa jumped over the table and pulled Eva into a hug. "I'm so happy for you!"
"You are?"
"Why wouldn't I be? We're both mothers of Sterling's kids, the man we love more than anything." She pulled away from the hug. "Sterling, I'm going to steal her for a moment."
"She's all yours, Lisa." Sterling kissed both of them as they left the dining area.
After they left, Sterling pulled his phone out and called someone.
"Hey! Are you busy?"
[I'm promoting a movie but right now, I'm free!]
"So? I heard you broke up with your boyfriend."
[Yeah, I didn't want to force him to be a father for someone else's child.]
"Listen, I was wondering if you could stay with me for a while. I don't want more exposure to our baby!"
[You don't want the baby to get exposed to my popularity?]
"No, I know how the media works. If they connect the dots and come to my family, I don't want the world to know about me and Catherine."
[I am working on something. I'll tell you everything if it turns out well.]
"Are you alright?"
[I'm fine. You know how I am, right?]
"I hope to see you soon, Sydney!"
[Kiss Catherine for me, will you!]
"Sure!" After hanging up, Sterling leaned back in the chair. 'Wow, that was one hell of a day!' He then made his way towards his room.
____________________
Eileen opened her eyes slowly. She rubbed her eyes and looked at her body. She was already dressed. In front of her, Brenna was sitting on her sofa. Eileen looked down. "Was the sex even necessary?" Eileen asked.
"I just got to see you shiver like the bitch you actually are, so, it was worth it."
"What are you going to do with me?"
"My aunt knows about you so you two are already broken up!"
"Figures!"
"You're never to approach anyone in my family, ever again!"
"But..!"
"If you think of contacting or communicating with anyone from my family, I'll expose your crimes to the whole world. Think of what your parents will do if they find out how you were earning your salaries."
"Brenna, I'm sorry!"
"Your sorry doesn't cut off the pain you caused me all those years. I stopped seeing people because of you." Eileen rubbed her arm and nodded her head. "Now, get out of my house!" Eileen picked up her bag and left the room weeping. Brenna looked around the room and got up. She moved onto her bed and took a nap.
___________________
That evening, Sterling knocked on the door to his parents' room. He went inside to see David and Ophelia. "Hi guys!"
"I thought you were on a date with Eva! What happened?" Ophelia asked.
"There is something I need to tell you." Just as Sterling said, Ophelia assumed that he was going to talk about the two of them. She raised her eyebrows to signal Sterling. He didn't understand what she was implying so he continued. "Eva is pregnant." Ophelia sighed. David looked at her confused.
"Come on, kid! You're old enough to know about protective sex!"
"Says the guy who got me pregnant three times when he was not even old enough to drink!" Ophelia remarked.
"Well, like father like son, I guess!" David smiled while Ophelia chuckled to herself.
"We will support you, Sterling! Not that you may need any!"
"That's not the bigger issue. Eva has been active with me and Brenna."
"What?" David exclaimed. "Did you know about this?"
"Brenna told me she was fooling around with Eva way before Sterling returned. She just couldn't stop."
Sterling and Ophelia explained the situation to David avoiding the incestuous aspects. "So, Eva's parents are coming. And you want us to convince them to let their daughter get married to Brenna because of your particular relationship with the others. Did I get that right?" David resumed the issue. "I knew polygamy would get you into trouble but I trust you to make it work."
"David, our son solved all our issues. We can do this for him, right?" Ophelia supported Sterling's request.
"Is Brenna okay with it?" David asked.
"Yes. She says she's cool as long as it's Eva."
"If all the parties involved are consenting to it, I'll convince Eva's dad!"
"What about her mom?" Ophelia asked.
"That's up to you, Ophelia! That woman makes me nervous. I feel like walking on thin ice every time she starts talking."
"Come to think of it, I've never met Eva's mom!" Sterling looked up thinking.
"Too bad, kid! I hope we have more time to prepare for them."
"About that!" Sterling agitated a little with his shoulders. "They're coming tomorrow! Bye guys!" He ran away after alerting his parents.
"My kids will be the end of me!" David sighed and went to sleep.
"You have no idea!" Ophelia pulled the sheet and went to sleep too.