Chapter 24: The Breaking — Frodo's Departure
The river divided the world in two.
Cedric stood on the western bank, watching the small figures on the eastern shore disappear into the trees. Frodo and Sam, heading east toward Mordor, toward shadow, toward a destiny that would determine whether everything else mattered at all.
[KINSLAYER'S INSIGHT: RANGE LIMIT — EXCEEDED]
[FRODO — MARK FADING]
[SAM — MARK FADING]
The system notation flickered as the distance grew. The Morgul-marks over the Hobbits' hearts dimmed in Cedric's perception, fading from sharp-bright to distant embers to nothing at all. They had passed beyond his range, beyond his influence, beyond the Pact's immediate reach.
They're going to Mordor, Cedric thought. Just the two of them. Carrying the burden that should break them.
And I'm staying here, with a tooth in my crown and a wounded man who knows more than he should.
"Let them go."
Aragorn's voice came from behind him, quiet but certain. The future king stood with his hand on his sword-hilt, watching the eastern shore with eyes that held grief and acceptance in equal measure.
"The Ring-bearer has chosen his path. We cannot follow it for him."
"I know." The words came easily enough. "I'm not suggesting we try."
Aragorn nodded, then turned away toward where Boromir lay on a makeshift stretcher of cloaks and branches. Legolas and Gimli knelt beside him, the Elf's hands working to stabilize the arrows while the Dwarf held the wounded man's hand with surprising gentleness.
Four of us now, Cedric thought. Plus a wounded man who can't travel fast. And somewhere out there, the Uruk-hai are taking Merry and Pippin toward Isengard.
The Three Hunters become four.
He followed Aragorn back to the stretcher.
Boromir was conscious but feverish.
The three arrows remained in his body — removing them required tools and time they didn't have — but the bleeding had been slowed with pressure and field dressings. His face was grey, his lips pale, but his eyes tracked Cedric as the Ranger knelt beside him.
"The Hobbits," Boromir whispered. "Merry and Pippin—"
"Captured," Cedric said. "We'll get them back."
"And Frodo?"
"Gone. He and Sam crossed the river. They're heading for Mordor."
Something flickered across Boromir's face — shame, perhaps, or grief, or the particular agony of a man who had betrayed someone he was sworn to protect. His hand found Cedric's wrist again, the grip weaker than before but still desperate.
"I tried to take it." The words came in broken fragments. "The Ring. I tried to take it from him. I couldn't... I couldn't stop myself. The voice, it whispered, it promised—"
"I know."
"You don't." Boromir's eyes burned with fever-bright intensity. "You don't know what it's like. To feel something else wearing your will. To watch your hands reach for something you know you shouldn't want and be unable to stop them."
I know exactly what that's like, Cedric thought. But I can't tell you that.
"The Ring corrupts everyone eventually," he said instead. "You're not the first it's broken. You won't be the last."
"But I should have been stronger." A tear tracked down Boromir's cheek. "Gondor needed me to be stronger. My father, my brother, my people—"
"You fought for the Hobbits after you fell. You stood against the Uruk-hai when you could barely stand at all. That matters."
The words were meant as comfort. They landed like accusations.
Because you were strong, Cedric thought. And I let you be wounded anyway.
He reached for the athelas supply in his pack, finding the last few leaves remaining. The healing herb wouldn't close the wounds, but it would ease the fever, slow the bleeding, buy time until they could get Boromir to proper help.
"This will hurt," Cedric warned.
He crushed the athelas and pressed it against the wound in Boromir's shoulder. The Gondorian's back arched, a cry escaping through clenched teeth, but the color returned to his face almost immediately. The herb worked as it always had — King's Foil, the healing plant that only true descendants of Númenor could unlock.
Aragorn should be doing this, Cedric thought. The Hands of the King are the hands of a healer.
But Aragorn was organizing the pursuit, his mind already turning toward the captured Hobbits. So Cedric worked in silence, binding wounds that he could have prevented entirely if he had chosen differently.
The Betrayal Mark burned cold against his chest the entire time.
Gimli stood over Boromir's stretcher with his axe in his hands.
The Dwarf's expression was fierce, protective — the loyalty of someone who had decided that this person would not die today, whatever the cost. His Morgul-mark glowed with steady, stone-deep light, unchanged by the chaos of the morning.
"He'll live," Gimli said. Not a question.
"If we can get him to help in time." Cedric finished the last of the bandaging and sat back. "The arrows need to come out properly. Infected wounds in the wild will kill him as surely as the Uruk blades would have."
"Then we find help. Rohan is close. The Rohirrim have healers."
"Rohan is also where the Uruk-hai are taking Merry and Pippin." Aragorn approached, his face set with determination. "We cannot go in two directions at once."
The problem was obvious. Four of them — three able-bodied, one wounded. One path led toward the captured Hobbits, fast pursuit through difficult terrain. The other led toward healers and safety for Boromir.
In the canon, Cedric thought, this choice didn't exist. Boromir died at Amon Hen. The Three Hunters pursued the Uruk-hai without him.
But I changed that. And now we have to deal with the consequences.
"I'll take Boromir to Rohan."
The words left his mouth before he fully processed them. Aragorn's eyes snapped to his face, surprise flickering before the Ranger's discipline smoothed it away.
"You would abandon the pursuit?"
"Someone has to." Cedric met his kinsman's gaze steadily. "You three are faster without a wounded man. And Boromir won't survive a hard run across the plains."
The logic was sound. But that wasn't why he was offering.
I can't face Merry and Pippin yet, he realized. Not with the tooth in my crown. Not with the Mark on my chest. Not when every look at them will remind me of what I let happen.
I need time. Time to understand what I've become. Time to decide what happens next.
Aragorn studied him for a long moment. Then he nodded.
"Find Éomer's riders if you can. The Third Marshal patrols these lands. He will help you."
"I know."
They clasped arms — the Ranger's grip, the gesture of trust between kinsmen. Aragorn's five-point Morgul-mark blazed in Cedric's vision, unchanged, undiminished. The future king didn't know what his kinsman had done. Didn't know about the tooth, or the Mark, or the half-measure that had earned them.
How long before he finds out? Cedric wondered. How long before Boromir's fever-dreams reveal the truth?
The question had no answer. Not yet.
They separated as the sun climbed toward noon.
Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli ran west, following the Uruk-hai trail with the speed that would become legendary. The Three Hunters, racing against time to save the Hobbits before Saruman could work his will.
Cedric moved slower, one hand on Boromir's stretcher, the wounded man's weight dragging at every step. The path toward Rohan was longer but gentler, following the edge of the forest before descending into the plains.
Different paths, Cedric thought. Different consequences.
But all of them lead back to the same place eventually.
He glanced east, where Frodo and Sam had vanished into the Wild. The Ring was going to Mordor. The Quest would continue, with or without the Fellowship that had begun it.
Then he looked down at Boromir.
The Gondorian was unconscious now, his breathing shallow but steady. The arrows still protruded from his body, the wounds still seeped, but the athelas had bought them time. Maybe enough time. Maybe.
I saved your life, Cedric thought. But I broke your trust doing it.
And sooner or later, you're going to understand that.
The Betrayal Mark pulsed cold against his chest, and the Crown tooth pressed against his brow, and Cedric walked toward Rohan with the evidence of his compromise bleeding on the stretcher beside him.
Behind him, the Falls of Rauros roared into the distance — the sound of a river that had witnessed the breaking of a Fellowship and would carry that knowledge toward the sea.
Ahead, the plains stretched toward a kingdom of horses and warriors, where a king slept under a wizard's spell and a nephew waited for news of a war that had already begun.
The Fellowship of the Ring was ten no longer.
It was fragments now, scattered across a continent, each carrying their own burden toward whatever ending awaited.
And Cedric walked among the fragments, wearing a tooth he had earned by betraying a friend, carrying the man whose trust he had shattered while trying to save him.
Estel, Galadriel had said.
Hope and warning both.
He still didn't know which one he had chosen.
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic