Rod Meyer glanced at the kid sitting beside him, who was visibly trembling, his legs jittering against the floor like he was about to be executed. Rod chuckled softly and turned his attention back to the screen. Warner Bros. had pushed the hype to astronomical levels, but in Rod's opinion, it was still just a superhero movie. Even a masterful filmmaker like Christopher Nolan couldn't escape the genre's inherent limitations.
[Batman Begins] had certainly been a massive leap forward compared to earlier Batman adaptations. The direction was gritty and sophisticated, with a tone far more grounded in realism. But despite its merits, Rod had found some plot points difficult to digest. At times, the story leaned heavily into comic book logic, veering away from the grounded world Nolan seemed intent on building.
And now, with the sequel, Warner Bros. had pulled out all the stops in their marketing campaign. The Joker's identity had been kept under wraps for months, sparking endless speculation online. Rod figured it was a calculated gimmick. Most likely, the studio had cast a relatively unknown actor and, realizing they couldn't sell a face people didn't recognize, leaned into the mystery. "Who is the Joker?" became a global talking point.
But Rod doubted the strategy would last. Once the audience saw the face behind the mask, the mystique would vanish. If the actor delivered even half as good a performance as Jack Nicholson did, he might become a household name. Especially if he had a skilled publicist to back him up, but that would be that. It won't do the film a lot of good.
The film began with the infamous bank robbery scene—the same one that had already been leaked online, not through YouTube or official channels, but via piracy sites scattered across the internet. Still, watching it unfold in full IMAX was something else entirely. The scale, the sound, the immersive clarity—it turned a familiar scene into something electric.
On screen, a group of masked robbers executed a coordinated assault on a Gotham bank. One by one, they began killing each other, each believing it was part of the plan. The tension built with each betrayal until only one man remained. The last thief was still wearing his clown mask as he approached the waiting getaway bus, calm and unhurried.
"You think you're smart, huh?" the wounded bank manager rasped from the floor, blood trickling down his chin. "The guy who hired you will do the same thing to you."
The masked man halted and turned. There was something almost casual about the way he strolled back to the dying man, like a predator confident that his prey posed no threat.
"The criminals in this town used to believe in something," the manager coughed. "What do you believe in, huh?"
Without answering, the figure crouched down and stuffed a smoke grenade into the manager's mouth. Then, in a slow, deliberate voice, he said, "I believe... what doesn't kill you simply makes you—"
He pulled off his mask.
"—stranger."
Gasps echoed throughout the theater.
The Joker had been revealed. Though many online had guessed it, seeing it confirmed in such a dramatic fashion sent a jolt through the audience.
The face was unforgettable. The white greasepaint was smeared unevenly, clinging to the contours of the man's face and revealing the skin beneath in ghostly patches. His lipstick extended far beyond his lips, trailing up into the deep scars carved into both cheeks. Around his eyes, black makeup formed smudged rings that gave his stare a hollow, almost inhuman intensity. His eyes looked like voids, barely visible within the darkened sockets.
His hair was a dull green—not neon or cartoony, but washed-out, greasy, and unkempt. His suit, too, was purple, but the shade was muted and grimy. Nothing about him sparkled. And yet, it was impossible to look away. This Joker didn't need a flashy costume to stand out.
Rod felt a chill crawl up his spine as the Joker's grotesque grin filled the massive IMAX screen. It wasn't just a performance. It was something else entirely.
And then he was gone.
The Joker boarded the school bus and drove out through the shattered front of the bank, blending seamlessly into the stream of identical yellow buses on the street. Within seconds, the chaos he'd left behind was swallowed up by the everyday noise of city traffic. Multiple police cars sped past, entirely unaware of the criminal slipping away in plain sight.
Rod sat still, stunned. Whatever thoughts he had about this being "just" a comic book movie were gone. That opening scene had completely shifted his expectations. It was bold, gripping, and smartly executed. The murmur of awe and excitement around him suggested the rest of the audience felt the same.
"The wait was so worth it!" the boy beside him exclaimed, practically bouncing in his seat. From what Rod had overheard earlier, the kid had won his ticket through a promotional contest. "Joker is so menacing."
"Keep quiet, Austin!" the girl on the boy's other side whispered sharply.
Rod let out a small chuckle at their exchange, but it quickly faded. The film had already pulled him back in. Even without the Joker onscreen, the narrative held strong. Batman was shown continuing his unofficial crusade against crime in Gotham. But now, there were others trying to follow in his footsteps, ordinary citizens dressing up like him and attempting to fight criminals. One of them even used a gun.
Rod shook his head slightly. That wasn't Batman. That wasn't what he stood for. Batman didn't kill. It was one of the core tenets of his character, the rule that separated him from the very criminals he hunted.
Would the Joker push him to break that rule? In the first [Batman] movie, Jack Nicholson's Joker ultimately died at the end. Would this version meet the same fate?
Then Harvey Dent appeared on screen, and Rod sat forward a little. He was the other major figure Warner Bros. had highlighted during the film's press tour. Onscreen, Dent was everything Gotham needed: charismatic, determined, and idealistic. He wasn't a typical politician chasing power or preserving his own status. He genuinely seemed to care.
He was the kind of man it was impossible to dislike.
And then came the line that made Rod pause completely.
"You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain."
Rod blinked. For a moment, he didn't even hear the next line of dialogue. That sentence echoed in his head like a slow bell. To most people, it might have passed by as a clever bit of writing. But for Rod, it was something else. It was true. Uncomfortably so.
People once revered inevitably became targets of public resentment if they stuck around long enough. Heroes were only appreciated while they were needed. After that, they were blamed for everything that went wrong. Why didn't they fix it all? Why weren't they perfect?
Because no one can be.
Rod reached into his pocket, pulled out a small notepad, and scribbled the line down before it could slip away from memory.
The movie moved on, and so did Rod's thoughts, returning once more to the Joker. He was back onscreen now, this time in full view. The camera lingered on his face long enough for Rod to study every inch of it.
Still, he couldn't recognize the actor. The man behind the makeup didn't resemble anyone familiar, at least not among the seasoned stars Rod could recall. That all but confirmed his suspicion: this Joker wasn't a major Hollywood name. Probably someone from the theater world. Someone trained but obscure.
And then the tension in the scene escalated.
"Give me one good reason why I shouldn't have my boy pull your head off," a mob boss growled, glaring across the table.
The Joker didn't flinch. In fact, he leaned forward, eyes wide and gleaming with chaotic energy.
"How about a magic trick?"
The madness in his voice matched the look in his eyes. It wasn't theatrical. It wasn't over-the-top. It was real. Disturbingly real. There was no hesitation, no forced menace. This man wasn't acting evil. He simply was.
To drive his point home, the Joker pulled a pencil from his coat and slammed it into the table, the sharp end sticking upright.
"I'm gonna make this pencil disappear," he said with a smile that was too wide, too pleased with itself.
As one of the henchmen lunged at him, the Joker grabbed the man by the back of the head and slammed it down on the pencil with brutal force.
"Ta-da! It's… gone."
Gasps and shrieks rang out across the theater. Several audience members recoiled, covering their eyes or turning away. The violence had been so sudden, so unexpected, that it sent a jolt through the room. But Rod couldn't look away. He was frozen.
It wasn't the act or the impact that shook him. It was what came after. The Joker looked around the room of stunned criminals with casual amusement, like he was daring someone else to try something. His expression didn't say, Don't mess with me. It said, Please do. I'm bored.
In that moment, Rod realized something profound. It no longer mattered who the actor was. This performance was so compelling, so iconic, that he would forever be remembered as the Joker. The role transcended the film itself. And the fact that it was part of a massive studio production made it all the more impressive.
"It's simple. We kill the Batman," the Joker declared blandly when asked about his plan.
"If it's so simple, why haven't you done it already?" one of the mobsters challenged.
The Joker stopped and turned his head sharply. "If you're good at something, never do it for free."
For a brief second, all the affectations dropped. His clownish persona, the slouched posture, the exaggerated tics, they all paused just long enough to let the meaning of the line land. He still maintained his strange, slurred accent, but the way he delivered that sentence was crystal clear. It wasn't just a line of dialogue. It was a lesson.
Rod felt it immediately. It was one of those truths that hit harder coming from an unexpected place. Even if spoken by a villain, it made sense. Especially in a world like theirs, in a country where everything had a price tag. He fumbled for his notepad again and jotted it down, doing his best in the dim theater light.
Every time the Joker appeared, the screen seemed to bend around him. His presence was magnetic. It was impossible to focus on anything else. For a split second, Rod thought he recognized the actor's face—something vaguely familiar—but he dismissed it just as quickly. Probably his imagination trying to make sense of the unknown.
As the story moved on, Batman was in Hong Kong now, on a covert mission to retrieve Mr. Lau, the corrupt financier allied with Gotham's criminal elite and, by extension, the Joker. Rod was impressed at how quickly the story moved, never losing momentum.
Back in Gotham, one of the local crime bosses had had enough. He put out a bounty on the Joker: dead or alive.
And someone seemed to take him up on it and was actually successful, only for it to turn out to be Joker's bluff all along.
"Wanna know how I got these scars?" he asked, licking his lips slowly, his tongue flicking out like a snake. He looked off to the side, almost wistfully, as if remembering something, before focusing back on his prey. "My father… was a drinker. And one night, he goes off crazier than usual. Mommy gets the kitchen knife to defend herself. He doesn't like that. Not. One. Bit."
Rod's gut twisted. For a moment, he actually felt something close to pity. A brutal childhood, a violent father—these were familiar stories in the real world, and they left lasting damage. But any sympathy he felt vanished instantly when the Joker killed the man without hesitation. Just a clean, efficient murder.
Then he stepped over the body without a second glance.
There was no remorse. No satisfaction. No hesitation.
Rod sat back, silent. He searched for some kind of logic behind the Joker's actions, some trace of motive. But there was none. It was all chaos. Unpredictable, unrelenting, and terrifying.
And somehow, watching it unfold was deeply satisfying.
In the minutes that followed, the Joker was absent from the screen, but not from Rod's mind. Even as Batman infiltrated Lau's secure high-rise in Hong Kong and extracted him without a trace, even as Lau gave up the names of hundreds of criminals in one fell swoop, flooding the justice system in a single stroke, Rod's focus remained fixed on one question:
What would the Joker do next?
And then, without warning, came the answer.
A man's body was discovered hanging outside the Mayor's office window. Dressed in a cheap imitation of Batman's suit and smeared with the Joker's grotesque makeup, the corpse swayed with the wind in full view of the horrified public. As if that weren't enough, the Joker had also released a recording—a homemade video that revealed the victim's final moments.
The camera footage was shaky, filmed with a handheld device. The lens focused on the trembling figure of a man in the Batman costume, tied to a chair, breathing heavily.
"Tell me your name," the Joker's voice said from offscreen, calm but unmistakably threatening.
"Brian Douglas," the man answered. His voice was hollow, his spirit already broken.
"Are you the real Batman? No? Then why are you dressed up like him?" The Joker's tone was mocking, playful on the surface, but laced with menace beneath.
Brian's entire body trembled. His hands were clenched, and his legs twitched involuntarily. Rod didn't need to guess—this wasn't acting. The fear on screen was too real. Whatever that actor saw while filming with the Joker must have shaken him to his core.
"H-he is a symbol," Brian stammered. "That we don't have to be afraid of scum like you."
There was a beat of silence.
"But you are afraid of me, Brian," the Joker said, almost gleefully, before moving closer. His gloved hands grabbed Brian's face and head, shaking him gently at first, then more forcefully, like a child toying with a broken doll.
Brian kept his eyes shut tight, frozen in fear.
"Look at me," the Joker said lightly, almost like a coaxing parent.
Brian didn't budge.
"LOOK AT ME!" the Joker roared suddenly, his voice booming through the grainy recording.
Brian opened his eyes—slowly, reluctantly—and when he did, his expression was filled with a haunting mixture of hatred and helplessness. He was staring into the face of chaos itself.
The camera turned, now focused on the Joker's painted face.
"This is how crazy Batman's made Gotham," he said, addressing the viewer directly. "You want order in Gotham? Batman must take off his mask and turn himself in."
He paused, letting the silence stretch.
"Oh, and every day he doesn't… people will die. Starting tonight. I'm a man of my word."
Then came the laugh—that sickening, broken cackle that started low and grew higher, more unhinged with each second.
In the background, Brian's bloodcurdling screams echoed, growing louder until the video abruptly cut to black.
Rod shuddered in his seat. He had to consciously remind himself: it was just a movie. The Joker wasn't real. He was just a character. A masterfully portrayed one—but fiction all the same.
He glanced around the theater. The unease in the room was almost physical. The audience had been captivated into silence, many of them frozen just like him. It was one of those rare moments when an actor's performance was so convincing, so complete, that the line between role and reality blurred.
The film continued. The scene changed to Bruce Wayne hosting a lavish fundraiser for Harvey Dent.
Rod welcomed the change of pace. The lighting was brighter now. Bruce made a dramatic entrance, stepping out of a helicopter accompanied by three glamorous women, each dressed in designer evening wear. Inside the event, champagne flowed and guests mingled under soft lighting and glittering chandeliers.
For a brief moment, it felt like the story might finally catch its breath.
But peace never lasted long in Gotham.
News broke that the Joker had issued a new threat, this time targeting three high-profile figures: the police commissioner, the judge who had just convicted hundreds of criminals in a single ruling, and Harvey Dent himself, the city's rising star and supposed white knight.
Rod's stomach sank. The storm was far from over.
And then, it happened. Swift and brutal.
Commissioner Loeb was poisoned in his own office. Judge Surillo's car exploded as she started the ignition. And as chaos unfolded across Gotham, the Joker crashed Bruce Wayne's party, his men in tow, to target Harvey Dent directly.
The tension shot through the roof when Bruce, thinking fast, placed Harvey in a chokehold and dragged him away, locking him inside a supply closet to keep him out of harm's way.
Meanwhile, the Joker took control of the party.
He moved through the guests like a predator stalking prey, stopping in front of one person, then another, performing random, unsettling gestures. He grabbed a drink. He sniffed someone's hair. He leaned in too close to whisper nonsense. Each movement seemed improvised, unpredictable, chaotic.
Rod sat forward in his seat, mesmerized.
The brilliance of the performance was undeniable. It wasn't just the script—it was the raw tension in the room. If Rod had to guess, even the extras on set weren't given cues. Their flinches looked too real, their terror too genuine. This wasn't acting. It was reaction.
"STOP!"
________________________
AN: Visit my personal website to read ahead, or check out my second Hollywood story set in the 80s.
Link: www(dot)fablefic(dot)com