Chapter 1: Winter's Choice
The royal procession wound through Winterfell's gates like a golden snake, banners snapping in the cold wind. Ned Stark watched from the battlements as King Robert's wheelhouse rolled across the cobblestones below, its Baratheon stag flying beside the crowned lion of House Lannister. The sight turned his stomach.
Fourteen years since Robert's Rebellion ended, and still the same players dance their deadly game.
"Father?" Robb's voice cut through his brooding. "The king wishes to speak with you. Privately."
Ned nodded, his weathered hands gripping the stone merlon. Below, he could see his children lined up in the courtyard—Sansa curtseying perfectly, Arya fidgeting beside her, little Rickon hiding behind Robb's legs. And there, standing slightly apart as always, was Jon Snow. The boy's bastard status never more apparent than when royalty came calling.
"Tell His Grace I'll meet him in the crypts," Ned said quietly.
"The crypts, my lord?"
"He'll know why."
The descent into Winterfell's heart felt longer than usual. Stone steps worn smooth by generations of Starks led down into torch-lit darkness, where the carved faces of his ancestors watched with sightless eyes. Each step carried weight—the weight of history, of promises made in blood and tower rooms, of secrets that could topple kingdoms.
Robert waited before Lyanna's tomb, already deep in his cups despite the early hour. Wine had not been kind to the king; his once-powerful frame had grown soft, his black hair shot through with grey. But his eyes, when they fixed on Lyanna's stone face, still held the pain of a young man who'd lost everything that mattered.
"She was so beautiful," Robert whispered, his words echoing off ancient stone. "Even carved in granite, she's more beautiful than any woman I've known since."
Ned said nothing. He'd learned long ago that Robert's grief was a fire that burned everything it touched.
"Jon Arryn is dead, Ned." Robert's voice cracked like breaking ice. "My Hand, my father in all but blood. Found him in his chambers three days ago, fever and chills, the maesters said. But I know better."
"Robert—"
"Poisoned." The king's fist slammed against Lyanna's tomb. "Had to be. Jon was strong as a bull, and he was investigating..." Robert's voice trailed off, his eyes darting toward the shadows. "There are things you don't know, Ned. Things about my children. About Cersei."
The torchlight flickered, casting dancing shadows across Robert's ravaged face. Ned felt the familiar chill of the crypts seep into his bones, but it was nothing compared to the ice that formed in his stomach.
"What things?"
"Jon was reading about bloodlines. Baratheon bloodlines going back three hundred years. Every Baratheon child born with black hair, Ned. Every one. Yet my golden-haired children..." Robert laughed bitterly. "Even I'm not blind enough to miss that anymore."
Gods preserve us. If Robert suspected what Ned already knew to be true—that Joffrey, Myrcella, and Tommen were bastards born of incest between Cersei and her twin brother—the realm would burn.
"I need you, Ned." Robert turned from the tomb, his blue eyes desperate. "I need the one man in this world I can trust absolutely. Come to King's Landing. Be my Hand. Help me uncover the truth about Jon's death, about my children, about this nest of vipers that's taken over my throne."
The request hung between them like a blade. Ned stared at his sister's carved features, remembering another plea made in a tower room filled with roses and blood. Promise me, Ned. Lyanna's voice seemed to whisper from the stone itself.
If I go south, I leave Jon unprotected. If Robert learns the boy's true parentage...
"The capital is poison, Robert. It killed Jon Arryn, and it will kill anyone who threatens the wrong people."
"All the more reason I need you!"
"And all the more reason I cannot come."
Robert's face darkened. "Cannot? Or will not?"
Ned turned from Lyanna's tomb to face his king—his friend—his brother in all but blood. "I will not watch another good man die for asking dangerous questions. I will not leave my family defenseless while I chase shadows in the Red Keep. And I will not risk my children's lives for the sake of your crown."
"Your duty—"
"My duty is to my family first. To the North first." The words came out harder than Ned intended. "You have brothers, Robert. Stannis is rigid as iron, but he's honest. Honorable. He could serve as your Hand."
Robert's face purpled with rage and hurt. "Stannis? That joyless, friendless man who speaks to me like I'm a wayward child? I need someone I trust, Ned!"
"You need someone alive." Ned softened his voice. "Robert, listen to me. If Jon Arryn was murdered for what he discovered, then the people responsible are still at court. They're watching. Waiting. Anyone who gets too close to the truth..."
"So you'd leave me to face them alone?"
"I'd leave you to face them with your brother. With the might of Dragonstone behind you. With a man who can't be bought, seduced, or intimidated." Ned placed a hand on Robert's shoulder. "Stannis may be stern, but he's your blood. He'll protect your interests even if he disapproves of your methods."
For a moment, Robert looked ready to strike him. Then the fight drained out of the king like wine from a broken cask.
"I came here hoping to relive our youth," Robert said quietly. "Instead, I find my closest friend won't even answer his king's call."
"You find a friend who values your life more than your commands."
Robert stared at him for a long moment, then stumbled toward the stairs. "Have it your way, Stark. Stay in your frozen wasteland. But don't expect me to understand."
Ned watched him go, listening to the king's heavy footsteps echo through the crypts until silence returned. Then he was alone with the dead, with their stone eyes and their eternal judgment.
I've refused my king. The magnitude of it threatened to overwhelm him. But as he looked at Lyanna's face one more time, he felt something like peace settle in his chest.
Some choices are worth the consequences.
The solar felt warm after the crypt's chill. Ned poured himself wine—good Northern vintage that burned away the taste of fear. Through the tall windows, he could see the royal party preparing for departure. Robert's fury had been magnificent; horses and men scrambling to ready themselves for an immediate return south.
The door opened without a knock. Catelyn entered, her face tight with concern and barely controlled panic.
"Tell me you haven't just destroyed our family," she said without preamble.
Ned set down his cup and turned to face his wife. Cat's auburn hair caught the firelight, and he could see the intelligence in her eyes working through possibilities, consequences, political ramifications.
"I've saved it."
"Saved it? Ned, you've just refused the king's summons. You've insulted Robert before his entire court. The Lannisters will use this—"
"The Lannisters would have used my presence in King's Landing far more effectively." He moved to the window, watching the chaos in the courtyard below. "Jon Arryn is dead, Cat. Murdered, I'm certain of it. And Robert knows things that make him dangerous to the wrong people."
"What things?"
Ned was quiet for a long moment. Outside, he could see Jon Snow helping to load supplies onto a wagon, the boy's bastard status ensuring he was assigned the most menial tasks even during royal visits. Ghost padded alongside him, the direwolf's red eyes seeming to watch everything.
He needs to know. They all need to know, or at least... she needs to know.
"Sit down, Cat."
"Ned, you're frightening me."
"Sit. Please."
She settled into the chair across from his desk, her back straight, hands folded. The posture she always adopted when preparing for bad news.
"There are things I've kept from you," Ned began slowly. "Secrets I swore to take to my grave. But if we're to survive what's coming, if our family is to be whole..."
"What secrets?"
Ned met her eyes directly. "Jon Snow is not my bastard son."
The words hung in the air like smoke. Cat's face went through several expressions—confusion, disbelief, something that might have been hope, then a dawning horror.
"Whose then?"
"My sister's."
The silence stretched long enough for the fire to pop and settle. When Cat spoke again, her voice was barely a whisper.
"Lyanna?"
"She loved Prince Rhaegar Targaryen. Willingly. She went with him to that tower in Dorne, and there she bore his son. She died making me promise to protect the boy, to raise him as my own, to never let Robert know the truth."
Cat's face had gone white. Her hands gripped the arms of her chair so tightly her knuckles showed bone-pale.
"For fourteen years," she whispered, "I've hated that boy. For fourteen years, I've resented him, been cold to him, made him feel unwelcome in his own home. And he was... he was..."
"Your nephew by marriage. Lyanna's son. The last living child of House Targaryen."
The words broke something inside Cat. She doubled over as if struck, a keening sound escaping her throat.
"Oh gods, Ned. Oh gods, what have I done? That poor boy, I've been so cruel—"
"You didn't know."
"I should have been kinder! Bastard or not, he was a child, and I—" She looked up at him with tears streaming down her face. "Why tell me now? Why after all these years?"
Ned moved around the desk, kneeling beside her chair. "Because I'm going to legitimize him."
"What?"
"Tomorrow, before the Old Gods, I'm going to name Jon Stark my trueborn son. Give him all the rights and privileges thereof. Make him Robb's brother in law as well as love."
"But his true parentage—"
"Remains secret. As far as the world knows, Jon Snow was my bastard, and now Jon Stark is my legitimized son. Nothing more."
Cat stared at him. "The Targaryens... if anyone discovers..."
"Then we'll face that when it comes. But Cat, that boy has lived fourteen years believing himself a bastard. Believing himself unwanted. He's served this family faithfully, loved us despite how he's been treated. He deserves to know he belongs here."
"And if Robert returns? If he demands answers?"
"Robert has his own problems now. And besides," Ned's mouth quirked in something not quite a smile, "what king troubles himself over a northern lord's bastard legitimization? Especially when that king is facing potential civil war."
Cat was quiet for a long time, working through the implications. Finally, she wiped her eyes and straightened.
"When will you tell him?"
"Tonight."
"The other children?"
"They'll know he's legitimized. The rest... perhaps someday. When they're older. When the world is safer."
Cat nodded slowly. "I'll need to... I should speak with him. After. To apologize. To try to..."
"He'll appreciate that. Jon has a forgiving heart."
"Too forgiving, perhaps." She stood, smoothing her skirts. "I should prepare the children for what's to happen tomorrow. This will change everything, you know."
"I know."
"Theon especially will struggle with this."
Ned nodded grimly. The Greyjoy boy's position as ward was precarious enough without watching a bastard elevated above him.
"We'll manage it."
"Will we? Ned, you've set so many wheels in motion today. Refusing Robert, legitimizing Jon... are you certain we're prepared for the consequences?"
Ned returned to the window. The royal party was nearly ready to depart. He could see Robert's massive form atop his destrier, the king's face still dark with fury.
"No. But I'm certain the alternative was worse."
Night fell early in the North, even in late summer. Ned sat in his solar as darkness settled over Winterfell, nursing a cup of wine and watching the flames dance in the hearth. He'd eaten supper with his family—a strained affair with Robert's absence hanging over them like a stormcloud. The children had sensed something significant approaching, whispering among themselves when they thought no one noticed.
A soft knock interrupted his brooding.
"Enter."
Jon Snow stepped into the solar, Ghost padding silently behind him. The boy looked nervous, his dark hair falling across grey eyes that held too much wariness for someone barely seventeen.
"You sent for me, my lord?"
My lord. Even now, even in private, Jon maintained the formal distance that bastard status demanded. It cut Ned's heart every time.
"Sit, Jon. Please."
Jon settled into the chair across from the desk—the same chair Cat had occupied hours earlier. Ghost curled up beside him, red eyes reflecting the firelight.
Ned poured a second cup of wine, sliding it across the polished wood. Jon stared at it in surprise.
"I'm not sure I should—"
"Tonight, I think you should." Ned raised his own cup. "We need to talk. About important things. About truth."
Jon's hand trembled slightly as he lifted the wine. "Have I done something wrong? If this is about the incident in the training yard yesterday, I can explain—"
"This isn't about punishment, Jon. It's about... family. About who you are."
"I know who I am."
The quiet dignity in that statement nearly undid Ned's composure. No, you don't. You have no idea.
"Do you remember your mother?"
Jon's face shuttered immediately. "You said you'd tell me about her someday."
"Someday is tonight."
Silence fell between them. Ghost whined softly, as if sensing the tension. Jon's knuckles were white around his wine cup.
"She was my sister," Ned said quietly.
Jon blinked. "Your... what?"
"Lyanna Stark. My younger sister. She was beautiful, willful, full of fire. She could ride like a centaur and fight like a wildcat when roused. You have her eyes, did you know that? Grey as a winter storm."
"I don't understand."
Ned leaned back in his chair, the weight of fourteen years pressing down on him. "The official story of Robert's Rebellion says Prince Rhaegar Targaryen kidnapped and raped Lyanna. That she died in a tower in Dorne, alone and afraid."
"Yes, I know the story."
"It's a lie."
Jon's cup clattered against the desk. Wine spilled across the wood like blood.
"Lyanna loved Rhaegar. Went with him willingly. They were married in secret, before the Old Gods and the new. And in a tower room filled with blue roses, she bore him a son."
The boy's face had gone ashen. "No."
"When I found her, she was dying from childbed fever. The wet nurses were dead, the guards fled. Just Howland Reed and myself, and a baby crying in his mother's arms."
"No, that's not... I'm your bastard. You told me—"
"I told you what I had to tell you to keep you alive!" The words came out harsher than Ned intended. He forced his voice to soften. "Jon, if Robert had learned that Rhaegar's son survived, he would have killed you without hesitation. You've seen his hatred for anything Targaryen."
Jon was shaking his head, over and over. "This isn't real. You're not... why would you..."
"She made me promise," Ned continued relentlessly. "Lyanna. My sister. Your mother. 'Promise me, Ned,' she said. 'Promise me you'll protect him. Raise him as your own. Let him grow strong and good and true.'"
"I'm not... I can't be..."
"You are Jon Sand, born of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen. You are ice and fire both, wolf and dragon. You are the last living son of the Dragon Prince, and you are my nephew."
The words hit Jon like physical blows. He doubled over, wine cup forgotten, hands gripping his hair.
"That's not... I'm nobody. I'm Jon Snow, bastard of Winterfell. I'm nothing."
"You are everything." Ned stood, moving around the desk. "You are the son Lyanna died to protect. You are the boy I've raised and loved as my own. You are Robb's brother, Arya's protector, the finest young man I've ever known."
"But I'm a Targaryen."
"You're a Stark." Ned gripped Jon's shoulders, forcing the boy to look at him. "Blood doesn't determine who you are, Jon. Choice does. Actions do. You've chosen to be honorable, loyal, protective of those weaker than yourself. You've chosen to be a Stark in every way that matters."
Tears were streaming down Jon's face now. "Why tell me? Why now?"
"Because tomorrow, before the Old Gods who see all, I'm going to legitimize you. Make you Jon Stark, trueborn son, with all the rights and privileges thereof. And I wanted you to know the full truth before you take our name."
Jon stared at him in shock. "Legitimized?"
"You've earned it a hundred times over. Your birth may have been complicated, but your heart, your character—those are pure Stark."
"What about Robb? His inheritance—"
"Remains his. You're the elder, yes, but I'm naming Robb my heir. You'll serve as his brother, his advisor, his strong right hand. As you've always done."
Jon was quiet for a long time, processing. Ghost padded over and pressed against his master's legs, offering wordless comfort.
"Does anyone else know?"
"Your aunt Cat knows about the legitimization. Howland Reed knows everything—he was at the Tower of Joy. Others... there are hints, suspicions, but no proof. And it must stay that way."
"The other children?"
"Someday. When they're older. When the world is safer for Targaryens."
Jon nodded slowly. Then, to Ned's surprise, he laughed—a broken sound halfway between joy and hysteria.
"All my life, I've wondered why I was different. Why I felt like I belonged here but never quite fit. Why I dreamed of dragons sometimes."
"And now?"
Jon met his eyes—Lyanna's eyes—and Ned saw strength there, acceptance, the quiet courage that had always marked him.
"Now I know I belong here because you chose to make it so. Because Lyanna Stark chose to trust you with her son's life. Because sometimes love matters more than blood."
"And tomorrow?"
"Tomorrow I become Jon Stark." He paused. "But I'm already your son in every way that matters."
Ned pulled him into an embrace, feeling fourteen years of guilt and fear finally begin to ease. Outside, Ghost threw back his head and howled—a sound that echoed across Winterfell like a herald of change.
The boy who had entered this room as Jon Snow would leave it as something more. Not just a Stark, not just a Targaryen, but the bridge between ice and fire, between the old world and whatever was coming.
Promise me, Ned.
"I promise," he whispered to the night. "I promise."
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0